Originally Posted by
NYCommuter
I was given the bag back very quickly, just after boarding started, and we stored it under the seat in front of us. Problem resolved. Post #2 was very helpful.
You omitted this extremely relevant fact that changes the situation drastically, giving you even less of a leg to stand on in a complaint. Seeing as how your initial post complained about poor FA service, and then you followed up with a reference to the "FA's Power Trip", I stand by my initial response. Post #2 wasn't "helpful" -- it agreed with your worldview based on incomplete information.
As for your statement that you never disagreed with the FA, of course you did.
"one of my traveling companion's bags was taken from her "because it won't fit on the plane"
And then you insisted it did fit on the plane.
Several have now agreed with me that you left out information, and that you clearly were trying to make a point that the FA was wrong and disagreed with you.
It is not trolling to make substantive criticism of a post someone makes on a discussion forum. You are not entitled to post about a situation and have no one disagree with the way you conducted yourself in it. Classic labeling of "trolling" when someone says something you disagree with. When lots of people agree that you were in the wrong for expecting to be able to deplane and then comparing it to an inapt situation, please refrain from accusing someone of being a troll.