In that case, you're better off taking a cheap MR for that $200 and earning the miles that way.

Best thing to do is always avoid "direct" flights when traveling, as you get screwed on the miles.

I still have yet to see how a flight can be a "direct" flight when an equipment change or different plane is used for the onward leg. That's a connection, not a "stop." I know AA's not the only one that does it, but it's a crappy industry trick.