Originally Posted by
JDiver
... A frequent flyer stops flying. The account cancels. The miles and record of lifetime miles disappear.
...
In our case the miles disappeared (as they should). The account was still there. The record of the lifetime miles on US was still there.
And you still haven't offered your opinion of the asymmetry between someone whose miles on US had expired and someone whose miles on AA had expired.
Originally Posted by
JDiver
...
You rant on FlyerTalk, call everyone who disagrees with you wrong, apologists, whatever. Water under the bridge. No change. It is what it is, not what you want it to be.
I'm not sure who you are addressing here, but the poster you quoted was giving their first post on this subject. Maybe I'm ranting. I don't think sethb or I called anyone any names.
But flyertalk is an appropriate place to praise goodness, fairness, justice and the American way.