Originally Posted by flieder

I'm not saying that we did not deserve the first ticket. And, we did pay it as soon as we received it. It was somewhere rural 1-2 hours from Rome from speeding. I believe we were going 110 kmh on a 90 kmh road. No problem there, as we knew we did speed and paid the fine which was about 200 euros.

The confusion comes in with the first letter as it was not clear that they required us to send the information along with the payment. The letter is in English, so I expected it to mean what it says. Which says send the reply form if you do not pay the fine.

This mistake on behalf of them should not cause me to pay additional 300 euros. I was just asking if anyone had to deal with similar situation and what sound advise they can give.

As it stands, I'm planning to write them an email (which they provided on the letter) and explain the mistake and see if they are reasonable.