robvberg, the rules clearly state that off topic threads will be closed or moved. The post you point out has nothing to do with "Discussion of the latest frequent flyer program buzz... " The discussion would be just as useful to you had you found it under 'TravelBuzz', which is probably where it belongs. It is not useful for people looking for breaking news about miles and points programs.

I think the point is that if we follow the guidelines, there will be no reason to close or move threads. Simple.