Originally Posted by
tuphat
Maybe I'm not thinking about this correctly, but: with a $5.95 fee per card, seems like this is a push under best circumstances. Even purchasing with a 5% card wouldn't fully cover fee plus liquidation cost, so the benefit seems to lie solely in the 40 cents per gallon off (per $100 card). So you save $8 on a 20 gallon fill-up?
It's really the combo benefit of 4x fuel points, 5% back card, and $5 coupon that makes this worth while.