FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Safety in China
Thread: Safety in China
View Single Post
Old Jun 8, 2013 | 11:14 pm
  #15  
jiejie
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Southeast USA
Programs: various
Posts: 6,710
Originally Posted by trueblu
I understand the conflicting situation you are in. And it may be appropriate to ask on an IBB whether Wuhan, in general, is a safe city or not. I've not been, but I believe it is safe from accounts of my students etc. from there.

But really, asking sanction from a bunch of internet strangers about to whom to entrust your child? And your anecdote might say your son is clever and resourceful, or just has a nasty streak -- not meaning to judge -- but it's impossible to say from your related anecdote, and since I will likely never meet him, that will always be the case.

It's ultimately your call. But I would say this: you have chosen to leave your son with his Chinese relatives, but repeatedly, you come on here complaining about them. This tells me some deep underlying issues that you have, which we can't solve. Legally speaking (I think, I'm no lawyer), when someone is in loco parentis, as your son's guardians are, their sayso should trump everything shouldn't it? They are ultimately responsible for your son whilst you are the absentee parent. If they don't feel comfortable, is it really ethical, just and fair to tell them to 'shove it' and entrust your son (and their beloved nephew) to what to them (justified or not) is a stranger??

By the way, the 'amazing China experience' you want your son to have is probably to learn about real Chinese culture -- and that will come far more by living with real Chinese people, not rock climbing or taking photos with a Nikon or some other branded digital camera. And since the guide will speak English, how will it improve your son's Chinese language skills?

I don't mean to have a go, but I really don't understand what you are trying to achieve by asking us, complete strangers, with regards to your son's safety.

tb
Dailey, I have to say that I agree with everything trueblu is very eloquently saying here.

Additional context provided notwithstanding, there is definitely something incongruent by putting your son's relatives in charge of his welfare while you're on the other side of the planet, yet then proposing something that they can't buy into but leaves them on the ultimate hook for responsibility in the (unlikely) event something happens to him. I suppose if this prospective guide can gain their confidence and trust in baby steps, then you and relatives will end on the same page and your son will end up not bored. Although frankly, his potential boredom doesn't seem that it should be the main driver of the resolution, if any.

While I'm reasonably comfortable in saying that Wuhan isn't any more or less dangerous than most other large cities (and in fact, I find Wuhan natives wherever I meet them in China to be some of the nicest and most helpful around), I'm uncomfortable in making any judgment on what you should do on this.
jiejie is offline