plenty of positive thoughts here:
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/luxur...-new-york.html

and here with report of a recent stay:
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/luxur...roperty-4.html

and dozens of more threads...just do a search. My specific views on my last stay are in the second link.

Perhaps you're itching to tell us a story of a bad experience there? We're used to that sort of thing here. As you know if you'e here often, in this forum you'll find complaints about the RC-NYCP, FS-GV, the Amans, you name it! It doesnt hurt anyone's feelings nor will it on its own dissuade me/anyone from thinking less of the hotels we've logged dozens of stays in.

So if that's the case....you may fire when ready.