Rented recently on the ES.
Selection: 2 Nissan Rogue's -- one with a massive dent in the roof. Each of them looked fairly beat up as well. VW CC that looked really nice, but I had to have 5 passenger capacity and there is a center console in the back.
The Silver Maxima was there, middle of back seat does not look comfortable though so I skipped.
Buick LaCrosse with less than 1500 miles. Nicely equipped but my initial reaction was negative because it was a Buick. Ended up taking it because EA just had a bunch of Malibus, Altima's etc.
Buick was a nice ride with leather, seat heaters (a must in Hawaii
) and all the bells and whistles. Drove nice and was impressive. Not my fathers Buick.
By the way, when you rent you have to go to the Emerald Booth in the lot to get your key once you have identified the car you want. Not a 'pure' Emerald Isle location.