Musken ... thanks for your excellent trip report and additional comments and perceptions. Like you, I very much enjoyed Amanpulo and can't say enough about the service, beaches, etc..
I was recently also reviewing your Amanpuri / Trisara review thread and was curious what your take is on Amanpuri vs pulo? Obviously totally different in terms of venues, but from the perspective of the accommodations, food, service, beach, etc... if you have some time and wouldn't mind writing up your thoughts, we'd love to hear it.