I have been following these posts for a while. First, I want to say kudos to Randy for stepping in and being involved in the decision. Second, I want to say that while Ozstamps may have a longer history of alleged infractions here, Johnfpage's actions have been called into question on many, many occasions on Coupon Connection.

Searching Coupon Connection bares that out. (No need to search other threads. JFP only posted on CC). Many people were concerned that JFP was trying to turn CC into his own personal business of buying and selling certificates (including receiving "gifted" certificates that he would later sell). JFP essentially admitted that he was running a business, revealing that he kept a computer spreadsheet of his transactions.

While nobody ever claimed that JFP reneged on any exchanges, many considered his actions to damage the spirit of CC, which was once a place where people more often "gifted" items and less often "sold" them.

I know that Ozstamps has rubbed plenty of people the wrong way. I take no position on that. But the integrity of Flyertalk, including the CC board, should be formost, and we should not lose sight of trying to maintain that integrity. Maybe CC will begin to return to what it once was: A place where generousity starts to outstrip profiteering once again.