I have seen a number of posts on the external handle on the BR. Some say it is more difficult to fit in overheads, and the space is a consideration.

I was able to get my hands on the BR Baseline bags today. They are well made, but they do not seem to be as well made as Tumi. Tumi just seems more durable, but without the warranty to back it.

Tough choices! I need the luggage before Oct 14th. This may come down to whichever I can find on sale. They are both great choices. I am going to stay away from Travelpro for now, thank you all very much for the advice.