It's not all about the stars! I have a number of reviews to post up around Xmas, but for me it's the experience in the hotel vs. the price.
On my last big trip the Ibis in Wellington stood out as a great (4*) hotel, thought it only has a 2* rating. It's clean, the showers are good, bed comfy. The food is fine, it's in a good location and the staff are great.
I always read the "poor" reviews for a good laugh - sometimes they are useful, othertimes........