Originally Posted by
spiffed
Have traveled J 2 return routes in past 2 months on Silver and never been OP-upped to F even tho the plane was empty
I called up the EK office and spoke to them about Gold benefits as i am going to achieve it in 15 days and why I should stick to EK over 9W as 9w offers upgrade vouchers to Plat members and the office desk told me I can ask for a complimentary upgrade at the check-in if there are seats available...

wonder if its true or if she was just telling me this to get me off the phone.
What do you mean by "the plane was empty"? If the class you booked in was empty, you will not receive an op-up.
Op-ups typically happen, when the class you travel is overbooked and the higher class has spare seats. Don't forget that Gold card holders are preferred over Silver card holders.