Originally Posted by
CMK10
I can't tell you how it compares. However, I can tell you that I always take my Dad and he's a New York 5-star restaurant snob and he likes it. Therefore, it must be pretty good

Well that is good enough for me. Every time I get together with my Dad, we go to a steakhouse.
This is one of my best memories as a kid, I guess I was sixteen at the time. I tagged along one of his trips to NY and he took me to a new steakhouse every night for a four days. We went to Sparks, The Palm, Peter Luger, and Smith & Wollensky (when there was just one or two). It was a few days of gluttony, but one is able to really form an opinion when they are done back to back.
Peter Luger was and is my favorite.
However, on my last trip to NYC. I went to Quality Meat which was good, and I loved the sides. The sides were quite imaginative . I thought that the creamed spinach yorkshire pudding was excellent.