Originally Posted by
TSORon
The objective of posting the article was to show that Behavior Detection has some scientific backing. That there is a basis in science for Behavior Detection. Its not voodoo, not magic, but it is also not completely proven (or even close). The same can be said for psychology, astrophysics, and a few other areas where one can get a post-graduate degree. Behavior Detection is mostly psychology, which may very well be voodoo but I have seen it used effectively around the world.
You can always find someone out there who will poo-poo what someone else claims (Flat Earth-ers, Moon Landing, Area 51), someone out there believes that “Math” is not an exact science. Go figure. It does not matter how old the article is, nor how the professor is reimbursed or not reimbursed for his time with the TSA, but if it provides a “value add” to the TSA and its mission. Obviously the TSA thinks so, but Behavior Detection has its limitations and the TSA knows this. It cant tell you if someone is a terrorist. Sorry, not going to happen. It CAN tell you if someone is displaying the signs of deception in an unconscious way. What happens from there is up to the BDO and the other part of their training.
(disclaimer: I am not a BDO, nor do I have the training as one, but I find the concepts of their job fascinating)
I think most of are objecting not to the science itself, but to the way how it is being used to harrass innocent people.
I think most of us believe in the subject of psychology, but strongly object when it it becomes a tool of harrassment and oppression in the form of BDOs in airports.
Let me give a more extreme example: psychiatry. Few would dispute its value. But in the USSR it was used as tool to suppress any form of free thought. For instance, people who believed in God were often declared insane and locked up in mental institutions where they were "treated" with powerful mind-altering drugs.
OTOH, I have not seen either mathematics or astrophysics used in this manner. BTW, I have a Ph.D. in both physics and math.
I think I made my point.