I know what you are trying to say and I agree with you on most of it. I guess everyone is basing their feedback on what they have experienced.

I had to fly them a few months back as that was the only decent option I got at that time. It was on a 777 and my TV screen would not stay up and was fixed with duct tape (what is their fascination with this stuff???) The seat was broken and when I asked for a beer I was told that there were none chilled and it would take some time.

The worst part was that the toilet smelled like a local train toilet. Ok there was no cra*on the walls but why can't they just maintain the toilets. Does the shi* stink more as its from a Indian person. Nope! Its just a lack of proper cleaning.

Yeah I would fly them again as I feel that they have improved in the last few years but only when my first three choice are not available.