Bumping this to see if there are any fresh recommendations.
It will be for a *very* special occasion, for drinking in the late evening (10pm-ish).
Budget is around $250. I am thinking of something a bit sweet, but not cloying. Dom was "too nutty" for her. Cristal has high marks but seems a bit cliche.
Currently looking at a Veuve Clicquot Rare Vintage Rose '85, and after reading this thread am thinking about Billecart Salmon Rose as well, although that doesn't have quite the "wow" factor I am looking for.
Krug rose seems to be out of my price range. Bollinger R.D. is described frequently as "yeasty" which isn't what I am looking for either.
Her favorite standard champagne is Veuve Yellow Label if that helps. My favorite for frequent drinking is Charles Heidseck Brut reserve. Although her tastes are more important than mine, especially in this instance.
Thanks for any and all recommendations :-). I will be purchasing now for drinking in 3-6 months. I am located in SF Bay Area if people have a favorite local merchant for pickup, otherwise I can receive shipments.
edit: Just wanted to note that I am not specifically looking for a Rose, it just happens that a Rose is in the top slot right now