I believe JohnG was just reacting to your replies. You asked the pros for their opinion and when it wasn't going your way, you kept on saying that what may work for others may not necessarly work for you. I agree with JohnG although I will take the word stupid out of the equation. I've read many of JohnG's posts, replies and I could tell you that while he could have chosen a different word, he did not mean to insult you. Still, you kept on insisting that your plan will somehow benefit you. Can you explain how? You said that you don't fly enough to make the middle tier on any one airline, that you basically just made the basic status on one. All the other miles came from other sources. That's great, but again, why waste the possibility to get comped in the future? If you only fly 2-3 times a year, what is the other status going to do for you? other then put a shiny card in your wallet. Sorry, that's how I'm reading this thread and I'm sure others see it the same way.
You should learn how to relax. You asked a question and many experts here gave you their honest opinion. Take it or leave it, but please spare us from your little temper tantrums.