Having sailed on Carnival a few times now, I'll have to disagree with the Walmart statement. Ive been on two different extreams of the fleet, from a fantasy class (albeit one that has had her evolution of fun) to a Conquest class ship. So far to this point I have no complaints about Carnival, granted nothing is perfect, I have seen unfreindly crew and some meals that were not perfect, but all in all great vacations.

I will however say that I have never been on a holiday class ship and nor do I plan on going on one. The holiday is an old ship anyway you look at it and if I am not mistaken her retirement is not too far around the corner.

Allready well into planing my next cruse, with carnival again. In the future I can see switching to Princess, Holland Amercia, Cunard or who knows maybe even Seaborn. However for us at the moment, Carnival fits very well into our lifestile, a great ballence between price and quality. I forsee having a Platinum Sail and Sign card in the resaonable future.

I would like to try RC and or Celebrity, espcially the chance to experence the Oasis of the Seas. NCL would be an option aswell espcially once the F3 class gets going.