This is what drove me crazy with it - option 2 should work, but I couldn't get it to do.
Originally Posted by
nmenaker
I'm on option 2, with a router, works fine.
I do NOT have direct access to the modem through the network, but it has never been required unless I am troubleshooting which is like once every four years. (I could of course easily set this up with the tomato software but don't even bother)
I think either of the 2, or 3 will work fine with a router. 1 is not the one you want.