Beijing & Shanghai: 3-night cities, or 4-night cities?
#31
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: San Diego
Programs: Fly UA MM 1K, Sleep Hyatt & IHG, Hertzer. 2022 Flyertalk Fantasy Football Champion
Posts: 11,197
Thanks for the Info!
My wife and I will be making our first trip to Asia this summer - 4 days in Japan and 4 days in Beijing. We'll be in Beijing Aug 7th-11th and I was also wondering if there was enough to fill up the schedule. I can't believe that I can actually read part of that schedule
#32
Join Date: Jan 2000
Posts: 3,208
If you don't care for nightlife, I think Beijing is the better place to visit in terms of allocation of days. On the other hand, if you decide that you want to visit Hangzhou or nearby towns then the advantage goes to Shanghai. In both cities, however, you can easily spend 3-5 days staying busy during the day (although Beijing is a better place).
Personally, if you want adventure and have the budget, then I would add a few more days to the itinerary and go somewhere else to get a better feel for the country. China's West(ern frontier) is as big as America's (which director Zhang Yimou has used effectively in his movies), and there are some great world-class/UNESCO places to visit in the two "autonomous" minority regions of Tibet and Xinjiang (think Lhasa and Kashgar, respectively) where you can easily occupy a week or more (but 3 days is also do-able if you time your connections). That's where I would spend my money on a side trip. Flight/train connections are improving, so it no longer takes days to get to these areas. On the other hand, this also means that it isn't so hard for China's frontier to be settled by "outsiders". Go now before these regions lose their uniqueness.
I think Hangzhou and Nanjing are frequently mentioned because they are near Shanghai by road or train, but they are not on my top ten list. If you have the budget to fly around (although domestic airfares are frequently discounted, they have not reached the level that LCCs have conditioned the customer to expect in Malaysia, Europe and parts of the USA), then the options open up dramatically.
Personally, if you want adventure and have the budget, then I would add a few more days to the itinerary and go somewhere else to get a better feel for the country. China's West(ern frontier) is as big as America's (which director Zhang Yimou has used effectively in his movies), and there are some great world-class/UNESCO places to visit in the two "autonomous" minority regions of Tibet and Xinjiang (think Lhasa and Kashgar, respectively) where you can easily occupy a week or more (but 3 days is also do-able if you time your connections). That's where I would spend my money on a side trip. Flight/train connections are improving, so it no longer takes days to get to these areas. On the other hand, this also means that it isn't so hard for China's frontier to be settled by "outsiders". Go now before these regions lose their uniqueness.
I think Hangzhou and Nanjing are frequently mentioned because they are near Shanghai by road or train, but they are not on my top ten list. If you have the budget to fly around (although domestic airfares are frequently discounted, they have not reached the level that LCCs have conditioned the customer to expect in Malaysia, Europe and parts of the USA), then the options open up dramatically.
Last edited by fallinasleep; Jul 10, 2005 at 9:42 am
#33
Join Date: Oct 2004
Programs: UA 1K, SPG Plat
Posts: 384
adding to Moondog's list,
pegasus: Alot of hip-hop music, and if you like trendy hot asians in rockstar (hot) outfits, theres plenty here.
Rojam: Trancy place, with lasers & everything. Has a small hip-hop room.
XingTianDi: Alot of bars at this district, and alot of live bands playing. Not too much dancing, just grab a table, and watch the live bands play... with sheet music ;o.
MBox: Near zapatas, but not as expatish.
Theres so many trendy clubs/bars in SH that I could go on & on, its best to just go & check 'em out.
pegasus: Alot of hip-hop music, and if you like trendy hot asians in rockstar (hot) outfits, theres plenty here.
Rojam: Trancy place, with lasers & everything. Has a small hip-hop room.
XingTianDi: Alot of bars at this district, and alot of live bands playing. Not too much dancing, just grab a table, and watch the live bands play... with sheet music ;o.
MBox: Near zapatas, but not as expatish.
Theres so many trendy clubs/bars in SH that I could go on & on, its best to just go & check 'em out.
#34
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Shanghai
Posts: 42,039
Originally Posted by shazbot
adding to Moondog's list,
pegasus: Alot of hip-hop music, and if you like trendy hot asians in rockstar (hot) outfits, theres plenty here.
pegasus: Alot of hip-hop music, and if you like trendy hot asians in rockstar (hot) outfits, theres plenty here.
Rojam: Trancy place, with lasers & everything. Has a small hip-hop room.
MBox: Near zapatas, but not as expatish.
#35
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Shanghai
Posts: 42,039
Originally Posted by fallinasleep
Personally, if you want adventure and have the budget, then I would add a few more days to the itinerary and go somewhere else to get a better feel for the country. China's West(ern frontier) is as big as America's
#36
Join Date: Jan 2000
Posts: 3,208
Originally Posted by moondog
I agree that there's a lot to see and do out west. The problem is that most people that request advice here have limited vacation time and don't make it to China very often. Therefore, I usually encourage people to get their fill of the big cities on their first trip and then do something more adventerous the next time around.
My interpretation of the OP's initial request for information was that he had the time and the inclination to get off the beaten track, especially as his interests were in art, history and architecture and not necessarily the latest trendy clubs and bars in Shanghai.
There are so many threads on Shanghai and Beijing on Flyertalk (and the information isn't going to get stale anytime soon), wouldn't it be nice to talk about some other destinations for a change?
#37
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: LAX, HKG
Programs: AA EXPLT, BA Gold, Shang Elite
Posts: 2,228
tier 2
to me tier 2 would include hangzhou, xian, guilin, kunming
maybe dunhuang, lhasa, suzhou, chengdu area, lijiang, xinjiang area, etc.
hangzhou clearly stands out among tier 2, (a clear top 3 on par with BJ and SH....10 years ago i would have put hangzhou in front of shanghai!) in terms of sightseeing and culture. IMHO Nanjing is not that special, and i would place NJ near the end of the above list.
maybe dunhuang, lhasa, suzhou, chengdu area, lijiang, xinjiang area, etc.
hangzhou clearly stands out among tier 2, (a clear top 3 on par with BJ and SH....10 years ago i would have put hangzhou in front of shanghai!) in terms of sightseeing and culture. IMHO Nanjing is not that special, and i would place NJ near the end of the above list.
Last edited by pegasus8228; Jul 10, 2005 at 6:05 pm
#38
Join Date: Oct 2004
Programs: UA 1K, SPG Plat
Posts: 384
Originally Posted by moondog
only popular on thursdays and increasingly annoying crowd
only mondays and with a group; otherwise, waste of time
where is there in mbox near zapata's? (i only know of mao ming rd, but i think i may have seen one on tongren rd last month)
only mondays and with a group; otherwise, waste of time
where is there in mbox near zapata's? (i only know of mao ming rd, but i think i may have seen one on tongren rd last month)
Rojam is always fun, although I'm a bit leary of the chinese E scene. I hear its big though.
Mbox is like a 10m walk from zapatas, in the direction away from mural. Its at this big intersection, and on the 5th floor of this building. Kinda hard to see.
#39
Join Date: Oct 2004
Programs: UA 1K, SPG Plat
Posts: 384
Originally Posted by moondog
I agree that there's a lot to see and do out west. The problem is that most people that request advice here have limited vacation time and don't make it to China very often. Therefore, I usually encourage people to get their fill of the big cities on their first trip and then do something more adventerous the next time around.
#40
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: NYC
Posts: 1,093
I just don't see the appeal of Shanghai to a western visitor. Yes it's a great place to make money and have parties. But for a first time vistor to China with limited time, how can Shanghai be preferrable to Hangzhou and Xi'an? It's like coming to New York and only visit the Chinatown.
#41
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: LAX, HKG
Programs: AA EXPLT, BA Gold, Shang Elite
Posts: 2,228
mntblue, i agree. but you do see the front edge of china's modernization in shanghai, and where the new china is going... that is why i suggested only 2 night for SHA.
lujiazui (pudong -- the new zone) has the most amazing group of new glass pane architecture in the world, from a green field 12 years ago.
imagine the canary wharf (or century) x 50, clustering with no building older than 12 years in between.
lujiazui (pudong -- the new zone) has the most amazing group of new glass pane architecture in the world, from a green field 12 years ago.
imagine the canary wharf (or century) x 50, clustering with no building older than 12 years in between.
Last edited by pegasus8228; Jul 11, 2005 at 11:27 am
#42
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Shanghai
Posts: 42,039
Originally Posted by pegasus8228
lujiazui (pudong -- the new zone) has the most amazing group of new glass pane architecture in the world, from a green field 12 years ago.
imagine the canary wharf (or century) x 50, clustering with no building older than 12 years in between.
imagine the canary wharf (or century) x 50, clustering with no building older than 12 years in between.
#43
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Omaha
Programs: UA/*A nobody, Bonvoy Plat, SW A-list, Hertz 5* (but who isn't???)
Posts: 677
Originally Posted by pegasus8228
but you do see the front edge of china's modernization in shanghai, and where the new china is going... that is why i suggested only 2 night for SHA.