FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Travel Technology (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/travel-technology-169/)
-   -   SIM card question (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/travel-technology/348657-sim-card-question.html)

sfolawyer Aug 23, 2004 12:40 pm

SIM card question
 
I'm still new at this, so I hope this is not a dumb question. I use Verizon here in the states (CDMA). I've bought a second, unlocked GSM phone to use in Europe. I'm going to buy local SIM cards there. It occurs to me that I might get a pre-paid SIM card here, with a small amount of minutes, so that I can use the phone right away for emergencies until I get the local SIM card.

Any suggestion on which carrier would be best to buy a US-based SIM card here on a pre-paid basis for this purpose?

ewrfox Aug 23, 2004 12:48 pm


Originally Posted by sfolawyer
I'm still new at this, so I hope this is not a dumb question. I use Verizon here in the states (CDMA). I've bought a second, unlocked GSM phone to use in Europe. I'm going to buy local SIM cards there. It occurs to me that I might get a pre-paid SIM card here, with a small amount of minutes, so that I can use the phone right away for emergencies until I get the local SIM card.

Any suggestion on which carrier would be best to buy a US-based SIM card here on a pre-paid basis for this purpose?

Your choice is Att Cingular and T-mobile... It depends on how the carrier is in your area.... Here in NYC area ATT seems to be the right way to go.... (If you want GSM service, otherwise Verizon is better)

I think* T-mobile is better in the SFO part....

pdhenry Aug 23, 2004 12:52 pm

I can't directly answer your question, except to point out that US prepaid plans generally require adding time/$ every 30-90 days to keep the invested time alive.

KVS Aug 23, 2004 12:55 pm


Originally Posted by sfolawyer
Any suggestion on which carrier would be best to buy a US-based SIM card here on a pre-paid basis for this purpose?

Most, if not all, North American GSM operators do not provide any international roaming capabilities to the users of their pre-paid services...

ScottC Aug 23, 2004 12:55 pm

All operators in the US have the same problem; expiring call credit.

You'll need to keep adding money every 90 days or so or the credit will expire.

FLYDCA Aug 23, 2004 5:17 pm


Originally Posted by KVS
Most, if not all, North American GSM operators do not provide any international roaming capabilities to the users of their pre-paid services...

Not a single US based pre-paid GSM provider allows International roaming that I know of. You can however buy pre-paid sims before your trip at this web site:
http://www.telestial.com

Dino2020 Aug 23, 2004 6:03 pm

O2 in the Uk do pre paid sims with credit that doesn't expire as long as you make or receive a call once every couple of months, they work anywhere in the world and are very cheap, you can normally buy them for £1 on line direct from the website.

I checked out that website above and oh my god!! $40 dollars for a card that are nealry given away

Link to there website where you can find out the charges for calls in a specific country

http://travelabroad.o2-uktech.com/coverage.php?n=b

Dino

nmenaker Aug 23, 2004 7:48 pm

best thins is the buy before leavgin
 

Originally Posted by sfolawyer
I'm still new at this, so I hope this is not a dumb question. I use Verizon here in the states (CDMA). I've bought a second, unlocked GSM phone to use in Europe. I'm going to buy local SIM cards there. It occurs to me that I might get a pre-paid SIM card here, with a small amount of minutes, so that I can use the phone right away for emergencies until I get the local SIM card.

Any suggestion on which carrier would be best to buy a US-based SIM card here on a pre-paid basis for this purpose?


From an in country providor. Like Virgin, t-mobile, etc.

There are companies that will sell online, or go with an ebay seller. Find osmeone with mnay cards, and ask them for one of each once you win an auction.

no us providors do interneational at all

Xyzzy Aug 24, 2004 8:58 am


Originally Posted by sfolawyer
It occurs to me that I might get a pre-paid SIM card here, with a small amount of minutes, so that I can use the phone right away for emergencies until I get the local SIM card.

You should be able to purchase a SIM card at the airport upon arrival. They are MUCH more readily available in Europe than in the US. If you tell us where you are arriving I'm sure someone here can even tell you where in the airport to find such a shop!

UAVirgin Aug 24, 2004 1:47 pm

Having just returned from London with my unlocked GSM phone I can tell you that my US T-Mobile prepaid card did not work in the UK. I quickly found a stationary store and purchased a Virgin Mobile pre-paid SIM. Unlike purchasing a prepaid card in the US; there were no forms to fill out, ID to produce, or credit card to be given.

pdhenry Aug 24, 2004 1:50 pm


Originally Posted by UAVirgin
I quickly found a stationary store and purchased a Virgin Mobile pre-paid SIM.

What was the cost, and how many minutes were included? Is Virgin Mobile 1800MHz only? (My phone uses 900 MHz overseas).

ScottC Aug 24, 2004 1:51 pm


Originally Posted by UAVirgin
Unlike purchasing a prepaid card in the US; there were no forms to fill out, ID to produce, or credit card to be given.

You don't need this in the US either.

They ASK for a name and DOB but that is only for your own account security. You can give them any name and DOB you want, as long as you remember it.

You do not need ID or a CC to get a US (T-mobile) prepaid sim.

ScottC Aug 24, 2004 1:54 pm


Originally Posted by pdhenry
What was the cost, and how many minutes were included? Is Virgin Mobile 1800MHz only? (My phone uses 900 MHz overseas).

Virgin mobile sim is GBP10 with GBP5 call credit.

Virgin is a virtual operator on the One2One network so it's fully GSM1800.

You can buy a starter kit with Nokia phone for just GBP40 or with a colour Motorola for just GBP50.

ewrfox Aug 24, 2004 2:21 pm

Are you talking about Virgin USA, because it clearly is CDMA... It would've been nice if they offered GSM service here in the States, then it will be easy for people from UK to use their Virgin Services while in the States....

GadgetFreak Aug 25, 2004 1:13 am


Originally Posted by FLYDCA
Not a single US based pre-paid GSM provider allows International roaming that I know of. You can however buy pre-paid sims before your trip at this web site:
http://www.telestial.com

Prepaid SIMS are terribly easy to find in Europe and some will let you roam here. As Dino2020 pointed out, the prices charged by this web site are in my opinion, bordering on obscene. Check out the web sites for companies like Virgin Mobile, Vodafone and Orange to see how cheap these cards are if you buy them in the country you are travelling to.

UAVirgin Aug 25, 2004 8:04 pm


Originally Posted by pdhenry
What was the cost, and how many minutes were included? Is Virgin Mobile 1800MHz only? (My phone uses 900 MHz overseas).

Looks like ScottC answered your questions re price, etc. I've got a tri-mode phone so just had to manually switch it to the non US freq. Adding minutes - topping-up - was so easy... just find a store that has the top-up logo posted on their door/window, hand them your E Top-Up Card and tell them how much you want to add and its done.

UAVirgin Aug 25, 2004 8:07 pm


Originally Posted by ScottC
You don't need this in the US either.

They ASK for a name and DOB but that is only for your own account security. You can give them any name and DOB you want, as long as you remember it.

You do not need ID or a CC to get a US (T-mobile) prepaid sim.

T-Mobile wouldn't sell me a prepaid SIM in the US unless I signed over my first born, it was truly obnoxious. They wanted Name, address, DOB, and a credit card (not just for the purchase). Maybe it was just some newbie sales clerk or something...

ScottC Aug 25, 2004 8:11 pm


Originally Posted by UAVirgin
T-Mobile wouldn't sell me a prepaid SIM in the US unless I signed over my first born, it was truly obnoxious. They wanted Name, address, DOB, and a credit card (not just for the purchase). Maybe it was just some newbie sales clerk or something...

Has to be, cause I've purchased several and they just hand them over, the name and dob was even optional...

GadgetFreak Aug 25, 2004 8:27 pm


Originally Posted by ScottC
Has to be, cause I've purchased several and they just hand them over, the name and dob was even optional...

I bought one for myy wife to test out TMobile a couple weeks ago. No credit card or anything. I just gave them a name and 50 bucks as I recall.

ewrfox Aug 25, 2004 8:30 pm


Originally Posted by ScottC
Has to be, cause I've purchased several and they just hand them over, the name and dob was even optional...

At my local cell place I got a $40 T-mobile card with 120 mins which includes new activation... I just wanted to see if my phone was really unlocked, even though I was 99.9% sure it was... Oh well, I can switch cards around now on my AT&T Phone...

Btw can a T-mobile Sim from US work on T-mobile UK?

Edit: I wasn't even asked for my name or anything for that matter... Lol

ScottC Aug 25, 2004 8:33 pm


Originally Posted by ewrfox
Btw can a T-mobile Sim from US work on T-mobile UK?

No. There is NO roaming with a T-mobile USA prepaid sim anywhere.

ewrfox Aug 25, 2004 8:36 pm


Originally Posted by ScottC
No. There is NO roaming with a T-mobile USA prepaid sim anywhere.

Damn! How about with any other provider? No right?

cnk Aug 26, 2004 2:36 am

Mobal?
 
Anyone have any experience with a company called Mobal?

http://www.mobalrental.com/

Looks like if you have a GSM phone which works in Europe, you can buy a SIM card for $19 and then pay just for the calls you make/receive. While the rates aren't nearly as good as pre-paid cards purchased in other countries, it seems like a good alternative for somebody who doesn't expect to make a lot of calls but wants the option available and for people who might be in multiple foreign countries and not want to have to buy prepaid cards in each place.

Any thoughts on this?

cnk

GUWonder Aug 26, 2004 4:19 am


Originally Posted by UAVirgin
T-Mobile wouldn't sell me a prepaid SIM in the US unless I signed over my first born, it was truly obnoxious. They wanted Name, address, DOB, and a credit card (not just for the purchase). Maybe it was just some newbie sales clerk or something...

My experience is the same as Scott's. There is no "verification" and nothing to prevent one from claiming to be Donald Duck who was born yesterday (or maybe 18 years ago just not to run afoul of some kind of fine print that may or may not be there).

Where did you try buying it?

The T-mobile UK pre-paid is good in many places worldwide although you pay high roaming fees too. There are some Lichtenstein-based and Monaco-based pre-paid SIMs that are great if you want cheap incoming and wish to globally roam on the same number. Of course in-country SIMs have free incoming in many countries of the world.

GUWonder Aug 26, 2004 4:22 am


Originally Posted by ewrfox
Damn! How about with any other provider? No right?

There are some creative work arounds but then you will not have a US-based SIM to roam on.

Based on your needs and the nature of your incoming/outgoing call needs and locations, there are some good deals around. $.39/minute incoming regardless of where in the world you roam is pretty useful.

GUWonder Aug 26, 2004 4:24 am


Originally Posted by cnk
Anyone have any experience with a company called Mobal?

http://www.mobalrental.com/

Looks like if you have a GSM phone which works in Europe, you can buy a SIM card for $19 and then pay just for the calls you make/receive. While the rates aren't nearly as good as pre-paid cards purchased in other countries, it seems like a good alternative for somebody who doesn't expect to make a lot of calls but wants the option available and for people who might be in multiple foreign countries and not want to have to buy prepaid cards in each place.

Any thoughts on this?

cnk

Lousy deal. I would look for something better priced.

What I have done is gotten some pre-paid SIMs that are linked to a "top-up" or similar feature and then have a local party (or go online and) get them re-charged as needed when roaming oversees.

GUWonder Aug 26, 2004 4:42 am

This is a better deal for higher volume users.

http://www.hopmobile.com/explore_costs.html

http://www.hopmobile.com/cgi-hop/pub...T=DISP_COUNTRY

Other options to be found here too:

http://www.prepaidgsm.net/en/international.html

UAVirgin Aug 26, 2004 6:37 am


Originally Posted by GUWonder

Where did you try buying it?

I bought it at a T-Mobile store in the local mall. The whole transaction took 45 minutes. In contrast buying my Virgin Mobile prepaid in London took 2 minutes with no information requested at all. It's tough to find good help in the service industry here in the US anymore.
:rolleyes:

ScottC Aug 26, 2004 7:14 am


Originally Posted by GUWonder

I always think that these international prepaid cards will get you put on some CIA/FBI/TSA watch list :D

UAVirgin Aug 26, 2004 8:00 am

FYI on the Virgin Mobile prepaid card (purchased in the UK). I just checked the fine print and you can't roam with the card in the US unless you go for the montly billing plan.

ScottC Aug 26, 2004 8:06 am


Originally Posted by UAVirgin
FYI on the Virgin Mobile prepaid card (purchased in the UK). I just checked the fine print and you can't roam with the card in the US unless you go for the montly billing plan.

Which is a good reason to go for the O2 prepaid sim, as it DOES roam in the US.

ewrfox Aug 26, 2004 8:28 am


Originally Posted by ScottC
Which is a good reason to go for the O2 prepaid sim, as it DOES roam in the US.

Inst Virgin UK on the GSM Network???

Here in the US they are on the SPrint CDMA Network... So unless Virgin has a deal with one of the 3 GSM providers I don't see how Virgin UK will work here...

ScottC Aug 26, 2004 8:34 am


Originally Posted by ewrfox
Inst Virgin UK on the GSM Network???

Here in the US they are on the SPrint CDMA Network... So unless Virgin has a deal with one of the 3 GSM providers I don't see how Virgin UK will work here...



Yes, Virgin is GSM, and yes, they DO roam on many other GSM networks, including some in the US. Just because Virgin in the US is on Sprint doesn't mean they can't make use of roaming on another US GSM network.

GUWonder Aug 26, 2004 8:35 am


Originally Posted by ScottC
I always think that these international prepaid cards will get you put on some CIA/FBI/TSA watch list :D

ROTFLOL Then again Scott, weren't you the one advocating the Swisscom pre-paid card that we used to track down certain Al-Qaeda principals? :D

GUWonder Aug 26, 2004 8:46 am


Originally Posted by UAVirgin
FYI on the Virgin Mobile prepaid card (purchased in the UK). I just checked the fine print and you can't roam with the card in the US unless you go for the montly billing plan.

The T-Mobile UK prepaid works pretty well too in roaming. The downside with the UK mobile pre-paid SIMs is that the rates are in pounds, a currency which remains stronger and more stable vis-a-vis the dollar more than the euro. A non-pound denomination will likely be cheaper per minute than a pound sterling-denominated one.

GadgetFreak Aug 26, 2004 5:20 pm

I have roamed in several European countries with my Vodafone (UK) card. It isnt cheap but it is probably comparable to the deals people are finding on the web. When I put it in my phone in the US it shows that it is working. I havent tried using it for voice. I sent my self a couple text messages. Still waiting for them to arrive. It might not work in the US. But I have used it no problem in France, Italy and Spain.

Well the sms I sent with my prepaid Vodafone UK SIM card from here in SAN worked when sent to my TMobile US postpaid account. So apparently you can use Vodafone prepaid cards in the US. Interestingly, the SMS I sent to my Verizon wireless phone hasnt come through yet. I will try again later. I entered the number manually, perhaps it had a mistake.

ewrfox Aug 26, 2004 9:08 pm

Btw, anyone here tried the International Sim card (forgot the name) that has a number based in Monaco?? I always wanted to buy it, but then you have to shell out $79 for the card then buy a $100 worth of credit....

Lol

ScottC Aug 26, 2004 9:24 pm


Originally Posted by ewrfox
Btw, anyone here tried the International Sim card (forgot the name) that has a number based in Monaco?? I always wanted to buy it, but then you have to shell out $79 for the card then buy a $100 worth of credit....

Lol

Not really worth it considering UK and other european sims do pretty much the same or even more.

Unless of course you want a cool "home" number :)

GUWonder Aug 27, 2004 6:16 am


Originally Posted by ScottC
Not really worth it considering UK and other european sims do pretty much the same or even more.

Unless of course you want a cool "home" number :)

Overdeveloped Monaco is not for me -- unless someone wants to help me seize a certain picturesque castle in a behind the scenes political coup; what was the name of that not so bad looking "princess"? :D

eric_packer Aug 28, 2004 5:42 pm


Originally Posted by ScottC
Yes, Virgin is GSM, and yes, they DO roam on many other GSM networks, including some in the US. Just because Virgin in the US is on Sprint doesn't mean they can't make use of roaming on another US GSM network.

Virgin Mobile UK rides on top of T-Mobile's GSM 1800 network in the UK.

http://www.gsmworld.com/roaming/gsminfo/index.shtml

Indeed, you can pick up a Virgin starter kit at Virgin Megastores or at Cellphone Warehouses, which are about as ubiquitous in the UK as McDonalds franchises.

If you're really hung up on getting a SIM with with Top-Up card before leaving the US, lemme know with a private message--I may have a Virgin starter kit still in box with 5GBP on the card.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 6:33 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.