![]() |
Originally Posted by ProleOnParole
(Post 29545890)
Surface laptops are not made by Microsoft. The OEM is Pegatron, essentially a part of Asus. While they are definitely among the thinnest and lightest and use some innovative solutions to achieve it, there are also trade-offs and drawbacks, and, unfortunately, widely reported quality issues, even confirmed by Microsoft themselves in a leaked memo: https://www.thurrott.com/mobile/micr...ty-reliability
Unlike most other laptops, including other thin-and-light ones, Surface devices have an iFixit repairability score of 0 out of 10, which is even worse than Apple products: essentially, everything inside is glued together and cannot be disassembled without causing permanent damage. In short, these are devices with a premium price tag (exceeding $3,000 for some configurations) that are unfixable by design and suffer from a high failure rate. Feel free to make your own conclusions. |
Originally Posted by hfly
(Post 29574082)
KRSW, that was my point, not really anymore, The keyboards may now be the same, hinges might actually be better on consumer models, and regarding the other materials you state, maybe you are talking literally another $3-4 in actual cost to the build quality
|
SurfaceBook is the way to go. No question
|
Originally Posted by emustyle
(Post 29573338)
I think if you can get over the "gaming" stigma, I've a good experience with the Razer Blade Stealth series.
I've found it well made, and competitive in terms of performance. Price may be an issue so that' could be the detractor. Given the price I'd have thought the best choice would be the Dell XPS 13, with the Lenovo X-series behind (either Carbon or the 2xx series). |
Originally Posted by Stewie Mac
(Post 29512229)
- no slower than this one (i5-3317, 4GB RAM), but guessing that anything I buy now will meet this.
Also, make sure you get 8GB of memory and some kind of SSD. The Lenovo X1 is a great machine, but at 14" it may be a bit heavier, and it will certainly have a bigger footprint. The 12.5" Lenovo X2x0 or Dell Latitude E72x0 are both the best 12.5" business machines and they will be more durable than the ultrabook-style super thin machines, although they'll be a bit thicker and bulkier. (I would recommend staying away from the Dell E52x0 series; the 5000-series quality has never been good, and unfortunately the 6000-series has gone.) If you want a convertible machine, the Surface Pro is one of the best, although a reasonably powerful configuration will be quite a bit pricier than your budget. The Surface Notebook is quite a bit less interesting. The XPS 13 is one of the best ultrabook-style machines out there, and manages to get a 13" screen into a 12" chassis. It's got an almost-macbook like lack of ports, but otherwise it's a superb machine. An i5 configuration new may be a bit beyond your budget, but the i3 model that will be in budget is probably OK. In general, I follow higher-power machines rather than the smallest ultrabooks, so current Samsung/Asus/etc ultra-thin models are a bit obscure to me, but both those brands have a good reputation. |
Any thoughts on the Lenovo X1 carbon 6th generation laptops? I'm looking for a primary laptop that's going to see a lot of car and plane travel. When I configured it on the main Lenovo website it cost somewhere between $1700 (current discount) to $2400 (llist). That's getting into the upper range of what I was looking to spend. I also looked at a Surface Book 2 but when I configured it with the top specs it priced out at nearly $3000 with only a $300 discount.
|
Originally Posted by deniah
(Post 29520635)
if i bought any laptop running windows, i would only consider lenovo (x1), or microsoft (surface).
everyone else just churns out mediocre slapdash products MS Surface pro convertible - so far, very very positive impression and satisfaction. Huawei matebook x pro ultrabooo - i was tempted by the daring attempt by huawei. Lives up to hype in some ways. Falls on it's face in others (I stand by what I said in other posts). Over this last week some very nice - on paper! - products were announced or previewed by dell, Lenovo, Asus, etc. Particularly the new Lenovos are intriguing |
Originally Posted by Lurker1999
(Post 30158295)
Any thoughts on the Lenovo X1 carbon 6th generation laptops? I'm looking for a primary laptop that's going to see a lot of car and plane travel. When I configured it on the main Lenovo website it cost somewhere between $1700 (current discount) to $2400 (llist). That's getting into the upper range of what I was looking to spend. I also looked at a Surface Book 2 but when I configured it with the top specs it priced out at nearly $3000 with only a $300 discount.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 3:47 pm. |
This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.