FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Travel Technology (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/travel-technology-169/)
-   -   Google Fi: Anyone care to post their experience? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/travel-technology/1688964-google-fi-anyone-care-post-their-experience.html)

Yoshi212 Oct 12, 2016 3:01 pm

I just got back from Africa & Europe with my Nexus 5X on fi and it worked really well. Better than my friend's Tmobile iPhone. The one "snag" is it takes a bit for it to register with the networks. Just let it do it's thing for a minute or two and you're up and running.


Originally Posted by turnleftbrighteyes (Post 27337699)
I thought I'd chime in as a happy Fi customer, who falls on the lower end of cell phone savviness (prior to Fi, I was a long-time customer of Virgin Mobile, which meant I had both a crummy phone and network.) I've never bothered to root a phone, and I've merrily traveled internationally without a working cell phone at all.

So, that said, Fi is great. I'm very pleased with the Nexus 5X. My main concern, which has been completely unwarranted, was battery life. I often don't need to charge it in the evenings. I love the lack of various carrier bloatware.I've had no issues with the network in the U.S. I have upcoming travel to South America and Europe, so hope all goes smoothly there (but if not, well, I'm used to not having a working phone anyway.) My bill is $10 less than with Virgin Mobile, which was already cheap to begin with, as I used a whopping 0.2GB of data last month, as I'm almost always near wifi.

In other words, I've had the sense the Fi was maybe being marketed to a more tech-oriented or interested consumer. But I'm very pleased and would happily recommend it to befuddled or cheapskate friends. So I hope Google doesn't abandon it...


ROW2Aisle Oct 12, 2016 11:31 pm


Originally Posted by LordHamster (Post 27296894)
...<<<snipped>>>... As for the delays.. I personally only experienced one delay in Kochi India on getting data, which I'm starting to think was due to a local carrier outage... not FI.

On landing in COK I had a good data connection on the first day but for the rest of the 3 day visit to Kerala the data connection was very spotty and if there was a connection it was on Edge or GPRS. I had very frequent delays in getting data connections with Fi around Kochi and elsewhere in Kerala in the last 3 days. At times it'd be hours before a data connection would be available. I tried cycling through the various providers and had no luck. However my standby iPhone with a local AirTel SIM always registered everywhere in Kerala immediately with 3G service.

In Chennai & Bangalore the Fi connection registers as HSPA or LTE without any delays.

nerd Oct 13, 2016 8:11 am


Originally Posted by turnleftbrighteyes (Post 27337699)
So, that said, Fi is great. I'm very pleased with the Nexus 5X. My main concern, which has been completely unwarranted, was battery life. I often don't need to charge it in the evenings. I love the lack of various carrier bloatware.I've had no issues with the network in the U.S. I have upcoming travel to South America and Europe, so hope all goes smoothly there (but if not, well, I'm used to not having a working phone anyway.) My bill is $10 less than with Virgin Mobile, which was already cheap to begin with, as I used a whopping 0.2GB of data last month, as I'm almost always near wifi.

What's your secret? I think the Nexus 5X is a great phone but my battery life is atrocious.

turnleftbrighteyes Oct 13, 2016 4:00 pm


Originally Posted by nerd (Post 27340817)
What's your secret? I think the Nexus 5X is a great phone but my battery life is atrocious.

When I said I wasn't a particularly advanced user, I wasn't kidding! I've done no real tinkering with any settings. Most of the time I forget to even turn on the battery saver mode, but I can regularly go 36-40 hours before having to charge. That said, I'm not a heavy user: I mostly am checking email, Evernote, maps, and reading things on Pocket.

With my previous (crap) phone-- and the exact same habits-- I could barely get 12 hours. So it's definitely not me.

Yoshi212 Oct 13, 2016 4:58 pm

While I wouldn't quite call the battery life atrocious I couldn't make it through a whole work day and night out without a recharge with my level of use. We made heavy use of my battery pack to recharge both an iPhone & Nexus 5X which for myself is a required accessory for travel.


Originally Posted by nerd (Post 27340817)
What's your secret? I think the Nexus 5X is a great phone but my battery life is atrocious.


Boogie711 Oct 14, 2016 9:13 am

Speaking of battery life, what are people's experience with battery life while roaming?

I have a Samsung S6 that goes into "roaming" mode while I'm in Canada with a T-Mobile SIM, and it hurts battery life. I was thinking of moving to Fi but I wasn't sure if it would merely continue to be a problem.

Dubai Stu Oct 15, 2016 6:49 am


Originally Posted by Boogie711 (Post 27345653)
Speaking of battery life, what are people's experience with battery life while roaming?

I have a Samsung S6 that goes into "roaming" mode while I'm in Canada with a T-Mobile SIM, and it hurts battery life. I was thinking of moving to Fi but I wasn't sure if it would merely continue to be a problem.

I live right on the Canadian border and cross regularly. Last year my wife worked there for more than 12 weeks. I've never noticed a difference on battery life with any of our electronics. Could you be pulling HSPA instead of LTE or be in a place where you carrier hop.

gpeso8 Oct 16, 2016 4:44 am

I had my first major hiccup you with ProjectFi this weekend. I had no data service in Medan, Indonesia with my Nexus 5x for the three days I was in the city. Had no issues with data with my wife's T-Mobile and our two local phones with two Indonesian providers (Telkomsel, and Three). Troubleshooting with Fi for hours accomplished nothing but a $10 credit.

Dubai Stu Oct 16, 2016 8:15 pm

Google Fi Question
 
Can I use the same Nexus 6 to activate more than one SIM?

ROW2Aisle Oct 17, 2016 12:57 am


Originally Posted by gpeso8 (Post 27352532)
I had my first major hiccup you with ProjectFi this weekend. I had no data service in Medan, Indonesia with my Nexus 5x for the three days I was in the city. Had no issues with data with my wife's T-Mobile and our two local phones with two Indonesian providers (Telkomsel, and Three). Troubleshooting with Fi for hours accomplished nothing but a $10 credit.

Your experience parallels mine. I had good data service with my Nexus 6P for the first few days after arrival in India with data service in Kochi, Chennai and a few other places but for the last 5 days my data service is out to lunch. I tried debugging the problem by switching multiple times between LTE, 3G & 2G manually on all the available service providers and had no luck. Signal Spy indicated that my phone was connected with HSPA or Edge or GPRS yet the use of any app indicated I was offline.

My data only SIM however works in my iPhone 5s and so I suspect the problem is with my primary SIM. I contacted Project Fi support and they also suspect that the problem is the primary SIM. They are mailing me a replacement SIM when I get back to the US. So now I'm using my backup Motorola Moto E dual SIM phone with a local SIM card for local calls and my Project Fi primary SIM for international calls and Wi-Fi calls, and my iPhone 5s for the Project Fi data service with the data only SIM.

TravelinSperry Oct 17, 2016 2:40 am


Originally Posted by gpeso8 (Post 27352532)
I had my first major hiccup you with ProjectFi this weekend. I had no data service in Medan, Indonesia with my Nexus 5x for the three days I was in the city. Had no issues with data with my wife's T-Mobile and our two local phones with two Indonesian providers (Telkomsel, and Three). Troubleshooting with Fi for hours accomplished nothing but a $10 credit.


Originally Posted by ROW2Aisle (Post 27355697)
Your experience parallels mine. I had good data service with my Nexus 6P for the first few days after arrival in India with data service in Kochi, Chennai and a few other places but for the last 5 days my data service is out to lunch. I tried debugging the problem by switching multiple times between LTE, 3G & 2G manually on all the available service providers and had no luck. Signal Spy indicated that my phone was connected with HSPA or Edge or GPRS yet the use of any app indicated I was offline.

My data only SIM however works in my iPhone 5s and so I suspect the problem is with my primary SIM. I contacted Project Fi support and they also suspect that the problem is the primary SIM. They are mailing me a replacement SIM when I get back to the US. So now I'm using my backup Motorola Moto E dual SIM phone with a local SIM card for local calls and my Project Fi primary SIM for international calls and Wi-Fi calls, and my iPhone 5s for the Project Fi data service with the data only SIM.

You may want to update the spreadsheet with your experiences - others have shown no problems: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets...UZOE5lhVU/edit

dyung Oct 17, 2016 2:22 pm

I don't believe you can as part of the activation process, your phone's MEID must be registered with Sprint, and they won't allow duplicate activations for the same MEID.

Dubai Stu Oct 18, 2016 4:25 am


Originally Posted by dyung (Post 27358352)
I don't believe you can as part of the activation process, your phone's MEID must be registered with Sprint, and they won't allow duplicate activations for the same MEID.

That was my concern as well.

thesun Oct 22, 2016 4:55 pm


Originally Posted by Boogie711 (Post 27345653)
Speaking of battery life, what are people's experience with battery life while roaming?

I've never had an issue with roaming having any effect on battery life with Google Fi. I've had better luck with battery life while roaming in some places actually than in many places at home in the US, likely due to denser cell coverage - always at 4-5 bars.

thesun Oct 22, 2016 5:04 pm


Originally Posted by Zorak (Post 27332544)
Peru: effectively did not work. ~10 days the majority of which was in Lima or Cusco and could never get it to "hold" a data connection. When coming out of airplane mode, I would get the LTE indicator (Nexus 6P) and usable data for about 30-90 seconds, then data dropped out and the service indicator changed to a hollow triangle. I could toggle airplane mode on/off again and get another 30-90 seconds, but ANGTFT.

Exacerbating this was the fact that hotel wifi seemed utterly crappy even in nicer hotels, individual SSIDs per floor that regularly cut in and out, and poor throughput (especially upload bandwidth). Had much better luck with wifi in cafes/restaurants.

The Reddit results in a Google search for "google fi peru" suggest this may be a problem with the underlying T-Mobile connectivity in Peru.

Had similar issues with Fi yesterday while spending 2 hours transiting thru LIM. I tried manually selecting networks - Movistar would only pick up 2G data while Claro Peru would repeatedly cycle between no signal, 3G, HSPA, and occasionally LTE. I was wondering if it was an issue with using a Samsung S7 but I guess I'm glad its not :)

Still better than the WiFi in the ridiculously crowded Sumaq lounge where I could get a strong WiFi signal but basically couldn't load any page.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 2:31 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.