FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Star Alliance (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/star-alliance-413/)
-   -   Best F product from BKK to W.Europe? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/star-alliance/1151130-best-f-product-bkk-w-europe.html)

GetSetJetSet Nov 21, 10 7:50 pm

Best F product from BKK to W.Europe?
 
Hi,

I am going to book with miles, so it has to be a *A carrier, however I don't care where in W.Europe the long-haul lands as I'm more than ok with a short hop back to Paris for the best longhaul experience. TG BKK right to CDG? LX, LH? In your opinion which *A carrier provides the best experience from BKK to W.Europe. Thanks!

Rejuvenated Nov 21, 10 8:37 pm

Does it have to be direct BKK-Europe? If so TG or LX. I've flown TG F several times in the past and my favorite aspect of their product is the catering, especially the Asian selection quality. I've never flown LX F thus far but all the reports I've read had almost nothing but positive feedbacks. People seem to be a big fan of LH F, but outside of of the FRA FCT, my experiences with them was below average.

If you don't mind connecting somewhere within Asia, I'd either go with NH or SQ. Two excellent products from my experiences. They have the best catering and best cabin crews among many airlines I have flown first class with. SQ IMO still has the best IFE out there.

GetSetJetSet Nov 21, 10 8:46 pm


Originally Posted by Rejuvenated (Post 15232015)
Does it have to be direct BKK-Europe? If so TG or LX. I've flown TG F several times in the past and my favorite aspect of their product is the catering, especially the Asian selection quality. I've never flown LX F thus far but all the reports I've read had almost nothing but positive feedbacks. People seem to be a big fan of LH F, but outside of of the FRA FCT, my experiences with them was below average.

If you don't mind connecting somewhere within Asia, I'd either go with NH or SQ. Two excellent products from my experiences. They have the best catering and best cabin crews among many airlines I have flown first class with. SQ IMO still has the best IFE out there.

I was hoping to go SYD-BKK-W.Europe and use BKK as a stopover point so yes needs to continue on direct from BKK back home. I hear the LX F product on the 330 is great, but I think they fly a 340 with the old F on BKK-ZRH and I don't know what kind of marks that gets.

Ocn Vw 1K Nov 22, 10 10:28 pm

For additional discussion and assistance, I'll move this to the Star Alliance airlines forum. Ocn Vw 1K, Moderator, TravelBuzz.

pogonation Nov 22, 10 11:43 pm


Originally Posted by GetSetJetSet (Post 15232116)
I was hoping to go SYD-BKK-W.Europe and use BKK as a stopover point so yes needs to continue on direct from BKK back home. I hear the LX F product on the 330 is great, but I think they fly a 340 with the old F on BKK-ZRH and I don't know what kind of marks that gets.

I have flown both the LX A330 and the A340. To me they are the same seat except the one on the 330 has slightly more privacy and a bigger screen. I have flown the ZRH-BKK route many times now in LX F and it is always an exceptional experience. IMO LX F is better than SQ F!!

Another decent option is TG F on the BKK-CDG route which is operated by a 77W leased from 9W. It has these beautiful suites in F and again the experience is fantastic. Check out my pictures from my most recent CDG-BKK flight here.

Those are by far the best two options from BKK to W.Europe ^

RoarAhead Nov 24, 10 7:19 am

Are there any gateways either in W. Europe or Asia that gets you on the TG F BKK - CDG a bit cheaper if on paid tickets rather than awards (i.e. connecting frm somewhere else)? I've tried the Jet F suites on TK and wouldn't mind doing it again...



Originally Posted by pogonation (Post 15248464)
I have flown both the LX A330 and the A340. To me they are the same seat except the one on the 330 has slightly more privacy and a bigger screen. I have flown the ZRH-BKK route many times now in LX F and it is always an exceptional experience. IMO LX F is better than SQ F!!

Another decent option is TG F on the BKK-CDG route which is operated by a 77W leased from 9W. It has these beautiful suites in F and again the experience is fantastic. Check out my pictures from my most recent CDG-BKK flight here.

Those are by far the best two options from BKK to W.Europe ^


pogonation Nov 25, 10 8:41 pm


Originally Posted by RoarAhead (Post 15266478)
Are there any gateways either in W. Europe or Asia that gets you on the TG F BKK - CDG a bit cheaper if on paid tickets rather than awards (i.e. connecting frm somewhere else)? I've tried the Jet F suites on TK and wouldn't mind doing it again...

ex:
BKK = 5870
SIN = 3310
KUL = 3990
HKG = 3433
ICN = 3193
HAN/SGN = 2880
PNH = 2900
CGK = 3485

One hell of a bargain IMO. Catch a cheap FD flight to HAN, SGN or PNH then only 2900 return ^

Prices aren't anywhere near as good ex CDG to any of the airports listed above.

RoarAhead Jan 8, 11 4:33 am

That's great work Pogonation - even HKG/ICN ain't that bad.

sbm12 Jan 8, 11 8:24 am


Originally Posted by Rejuvenated (Post 15232015)
...I've never flown LX F thus far but all the reports I've read had almost nothing but positive feedbacks. People seem to be a big fan of LH F, but outside of of the FRA FCT, my experiences with them was below average.

I would agree with these sentiments. I did LX C on the outbound and LH F on the return on my recent TATL award and not even the Lufthansa First Class Lounge in Munich (not the FCT, but I've done that, too) was enough to convince me that LH F is worth the upcharge. I'd take TG F over them in a heartbeat just based on the potential for it to be better.

littlevoices Jan 8, 11 10:40 am


Originally Posted by GetSetJetSet (Post 15231470)
TG BKK right to CDG

Fully agree and would go further to say that there is no real comparison as long as the 77W is still on the route. LX would be a second choice if availability forced it.

Rationale:
BKK First Lounges are some of the best in the world and definitely in the top 2 for Star Alliance (You could argue that the FRA F terminal is better depending on your view)
The 77W is one of the best First class "hard" (seat/suite/avod) products in the alliance, and fits perfectly for your itinerary, much better than an old 747 to other areas in Europe.

The service will probably be inferior to LX, as will the quality of the food, but I'd sacrifice it for the better beds/suite/avod product.

This is based on my own experience; a couple of LX Fs (though to other parts of Asia) on the old A340, then five TG F flights in the past year, twice on the A346, twice on the 77W and once on the 747 both starting, transiting and ending in BKK. My favourite ever flight has been an LX one though (ZRT-NRT) but if you originate in BKK you lose a few plus points of ZRH for this comparison.

SocialAdept Jan 27, 12 4:19 am

Flying BKK-FRA on TG C earlier this week (fishbone config) I noticed that the F seat were very suite-y as well and similar to the 77W ones. Can anyone explain to me their difference? Thinking of going back to BKK soon and the TG F from FRA has a leg up on the competition as I'm based in GOT (CDg would include some backtracking).

Unterwegs Jan 27, 12 8:04 am


Originally Posted by SocialAdept (Post 17896201)
Flying BKK-FRA on TG C earlier this week (fishbone config) I noticed that the F seat were very suite-y as well and similar to the 77W ones. Can anyone explain to me their difference? Thinking of going back to BKK soon and the TG F from FRA has a leg up on the competition as I'm based in GOT (CDg would include some backtracking).

TG has a different F on the 77W (it has been discussed here a few times already). This planes also have the herringbone C - both are very nice and superior over what LH or many other carriers have.

Their older style F (on the 747 and the A3x0) is a bit dated similar to the old F of LH, LH, the C is not horizontal flat, also similar to LH.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 7:01 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.