Go Back  FlyerTalk Forums > Community > Trip Reports
Reload this Page >

Vancouver via CGK, SIN, CAN, HKG and SFO: On GA Y, SQ J, CX F and AC J

Community
Wiki Posts
Search

Vancouver via CGK, SIN, CAN, HKG and SFO: On GA Y, SQ J, CX F and AC J

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Sep 3, 2011 | 1:49 am
  #16  
Original Poster
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: CGK
Programs: FlyingBlue | Krisflyer | SPG | HHonors
Posts: 1,563
SQ850 SIN-CAN cont'd

The meal service was a bit underwhelming considering their wonderful menu extensive selection. Anyway after the meal service, the crew placed a bottle of mineral water for passengers and I set my seat to the angled lie-flat position and found it to be as comfortable as the Qantas Skybed fitted on their A330s. I head to the lavatory and noticed that SQ offers some toothbrush and shaving kit on the drawers under the washbasin. Upon returning to my seat, I requested for a set of SQ's playing card and writing kit, since I remembered that they have a very nice 'Raffles' class writing kit long time ago. However, when they came back with the normal writing kit which I had obtained in Economy Class last time, I was a bit disappointed. It was a very nice and decent writing kit nonetheless.


Angled but lie-flat business class seats


SQ A330 business class cabin

Service in this flight practically stopped after the meal service reminding me of the transcontinental business class flight I had on AA between JFK and LAX early in the year. So my empty glass of Sencha practically sat on the armrest even after I returned to me seat. I continued watching 'Thor' for a while further before deciding to catch up on my sleep since I woke up early this morning for this flight. I had a nice 1 hour rest before the captain announced the start of our descent into Guangzhou.


Descent into Guangdong province

It was a cloudy but pleasant day in Guangzhou with cool weather in town on the day I arrived. While it was cloudy, it wasn't raining so it helped to lower the summer temperature somewhat. Definitely a welcome compared to the summer heat I experienced in Shanghai last year! Though the cloudy weather meant there wasn't much to see upon landing. Guangzhou's location along the river, with Baiyun mountains at the north end of the city as well as numerous reservoirs scattered in the suburbs also meant that the city would be cooler in the summer months compared to densely populated Shanghai.


The city of Guangzhou, notice the Pearl river cutting through the city.

The pilot performed a smooth landing at Guangzhou Baiyun and I was impressed at the exterior of the Baiyun Airport. However air traffic seems low for such a large airport. I surmise the airports in Shenzhen which is close to Guangzhou has diverted much of the business passengers while Hong Kong remains a major transit airport for much of the world. The low amount of air traffic meant it was a short time to our gate at the international terminal and we were soon parked at our assigned gate.


Guangzhou Baiyun Airport


Arrival at Guangzhou Baiyun

Disembarking was fast in the airport and we alighted into a dark end of the arrival terminal similar to my arrival in Melbourne. Why can't all airports have arrival halls like Changi, Vancouver or Hong Kong? Anyway while the arrival hall wasn't particularly nice like its exterior, I was able to capture some nice shots of our A330 since my rushed boarding didn't permit me to take any photos of the plane. Immigration afterwards was alright, though the queue was slightly long for foreigners. Apparently there were some passengers on a tight transit schedule and a China Southern gate agent directed some foreigners on the 'China National' line but without communicating with the one in charge of the line who then sent the 2 foreigners out of the line. I guess the airport was still lacking in some operational procedure, but even though the queue was moderately long, the bright and spacious immigration hall was a comfortable place to be waiting in.


Singapore Airlines Airbus A330 in Guangzhou

While checking my passport, the immigration officer was scanning my Australian visa, and I wondered why he chose this visa specifically since it didn't concern me entering China. Weird but I didn't want to ask about it lest it increases curiosity on his part. Anyway by the time I left, my luggage was already on the carousel and ready for pick up, so Baiyun Airport is pretty efficient in baggage handling considering the short walk from the gate to immigration and finally luggage claim. Exiting the airport, I was greeted by a staff from the Westin Hotel since I had a limousine transfer arranged with the hotel. It was a nice ride towards the Westin located in the Tianhe district on an S-Class which had cooling fans on the seats for the hot summer days.


Baggage claim at Guangzhou Baiyun

For as long as I could remember, I was really pleased with every SIA flight I had taken, when the majority of those are in Economy. I can't say Singapore Airlines as being one of the best airline, especially on the service department based on this flight, since it was just average at best. The only great part of the flight was the new regional business class cabin on the A330s which I prefer to Qantas A330s since they have much better hardware. Service wise this flight was lacking miserably compared to flights on Cathay Pacific or Qantas in the same cabin class. As one might also notice, the Silverkris Lounge doesn't announce for boarding at the lounges which made me take my time to head to the gate, and this resulted in me being the last passenger to board. This is because SQ's boarding time on the boarding pass is always ridiculously early and always end up having passengers have to wait at the gate waiting for boarding. So on the overall, I would rate this flight as another business class flight - good but not excellent.

More photos on my flickr set.

Last edited by quirrow; Sep 18, 2011 at 2:10 am
quirrow is offline  
Old Sep 3, 2011 | 1:51 am
  #17  
Original Poster
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: CGK
Programs: FlyingBlue | Krisflyer | SPG | HHonors
Posts: 1,563
Originally Posted by andrewsco
+1. Incredible photos.!
Glad that you enjoyed the photos!

Originally Posted by BryanIAH
Great photos! I can't wait to read the rest of your report.
Just posted the next installment of the trip on SQ's new business class seats for regional routes.
quirrow is offline  
Old Sep 18, 2011 | 2:00 am
  #18  
Original Poster
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: CGK
Programs: FlyingBlue | Krisflyer | SPG | HHonors
Posts: 1,563
Sheraton Shenzhen Futian and Sheraton Towers Hong Kong

China used to be a place where one can easily find high-end properties for a lower cost, but perhaps due to the Universiade Games being held in China during my stay there, it was now proving to be a relatively costly place to stay in the city. Wanting to get a taste of the city of Shenzhen as I make my way to Hong Kong, I decided for a night stay in the Sheraton. Stopping over in Shenzhen wasn't a mistake but choosing this hotel was. First off during my arrival, there was hardly any bell boy on the front door and no one came over to help me with luggage until like 2-3 minutes later. Maybe it was due to extra preparations for the University Games, but still no excuse in my opinion, as the true test of an organization comes in times of crises.


Sheraton Shenzhen Futian

Heavy security entering the main lobby was also another nuisance, but I admit that wasn't the hotel's fault. Check-in was alright and there was a special SPG member's line which was nice. But I have to say the lobby is really not to my kind of taste in terms of decor. It just reminds me of those old Chinese style hotels circa 1980s. While it might be fitted with marble and chandeliers, I would rather be in a cool lobby like the Andaz anytime. Tracking back to the check-in process, I enquired with the front desk agent on places to eat, and she only referred me to the hotel's restaurant. I even specifically asked her twice about places to eat outside the hotel, but she again referred me to the 2 hotel's restaurants which wasn't even open yet when I arrived. I am really frustrated by hotels that really try to push their guests to go dine at their establishments. Hotels need to understand that providing great lodging experience is what they should concentrate on. What I really appreciated and know from my stay at the Westin Guangzhou was that even SPG Gold get a choice of welcome amenity. I picked the free internet since my rate didn't include internet nor breakfast.


Bedroom and workspace


Spacious bathroom

As with all check-ins, the agents will always try to mention how great the room assigned is, but when I head to my room on the middle tiered floors, it was nothing spectacular. There was some minor irritation though like close proximity to the ventilation ducts and a view into the courtyard which makes the room dark in the afternoon and the noise might be a nuisance to some. But with just one night stay and not wanting the hassle, I just stuck with this room. The saving grace to the room was perhaps the large and spacious bathroom which had a nice soaking tub and a walk-in shower. However this makes the room seem pretty cramped and the dark decor made it even seem smaller. So on the overall, I don't feel particularly comfortable staying in the hotel.


View from the room

Location of the hotel is at Shenzhen's new central business district in Futian and there is a shopping mall called Central Walk in the middle of 2 rows of skyscrapers which offers a wide variety of food outlets and also contain a Carrefour hypermart in the basement. There is also a subway station connected to the mall so transportation shouldn't be too much of a problem. Other amenities of the hotel includes a landscaped swimming pool in the middle of the 3 towers that comprise of the Sheraton Shenzhen Futian, and the middle tower is actually the corporate headquarters of the company that owns this property.


Grand lobby

I managed to get a late check-out time of 3 pm from the hotel and arranged for transportation to Hong Kong which was duly managed by the concierge. While the concierge staff was helpful and provided maps and assistance in booking the transportation, they did it with a stiff kind of service. In addition there doesn't seem to be excellent communication amongst the team members which caused some confusion during check-out. Nothing that disrupted my travel plans anyway. Somehow this Sheraton reminded me of its sister property in Jakarta, and I wondered if Starwood is positioning its Sheraton brand into the lower rungs.


View from the Towers Lounge

This brought me to think about my next stay in Hong Kong which was at the Sheraton Towers in Hong Kong. I had decided to save substantially on accommodation costs by switching to the cheaper Sheraton Towers from the W Hong Kong. As much as I am a fan of the W in Hong Kong, the promotion Sheraton Towers had on its Towers Club Room seemed more value for money, and since I haven't had the chance to stay in this property, I decided on the Sheraton.


Main lobby of the Sheraton Hong Kong

The Sheraton Towers in Hong Kong is located in a much more accessible tourist location, beside the Peninsula, right by the waterfront and the Club Lounge has possibly one of the nicest views of the Hong Kong skyline. Shopping in Tsim Sha Tsui is just steps away, and so is the Star Ferry to Central. So this would be an advantage to the W for those with shopping and dining in mind. The only drawback is that this is a much older property though it was renovated and did not feel outdated as I entered the lobby. The main check-in and reception area is located on the second floor, and i was given directions but not led into the check-in area. Since the common check-in line had some queue, I decided to head to the Towers Reception which could be accessed by another side elevator. As expected, the Towers Reception is a sit down affair with my check in details being prepped beforehand in a nice folder. These little features make me remember a particular property and truly differentiates one from another.


King bed at the Sheraton Towers floor


Partial harbour view from room

I was provided with a room that had partial harbour views of the Western district, but other than that, there was no added benefits for SPG Gold members. Since I was staying on the Towers Room, internet was complimentary, along with evening canapes and breakfast at the Oyster Bar on the top floor. The room itself was unspectacular and a bit on the small side. The one thing I did not like was their wooden corners on the beds which one can easily knock into when crossing the room. In fact I knocked myself twice, and so that really made me wish the room was slightly larger. Compared to the new Hyatt Regency in Tsim Sha Tsui which also has small rooms, I would have preferred the latter since it felt much more comfortable. The room in the Sheraton was just too cluttered with too much furniture. Sadly, the bathroom also tried to fit in too much, including the miniscule bathtub and a walk-in shower. In my opinion, with such a small space constraint, they should have just went away with the bathtub and stuck with just a walk-in shower, so as to provide more space in the room.


Bathroom in the Sheraton Hong Kong


Fruit platter in room

Amenities provided in the room was by Crabtree & Evelyn which was uncommon since it was a Sheraton and I was half-expecting the generic Sheraton toiletry kit. What was more suprising was the provision of a small tube of L'Occitane cream during turndown service for the first night, and chocolates for the second night. There was also a welcome fruit platter in the bedroom on my arrival. These little gestures are things that I appreciate once again!


Bathroom amenities

The ability to view the night scenery from the Towers Lounge was a draw to why I would want to stay here and I was sorely disappointed by the small size of the lounge considering how many Towers Club guests there are. By evening all the seats were packed that the receptionist had to open up the meeting room to allow guests to sit down and eat there. This was when perhaps one might feel shortchanged. However, the Club Lounge did offer an excellent variety of snacks and drinks, including nachos with 4 different types of dips, fruit platters, sandwiches, desserts and the light but excellent Kronenbourg 1664 beer from France. First time seeing this anywhere in a hotel club lounge!


Beer and nachos at the lounge

Breakfast in the Oyster Bar was also great with guests being able to select from a menu and I noticed that the relatively large number of Japanese guests in the property might have resulted in a Japanese and Chinese breakfast set option, all served in a nice Japanese lacquered box. I had the western option on both days, starting with Eggs Benedict on the first day and Banana Pancakes on the second day. On top of the menu selection, guests could also help themselves to toast, pastries, yogurt and fruits from the buffet table.


Breakfast at the Oyster Bar

Other amenities in the Sheraton Towers Hong Kong includes a swimming pool which was a bit small and not as amazing as the W's rooftop pool that affords one of the most amazing rooftop pool vistas. On the day of departure, I headed to the airport on the hotel limo which was once again a pleasure considering the amount of luggage I had. And the most memorable part of the journey was discovering the wireless internet service within the limo which allowed me to 'check-in' my location as I crossed the Tsing Ma Bridge. Given that my stay in Hong Kong was cheaper than the Shenzhen property, I was definitely more keen to return to the Sheraton in Hong Kong, provided costs remain the same or lower. Any higher and I would rather pick the W. And for those looking for a hotel in Shenzhen, I suggest the Westin Nanshan which seems nicer and is located closer to the tourist sights.


Buffet counter during breakfast
quirrow is offline  
Old Sep 18, 2011 | 2:06 am
  #19  
Original Poster
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: CGK
Programs: FlyingBlue | Krisflyer | SPG | HHonors
Posts: 1,563
The Wing and the Cabin - Lounges in HKIA


Crossing Tsing Ma bridge on an S-Class limo

This is my first experience of flying 'real' First Class and to be able to conduct this in Cathay Pacific is truly something special. Since I had a lot of luggage and having been spoilt by the luxurious transfers in China, I thought why not just settle for a hotel limo. While the Hong Kong airport express is excellent, it doesn't have a Cathay First Class counter if I recall... And I wasn't staying at the W, Four Seasons or Ritz-Carlton which were the hotels with direct access to the Airport Express. Thus I had obtained a ride to the airport on a Mercedes Benz S Class from the Sheraton HK. It was a nice ride and the limo even has complimentary wifi onboard. This meant I was able to do some facebook browsing and messaging using the wifi on the 40 minute ride to HKIA.


First class check-in at Hong Kong


Cathay Pacific first class counters

I was dropped off in the first section of the main terminal which was home to the first 2 rows, and they are reserved for Cathay's First and Business Class check in counters. I headed straight to the First Class counters which unlike any other counters have no luggage conveyor. Instead, a luggage attendant will come over to bring passengers' luggage over to be tagged. A clear display facing the passenger shows all details of their flight and it does feel like a whole new experience. Passengers are also able to check in 3 bags compared to the usual 2, and the luggage attendant was helpful enough in getting a box so I can put my shoe box and some toiletries in it to be checked in.


Entrance to the Wing

After passing me the boarding pass with seat 1A in it though, that is where the experience stops. No special priority screening. Thankfully, there was only a small queue at the security screening, and the queue at immigration was equally short. The excellent this was just after immigration lies the entrance to the Wing First Class Lounge and since the Business Class lounge was being renovated, it was only accessible to First Class passengers. Like many virgin experiences, entering a First Class Lounge was a first for me and being inquisitive, I decided to check out the wonderful private cabanas that Cathay Pacific provides its First Class passengers with. I was directed to the first cabana and it was a nice little private space one could retreat into. I started the experience by relaxing with my iPad at the lounge chair before deciding on a nice shower before my flight.


The cabanas at the Wing


Private bathtub in the cabana

This made it the second time I had shower in an airport. Even with the small porch in the cabana being accessible to others using the cabana, it still felt private and really relaxing. The ample space also made it a comfortable place for a shower as I could really stretch out. They even have a full size bathtub, but seeing that it was quite old and had some stains, I just headed for the rain shower. Bathtubs are after all for the lazy evenings, and not the morning when one still has the energy to do much stuff. With the refreshing shower done, I used the complimentary amenities to dress up before storing my luggage by the receptionist desk. I was provided with a small envelope with a token enclosed within and it was a really nice to be free of the hand carry bags while I roam around my favourite airport in the world - Hong Kong International. I managed to do some shopping at the Shanghai Tang store which had a trousers I had wanted in stock (they were out of stock in town).


The Cabin Macintosh workstation

My next stop after that was The Cabin, which is Cathay's newest lounge in Hong Kong, and having had a short visit during my last trip passing by Hong Kong, I didn't manage to capture the whole essence of the lounge. This time, though, I really like the new lounge and the concept it brings to passengers. Unlike the Pier and the Wing which are similar lounges offering a full variety of services and amenities for the First Class passengers, the Cabin is open to all premium passengers, meaning there is no specific First Class section. But the individual space-age chairs more than make up for it. The ones with a view of the tarmac are the most desirable, and while the right section of the Cabin is pretty small, the one on the left is much more spacious and comes with a Health Bar.


Juice and tea at the Health Bar

They were offering a nice selection of salads and sandwiches for guests, while the bar itself has a daily selection of healthy beverages from juices to teas. I ordered a glass of grapefruit juice and a cup of chilled chrysanthemum with honey. The latter is perhaps one of the best chilled tea beverages I have drank and instantly made me a fan of this lounge. The way this lounge was designed was catered to the weary frequent flyers and with a healthy theme around it, I do believe it will help to relieve the stress of flying! A really ingenious concept for an airline lounge!


Dining alcove at the Cabin


Space seats at the Cabin


Walkway at the Cabin

Since I wasn't interested in their salads, and still with some time to spare, I headed out of the lounge to watch planes, and this is another airport where one can do without lounges. With the open plans of the gates, and all security screening being conducted before the immigration and at transit points, it has an open and airy feel. This also means everyone is free to view all other passengers' planes. This time round, I manage to capture the pullback of the Korean Air 747 which was still docked when I saw it earlier while shopping for my pants.


Korean Air jumbo jet pulling back for Incheon


The Wing dining table

Eventually, it was back to the Wing for some proper meal before the flight. The small dining area was much more packed compared to my earlier visit when no one was in the dining area. Since the buffet table food was not to my fancy, I asked if I could order the Dan-dan noodles. The receptionist asked if I wanted a small or large bowl, and I picked the former since I didn't want to be too full for the food onboard later. I also helped myself to a small morsel of roast pork or commonly known as char siew topped with some broccoli with mushrooms for my vegetables.


BBQ Pork with broccoli

Once seated, a waiter came over and took my order for drinks and I went with green tea since they do not have Longjing tea. When the tea was served it came in a hot metal pot with this small piece of paper to act as the handle, but with the handle so flimsy, it teared on the top section, making it hard to handle the pot. In my opinion, they should have just went with a porcelain tea pot and save passengers of all the hassle. The noodle that came later was excellent as usual and one of my favourite airline lounge food!


Dessert counter at The Wing


Dan Dan noodles and green tea

After my small meal, I asked for a cup of Haagen-Dazs cookies and cream ice cream and enjoyed it in the far corner of the lounge near where the renovations were taking place. Even with the slight noise from the renovations, it was still a nice place to relax and with no one else around I was able to do a Skype conversation on the iPad with my mum before boarding. The mezzanine location of the Wing also ensured the nicest views amongst the other lounges in Hong Kong. Cathay's lounge in Shanghai also had a similar placement giving it a vantage spot of the departure concourse and the flights departing. I had a nice conversation undisturbed in this end of the lounge before proceeding for boarding. On the way to boarding, I also got to capture some shots of Cathay's 100th Aircraft with a special livery.


The Library at the Wing


Cathay Pacific's 100th aircraft - an Airbus A330

Though I arrived at the airport way earlier before my scheduled departure, I was really relaxed and truly enjoyed the facilities in Cathay's home lounges. Their new innovative lounge offerings in Hong Kong coupled with the convenience of its amazing international airport makes Cathay Pacific one of my favourite airlines and reminds me again to be loyal to the company!
quirrow is offline  
Old Sep 18, 2011 | 4:21 pm
  #20  
10 Countries Visited20 Countries Visited30 Countries Visited20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Tokyo, Vancouver, Hong Kong, Dublin
Programs: CX DM
Posts: 880
I love the wide angle shot of the Library ! Very warm and elegant !
marcuslai is offline  
Old Sep 28, 2011 | 8:03 pm
  #21  
UMD
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 249
Great TR! I have to say your photos are all composed very well and very clear too. Thank you.

Amazing that GA still finds time to serve meal on a short 35 - 40 mins flight between TKG and CGK. I have been very impressed with this airlines since the transformation happened.

Originally Posted by KLflyerRalph
Just got back from Indonesia. Flown with GA AMS-DXB-CGK and found them to be EXCELLENT. Really. Crew, food, seats, IFE... all better than MH and certainly 4 star. Can't wait for the 77W's and Skyteam membership.
Reason for CGK having 2 security checks is probably connections. If you're connecting from let's say DPS (own experience) you aren't bothered with the pre-check in security thus have to have one at the gate.
I also stayed at Le Meridien Jakarta and found it also great. Breakfast was really the most extensive I've ever had.

I'm thinking of doing a TR on the trip if I find the time for 5 flights and 20 days of hotels and tours!

Thanks for the TR so far. ^
Please do share your TR. Would love to read it. Not intending to hijack this TR but you can PM me if you would like to read my TR on my GA's flight from SIN to AMS in C and back in July this year.


Originally Posted by quirrow
I like the way how Hong Kong does it for connections, in that it directs the arrival passengers into transit points and security checks from there. IMO, it works better than how SIN or CGK does it...

On a side note, I do hope you could post a review of it, would love to read it, since I had some really excellent flights on GA too between CGK and DPS!
NRT is the same as HKG as well.
UMD is offline  
Old Sep 29, 2011 | 12:09 am
  #22  
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Posts: 1,158
Nice tripreport so far. I love the photos. Looking forward to read/see the rest.
SQ325 is offline  
Old Oct 2, 2011 | 4:53 am
  #23  
10 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Lon ,(former ABZ + AUH)
Programs: BAEC Gold, Starbucks Gold, CO Op gold
Posts: 160
Great Trip report so far, and i really love the colour you are capturing with your pictures, very vibrant
Omar84 is offline  
Old Oct 2, 2011 | 10:27 pm
  #24  
10 Countries Visited
20 Countries Visited
30 Countries Visited
15 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: YVR - Vancouver, with most winter weekends in Whistler.
Programs: Aeroplan 35K, Alaska MVP, Marriott Titanium / Lifetime Platinum, Hertz President's Circle
Posts: 4,633
Great Report.

Loved the photo of the CGK departure check in desks. Used to date an Australian woman who spent lots of time in Jakarta. Had many teary goodbyes in that hall!
worldtraveller73 is offline  
Old Oct 5, 2011 | 5:05 am
  #25  
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: On the beach
Programs: QF P1 (OWE) LTG (OWS)
Posts: 822
Fantastic TR - loving it all ^
amaroo is offline  
Old Oct 5, 2011 | 12:33 pm
  #26  
10 Countries Visited
20 Countries Visited
30 Countries Visited
20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Let me check my Logbook
Programs: Southwest Rapid Rewards; AAdvantage; Alaska Mileage Plan; Wyndham Rewards; Choice Hotels
Posts: 2,406
Very good trip report. I'm looking for more.
Loose Cannon is offline  
Old Oct 21, 2011 | 1:34 pm
  #27  
Original Poster
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: CGK
Programs: FlyingBlue | Krisflyer | SPG | HHonors
Posts: 1,563
Originally Posted by UMD
Great TR! I have to say your photos are all composed very well and very clear too. Thank you.

Amazing that GA still finds time to serve meal on a short 35 - 40 mins flight between TKG and CGK. I have been very impressed with this airlines since the transformation happened.
Yup GA has always done pretty well, and in the late 80s to early 90s, they were really amongst one of the best carrier in the region! I really liked how GA gives out candies before flights to all passengers.

Originally Posted by SQ325
Nice tripreport so far. I love the photos. Looking forward to read/see the rest.
Thank you for the comments!

Originally Posted by Omar84
Great Trip report so far, and i really love the colour you are capturing with your pictures, very vibrant
I made some it more vibrant through Lightroom which is a very nice photo editing software to make photos look much better!

Originally Posted by worldtraveller73
Great Report.

Loved the photo of the CGK departure check in desks. Used to date an Australian woman who spent lots of time in Jakarta. Had many teary goodbyes in that hall!
Aren't airports all a place where frequent outbursts of emotions (happiness and farewell) always take place at?

Originally Posted by amaroo
Fantastic TR - loving it all ^
Last few segments to come!

Originally Posted by Loose Cannon
Very good trip report. I'm looking for more.
Posting the next instalment soon! Been busy with my coursework so far...
quirrow is offline  
Old Oct 21, 2011 | 2:46 pm
  #28  
Original Poster
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: CGK
Programs: FlyingBlue | Krisflyer | SPG | HHonors
Posts: 1,563
First on Cathay in the First Seat on a 747 - Part 1

CX870 HKG-SFO
14 Aug 11
1405-1135
1433-1156
Boeing 747-400 B-HOX
Seat 1A

Boarding for what appears to be a full flight today on a Jumbo Jet could be frustrating with long lines and due to the need for extra security for flights departing to the United States, my flight to San Francisco was due to depart from Gate 4 which is the end of the terminal. The problem was another long distance flight was departing at gate 3 and there was a long queue to enter the enclosed compound. I went over to queue at the shorter premium line and upon checking my boarding pass, the boarding agent called her colleague who came over and breezed me past the rest of the queue, including Business Class passengers. So that's what First Class is all about, since the airline does really put you in first place. The agent allowed me to bypass everyone queueing for boarding and led me to the additional security check. From there, I stopped by to take some shots of the 747 before I headed to the First/Business aero bridge.


The 747 that flew me to SFO

As expected, upon showing my boarding pass with 1A on it, the flight attendant gestured for another crew member to bring me over to my seat. By the time I arrived at my seat, nearly half of the First Class cabin was occupied, which meant it was not possible for me to capture the whole cabin to my liking. No matter, I was still pleased to be seated on 1A at the nose cone of the 747, and with the unique design of the plane, it also meant I was seated even more upfront than the pilots! I stowed my hand carry under the ottoman, and the crew mentioned to me about the closet where I could store my extra shopping bag.


View from 1A

With 3 windows by my side, I admired the view of the terminal from this end and explored the very comfortable First Class seats. The flight attendant came back shortly with drinks order and I requested for champagne to complete the experience. She came back with a fresh bottle of Krug and showed me the bottle before pouring the bubbly over a flute glass. The little gesture made all the difference in the world between First and Business and it is no wonder Cathay First is considered one of the best! I was already wowed up to this stage!


Windows to the World


Shanghai Tang Pyjamas

The crew came around again and offered me newspapers but having taken a copy from the lounge, I was fine and she next came by with hot towels and another came to enquire about my pyjama size. I took a medium size thinking it would fit. When she came back with the medium pyjamas, I realized it was still too large and exchanged it with a small size. Since dinner will be served first after the flight, I decided to change to my pyjamas after the meal, and thus continued to play around with the seat features, browse through the entertainment choices available and just relax with my glass of champagne. It took a while before boarding was completed and there was an issue with some missing passengers which delayed our departure a bit. This short delay prompted the stewardess into action as they gave out immigration forms for passengers. And the long time I spent in the cabin on the ground also showed me how wide and long the First Class seats were. Even fully extending my legs, they were still too short to reach the ottoman. Well I am not too tall to begin with but it still showed how very large a space it is. The fold down armrests on the side also made the seats a lot wider when put up.


Orchids by the window


Seat 1A

The controls for the seats are all placed ergonomically by the large ledge beside the window. I do think seat 1A had a lot larger ledge which makes it easier to place one's newspaper, reading materials, passport, drinks and that hot towel. In first class, the stewardess were also nice enough to only collect the glasses and towels at the last minute of pullback. More time to enjoy the beverages! During our pullback, the crew ensured all the TV screens were pulled out and with the TV screen fully extended, it was no bother to me as mentioned by some reviews of this particular seat. I do admit it is a bit of a bother since they were stowed back to the sideways position for take off after the safety video which was screened in English, Mandarin and Cantonese. This meant no video of the take off or landing, so if they are truly important, other seats in the First Class cabin might be more suitable.


Flying over Wanshan Archipelago

Pullback was a long affair but being seated in 1A, the time just seems to pass by quietly though a ride on the nose of the 747-400 shows the age of the plane since it was a relatively bumpy ride when the plane decided to go full throttle for take-off. This is definitely not one of the best take-off experience! But as we took off on the southwesterly route, we were treated to excellent harbour views around Lantau Island, allowing me to spot the small village of Tai O. What is more amazing is the view as the plane passes by the group of islets known as the Wanshan Archipelago. With the clear blue skies and azure waters, it was a nice sight, and best of all was how I had all 3 windows in the prime vantage point to enjoy it!


Flying over South China Sea

Upon reaching cruising altitude and when the seat belts sign were off, I headed to the toilet and noticed the occupied signs on the lavatories, but the crew mentioned it was due to passengers in the Business Class using these toilets that they had to make it look occupied. Similarly in First Class, the lavatories have a huge difference, and this lavatory sure have enough space and even comes with 2 private windows, making the lavatory feels much airier.


First Class Lavatory

After returning to my seat, the flight crew took down drink orders and I went with a cup of Hong Kong style milk tea which came along with a small bowl of warm assorted nuts, whereby in Business only almonds were given out. The senior purser then returned to give out menus for the flight. Today's crew serving first class was led by Irene, a senior purser from Malaysia with her assistants from China and HK and the flight crew manager was from Philippines. During this whole time, I was always addressed by name, making the experience much more personal indeed. As expected, the food in First was definitely much better and I was looking forward to an excellent feast! The senior purser returned for my meal order and went through the list with me, including asking me if I would like the caviar for starters, and my preferences for the soups and main courses. I just requested for food from the Chinese favourites since I think Cathay's chinese food offering is perhaps the best amongst any airline in the world. I also requested for a fruit plate in addition to the dessert, and she told me she would try to get one from the Business Class section for me as it wasn't in the menu.


Cathay Pacific First Class Menu


First Class Cabin onboard Cathay 747

Shortly after my food orders were taken, I relaxed on the seat and switched on the IFE. This was the minor flaw though it made some special incident as the inflight destination and route that was inputted showed a HKG-LHR routing on flight CX253. I sure hope the plane wasn't flying in the opposite direction to my planned destination. To reassure passengers, a ticker was screened on the IFE screen to indicate a malfunction in the destination routing and the captain also reiterated that we are indeed flying across the Pacific to San Francisco. This I continued to watch Thor that I had left from my previous flight.


Welcome screen showing incorrectly that it is flying to LHR

It was then at this time that the flight duty manager came over and introduced herself. She saw my that my face had turned quite red from drinking the champagne earlier and seems to fear that I have become slightly drunk. Thus the words she mentioned to me was about getting her passengers to just relax and drink lots of water. Upon enquiring about my route, she was surprised I did not board the direct HKG-YVR service, instead choosing to take the longer route. To me this longer route was more interesting in that I get to try out a new routing, and with more availability on the 747 it was an obvious choice. I would also be able to take this opportunity to visit one of my favourite cities - San Francisco once again!


Cathay Pacific First Class dining set-up


Cathay Pacific First Class starters

Just as we approached the southern tip of Taiwan, my table was prepped for the meal service. The much larger table also meant more weight and more force required to pull it out from the armrest. Again, no need to do anything as the crew member came over to help you set up the table. It makes me feel really helpless and lazy though! The plate of caviar was brought out promptly and served with potatoes, the complete condiments, toast and the Balik Salmon. Being a fan of roe of all sorts, I really enjoyed this starter, and the taste will probably linger for years to come.


Flying over Tainan

The icing on the cake was the view provided out of the window as we flew past the city of Tainan, Chiayi, the eastern mountain ranges of Taiwan and finally into the Pacific Ocean. All these while I slowly savour the caviar and the salmon! Wonderful to be in First Class on Cathay eh? The highlight of the meal doesn't stop here though as the next course was equally spectacular. Choosing from the Chinese selection, I had the papaya with pork, almond and peanut soup which was sweet and doesn't reek of the papaya scent. It came along with the cold plate of marinated sliced abalone served with chilli soya sauce. The abalone was tender and full of flavour by itself, which surpassed my expectations for abalone served on a plane. As with service in Chinese restaurants, chopsticks were offered and this was something missing from Business Class as well.


Soup and cold plate


Abalone for cold platter

Given the high quality of the starters, the main course might seem a bit underwhelming, but it was a nice pairing for Chinese cuisine. I had the sesame salt-baked chicken with sesame sauce which was better than what I expected though the accompanying stir-fried pak choy was a bit overcooked and didn't look too nice. Still, the ability to have freshly cooked jasmine rice with a pair of side dishes was a great finish to the main meal. Throughout the meal service, I only requested for water and the crew made sure my glass of water is frequently topped up with fresh Evian mineral water!


Steamed rice for main course


Sesame Salt-baked Chicken 芝麻鹽焗雞


Stir-fried Pak Choy 炒白菜
quirrow is offline  
Old Oct 21, 2011 | 2:48 pm
  #29  
Original Poster
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: CGK
Programs: FlyingBlue | Krisflyer | SPG | HHonors
Posts: 1,563
First on Cathay in the First Seat on a 747 - Part 2

To end the meal, the black forest pudding with vanilla ice cream ad raspberry coulis was just perfect. The warm chocolate pudding sweetens the palate with the coolness of vanilla ice cream that just melts delicately. Add in the sour raspberry drizzle, and the taste is just that of a classic black forest cake. just before dessert service commenced though, the cabin lights were dimmed to allow those passenger who skipped dessert to retire first for the night. I was also offered a choice of after meal drink and went for green tea which came in a pot, much better than the way it was served in the lounge. Every passenger was also provided with a bottle of Evian placed by the side for personal refreshment.


Black forest pudding with vanilla ice cream and raspberry coulis


Green tea in a pot

The generous fruit platter that came after that totally satisfied my stomach for the dinner! So from the start of boarding till the end of the meal, I already had a nice glass of champagne, milk tea, nuts, a tour of islands in the south of Hong Kong, a magnificent vista from the eastern end to western end of Taiwan, and the best inflight cuisine ever. As you can see, there is no need to advertise top star chefs in airline menus, since they don't really improve on the taste, and just make expectations harder to reach. Definitely a great start to my flight! In between my meals, I also finished the movie 'Thor' and got ready to retire to my bed. Before that, I had to request for an amenity kit since I wanted the socks and it turns out the crew had forgotten to hand them out to passengers as they were too busy. I returned back to my seat and withdrew the hangar from the closer as the crew member came around with the amenity kits.


Fruit platter

As I got up to head to the lavatory, she also enquired if I wanted my seat to be made up into a bed, and I obliged since I wanted to take a nap after the meal. As mentioned earlier, the First Class lavatory is definitely a more comfortable space for one to brush their teeth and change! The wonderful amenities within the lavatory was also by Acca Kappa just like the contents of the amenity kit. There was also hand towels, moist paper towels, shaving kits and sanitary pads in the drawer underneath the washbasin.


Washbasin onboard Cathay Pacific First Class


First Class Bed

The small size of the pyjamas really fitted me nicely and it was a really comfortable piece of cotton pyjamas with a nice oriental design, derived from Shanghai Tang's classic collections. Perhaps the best pyjamas on any airline as well, though I realized it can get warmer than the Qantas Business Class pyjamas which I also liked for its simplicity. On my return to the seat, the crew asked me if I would fill up a comment form and provided me with the form, a pen and a $5 voucher for inflight purchases. Upon my return to the seat which by now has become a bed, I filled up the comment form and returned it to the crew. I also decided to ask the crew if I could like maybe use the voucher to offset the purchase of an extra pair of pyjamas which I was thinking of giving to my Dad. The crew responded graciously by saying she would check with the senior purser and get back to me. I returned to my seat thereafter and take a peek out of the window to notice that we had just passed the southern coast of Japan. The nice sunset cast a warm glow to the scenery outside and fortunately the moving map still showed our correct location and travel routes even if the home screen of StudioCX still thinks we are heading to London Heathrow! As I lie down on the 'bed', I got really comfortable, even with the IFE screen being extended outwards, and there was really no issue of getting out or knocking my feet against the IFE.


Flying past Southern Japan

I had nearly 4 hours of sleep and found the additional duvet for the seat to be supremely comfortable. With the nice fluffy blanket, it was a cozy 'suite' for a nap and I was neither too hot or cold. In fact the temperature was just perfect. Though I imagined the same ambience in an A380 would be even better since there would be less noise. During my short nap, there was also a bit of turbulence, which woke me up eventually and this also meant that I didn't have a long sleep as I wanted to.


Ice cream and more tea


Horizon over the Pacific

So I asked for some ice cream along with a pot of green tea by walking to the galley. I like to take this opportunity to stretch out my legs a bit rather than just asking for the attendant button. The senior purser was there at the galley at the time and mentioned to me about the pyjamas which I seemed to have forgotten after my nap. Anyway she mentioned that they are running low on the small sizes and it would be better for flights heading back to Hong Kong when they would be able to know if they have spares to pass to passengers. But not a chance of even purchasing them onboard since they are 'exclusively' for Cathay's First Class passengers!


StudioCX


More caviar

I continued watching my episodes of House M.D. while enjoying my supper. And as the ice cream and pot of tea came in a small tray, they were able to be placed on the ledge rather than requiring me to take out the whole table out again. Another benefit of First Class. Finishing the tea and the ice cream, I took another peek out of the window to see the sun setting across the horizon, giving it a nice hue to the scenery as we pass by the Bering Sea. I returned for another short nap, but was only able to sleep for another 45 minutes or so before waking up once again. This time round, I decided for more snacks and enquired if I could get snacks from the snack bar. Instead the crew asked if I would like to order from the menu. I guess she didn't understand I wanted chips or chocolates, so I had to further explain and she eventually led me to the business class section where there was a self snack bar and I got a couple of pralines with a pack of apple chips to enjoy with more entertainment from StudioCX. I also enquired if they might have more caviar, and while they said they have it, they didn't have the potatoes. I just wanted the caviar with the toast anyway, and these were then delivered to me shortly afterwards as I am halfway through watching the comedy 'How I met your Mother'. With the caviar, I also ordered a cup of Hot Chocolate and it was a fantastic snack prior to the breakfast that would be served later.


Fruit platter to start breakfast

I gave up on sleeping and decided to just relax during the flight with several more episodes of House to keep me occupied. It was definitely a very nice way to lounge on the bed while watching some of my favourite TV shows. Around 1 hours and a half later, the first course of breakfast was served which consists of more fruit, grapefruit juice, mango & passionfruit smoothie and warm fluffy croissants with a selection of spreads, honey and butter. A glass of smoothie for breakfast is always appreciated and the starter was an excellent prelude to the main course of dace fish julienne with pak choy congee and stir-fried egg noodles with vegetables. I went with the Chinese selection for breakfast again when orders were taken earlier during the flight and didn't regret my choice at all. The congee is as good as those one can get in the congee house around Hong Kong, though the stir-fried noodles was a bit too oily and I was already too full after the bowl of congee. There was also freshly brewed coffee served in between which was excellent to perk me up just before our entry into the United States.


Dace fish julienne with pak choy congee 白菜鲮鱼粥

The completion of breakfast service also marked the near to the end of the flight and I used this opportunity to change back to my clothes. However the busy cabin in the morning meant many passengers had the same idea, and both lavatories were used, so the crew mentioned that she will call me from my seat once the lavatories are ready for use. I returned to my seat and continued my show on the IFE and realized that in First Class the service is truly so much better and that is what passengers are paying for in addition to the luxurious offerings.


Seat armrest in First Class


North California in sight

Again I was able to change back to my clothes in the clean lavatory, and it is amazing how the lavatory is well maintained during the whole flight in the First Class cabin. I guess it helps that only 2 lavatories are shared amongst 9 persons. Returning back to my seat and with the cabin lighting being switched on in preparation for our descent, I was comfortable in putting the window shades up to get a glimpse of the coast of Northern California and San Pablo Bay indicating we are close to landing in San Francisco. I tried to get a glimpse of the Golden Gate Bridge but it just seems to be eternally covered in fog while the downtown and the Bay Bridge is visible under clear skies. Passengers on my side of the cabin are treated to a view of Foster City and the artificial lake within as we landed on the runway at 11:56am local time. The plane took some time to taxi towards the gate and it was a magnificent summer day in San Francisco.


Downtown SF and the Bay Bridge


Landing at SFO

To truly end the flight on the high note, the flight attendant held back all business class passengers on disembarkation to ensure all First Class passengers disembarked first. It was something really necessary since the queues at the immigration was really long with several international flights arriving around the same time. This was something I really didn't expect since my arrival into JFK on Cathay's flight from Vancouver had been met with no immigration lines at all. There was a really long wait of more than 1 hour before I was served and allowed to proceed and collect my luggage. The priority luggage tags had no effect at all in this case since all the luggage were out on the conveyor by this time. There were complimentary trolleys in the international arrival baggage claim which was a nice welcome, before I pushed my luggage to collect my rental car from Hertz.


First 3 rows of the First Class cabin

My first time on an international First Class flight with such a great airline like Cathay Pacific totally exceeded my expectations and I finally understood what the fuss was about CX's First Class. Let's just say I would think First Class is absolutely worth the money/miles required if one could afford it. It is such a great experience to be able to fly in First, from the food to the extra mile that the crew goes for the passenger and the added comfort and amenities, that this flight would always be on my mind. Save for the minor flaws like the faulty IFE information on the home screen and the long queues on arrival at San Francisco, I think this flight is close to perfect as far as it goes. It also reaffirms Cathay Pacific as my top airline in the world.


Fondly missed seats...


Jumbos at SFO
quirrow is offline  
Old Oct 21, 2011 | 4:54 pm
  #30  
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Argentina
Posts: 40,876
A wonderful report with great pictures to match. ^
HIDDY is offline  


Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service -

This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.