new MR member, no points, overwhelmed
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: SEA
Posts: 2,556
new MR member, no points, overwhelmed
I am a Marriott Rewards member...but have no points (since I am not a frequent hotel-stayer). I have checked numerous places on FlyerTalk for ideas on getting deals at Marriotts. I tried the codes listed on a different thread. I don't seem to qualify for any.
Will stay in NYC several nights in August. In my case are the best deals I can hope to get the ones that are on Marriott's webpage? That seems to be the case. I have gotten an overload of information checking online and on FlyerTalk in recent days and have ended up overwhelmed. Any advice you could offer would be appreciated.
Will stay in NYC several nights in August. In my case are the best deals I can hope to get the ones that are on Marriott's webpage? That seems to be the case. I have gotten an overload of information checking online and on FlyerTalk in recent days and have ended up overwhelmed. Any advice you could offer would be appreciated.
#2
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: SEA/PBI/SVO/DME
Programs: SU/DL/US/MR
Posts: 717
I am a Marriott Rewards member...but have no points (since I am not a frequent hotel-stayer). I have checked numerous places on FlyerTalk for ideas on getting deals at Marriotts. I tried the codes listed on a different thread. I don't seem to qualify for any.
Will stay in NYC several nights in August. In my case are the best deals I can hope to get the ones that are on Marriott's webpage? That seems to be the case. I have gotten an overload of information checking online and on FlyerTalk in recent days and have ended up overwhelmed. Any advice you could offer would be appreciated.
Will stay in NYC several nights in August. In my case are the best deals I can hope to get the ones that are on Marriott's webpage? That seems to be the case. I have gotten an overload of information checking online and on FlyerTalk in recent days and have ended up overwhelmed. Any advice you could offer would be appreciated.
Take a deep breath and step away from your situation if you're overwhelmed.
What is your main purpose.... gain points on your account, grab silver status (given after 10 nights w/ Marriott) or just the best deal possible ?
#3
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend


Join Date: May 2002
Location: YEG
Programs: HH Silver
Posts: 57,066
As an fairly infrequent Marriott guest myself (under 5 nights usually every year) I essentially ignore the program in favor of the booking best deal at Marriott or elsewhere. I don't qualify anymore for silver, not that it had really any perks anyway, so don't sweat the points chase. Status and points really only come in to their own when you stay often at hotels so if you don't MHO is to relax and focus on the price and not get distracted by the other stuff.
#4
Moderator, Marriott Bonvoy & FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: McKinney, TX, USA
Programs: United Silver; AA Plat/2MM; Marriott LT Titanium; Hilton Gold
Posts: 11,775
But with that said, there are ways to accumulate points in various programs even without a lot of traveling. I suspect there is more than one or two persons on FT whose main points earning vehicle are CCs instead of actual travel. So it is still possible to earn not only points but status as well by judicious CC use. Silver is possible with only CC use for Marriotts, but mid-tier Gold is possible with the SPG and top tier is possible in HH with CC use alone.
For NYC travel specifically, if you are looking for your best deal possible, you might be better off making a reservation with something like Priceline and just not worry about the few points you might be missing out with that trip.
#5
In memoriam
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: MAN
Programs: Marriott Lifetime Titanium, IHG Spire, UA Silver, Dennis The Menace Fan Club
Posts: 1,457
The reality here is that the likes of priceline will, over 95% of the time, do a better deal on the cash rates. Points become relevant if you stay a lot, because at the upper echelons of membership you are awarded more per $ AND you get free bennies.
The problem for the leisure traveller is that the program is designed principally for the weekday business traveller, with lounges mostly only fully open on weekdays and with 72 hour override mostly "needed" to cover weekday events. The bennies make it easier for the traveller on the corporate $ to have an easier stay, and get what is in effect a backhander (points) for future travel. This works out valuable to us road warriors, with the higher rates paid by our companies on weekdays and with the bonuses etc its quite possible to earn 7000+ points per night, which over a mere 3 nights (cat 3 or 4) or 4 or 5 nights (cat 5+) will get you a free night stay. With the 5 nights award for the price of 4 its possible to get a 5 night stay at one of Marriotts best hotels (cat 7 or 8) for 15-20 nights of business stays.
Not that its cheap to those who pay the bill, to do a top hotel for 5 nights would require 160,000 points. Assuming our member is a PLT and 40,000 points came from megabonuses, the remaining 120,000 over 20 nights would be 6000 points per night, meaning a spend by our employers of $400 per night, $8,000 overall. And remember to get the 40,000 megabonus you have to do the 20 nights in 3 months, so it really only works for the regulars spending other peoples money.
To reverse this around, assuming no status and that your stays were only 4 or 5 nights per year, at weekends, on rooms averaging 100 ($150) per night it would take you about 20-25 YEARS to stay the 106 nights to get that 5 night (160,000 points) break (remember, our PLT can manage that in just 3 months!). Against that with Priceline you should get a weekend 4* room for about 70 night ($100) thus saving yourself the price of a free night once every 2 or 3 nights.
Having said all that it is fair to point out that you'll not find Marriotts best 5 star hotels lurking around on priceline, yes, I think you'll find the majority of Marriotts inventory there, but its unlikely the likes of Londons Grosvenor House and New Yorks Marquis will ever make its way there, so the only way to stay at Marriotts very top establishments is to "pay". Cash or Points. I can vouch that a lot of us do use our points for the very best of Marriotts inventory, thus squeezing a bit more value out of the scheme, but the simple fact remains that it just isn't worthwhile unless you're a regular...
The problem for the leisure traveller is that the program is designed principally for the weekday business traveller, with lounges mostly only fully open on weekdays and with 72 hour override mostly "needed" to cover weekday events. The bennies make it easier for the traveller on the corporate $ to have an easier stay, and get what is in effect a backhander (points) for future travel. This works out valuable to us road warriors, with the higher rates paid by our companies on weekdays and with the bonuses etc its quite possible to earn 7000+ points per night, which over a mere 3 nights (cat 3 or 4) or 4 or 5 nights (cat 5+) will get you a free night stay. With the 5 nights award for the price of 4 its possible to get a 5 night stay at one of Marriotts best hotels (cat 7 or 8) for 15-20 nights of business stays.
Not that its cheap to those who pay the bill, to do a top hotel for 5 nights would require 160,000 points. Assuming our member is a PLT and 40,000 points came from megabonuses, the remaining 120,000 over 20 nights would be 6000 points per night, meaning a spend by our employers of $400 per night, $8,000 overall. And remember to get the 40,000 megabonus you have to do the 20 nights in 3 months, so it really only works for the regulars spending other peoples money.
To reverse this around, assuming no status and that your stays were only 4 or 5 nights per year, at weekends, on rooms averaging 100 ($150) per night it would take you about 20-25 YEARS to stay the 106 nights to get that 5 night (160,000 points) break (remember, our PLT can manage that in just 3 months!). Against that with Priceline you should get a weekend 4* room for about 70 night ($100) thus saving yourself the price of a free night once every 2 or 3 nights.
Having said all that it is fair to point out that you'll not find Marriotts best 5 star hotels lurking around on priceline, yes, I think you'll find the majority of Marriotts inventory there, but its unlikely the likes of Londons Grosvenor House and New Yorks Marquis will ever make its way there, so the only way to stay at Marriotts very top establishments is to "pay". Cash or Points. I can vouch that a lot of us do use our points for the very best of Marriotts inventory, thus squeezing a bit more value out of the scheme, but the simple fact remains that it just isn't worthwhile unless you're a regular...
Last edited by BrightlyBob; May 11, 2010 at 7:44 am
#7




Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: PHX
Posts: 4,815
You can redeem marriot points for "travel packages" which give you miles and e-coupons or paper coupons for multi-night stays. Some people do an exchange when they need the miles, even if they don't have an immediate need for the hotel vouchers.
I'm not certain whether such vouchers actually are transferrable or what the terms and conditions are, but I do see them on coupon connection from time to time, so it's worth taking a look.
#8
Join Date: Nov 2007
Programs: aa advantage, marriott rewards
Posts: 63
In NYC you will usually find that the points required for a stay do not offer a great value. I live about an hour out of Manhattan and visit about three times a year to see shows, museums or just sightsee. Although I have close to a million MRP's in my account I pay the cash rate on most visits. I can usually get a rate of around $200-$250 a night. In a CAT 8 hotel like the Marquis or the REN Times Square that equates to about .006 cents per point. I'd rather save the points for overseas trips where the room rates are closer to $500 a night and you get a better value for your points.
You might want to check out some of the non-chain hotels like the Hudson Hotel on 58th. They are running a special for $239 in August and it is a truly unique NYC hotel.
You might want to check out some of the non-chain hotels like the Hudson Hotel on 58th. They are running a special for $239 in August and it is a truly unique NYC hotel.
#9
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Winter Garden, FL
Programs: Delta DM-3MM United Gold-MM Marriott Lifetime Titanium Hertz President's Circle
Posts: 13,498
It is really tough to get a deal in NYC. And points don't provide good value, either.
Bruce
Bruce
#10

Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Raleigh, NC, USA
Posts: 302
I would also recommend checking the discount online sites such as priceline to see what deal you can get with them.
You can also get 10% off gift cards and airline miles on either Delta or USAirways. This would require that you purchase at least $1000 so you would need to be able to use that amount to be worth the entire 10% off. But anything charged to the room could be paid by the gift card. The links are below. Using a Marriott credit card for the purchase would also get you 5pts/$.
https://www.marriottvacationcardoffer.com/delta
https://www.marriottvacationcardoffer.com/usairways
You can also get 10% off gift cards and airline miles on either Delta or USAirways. This would require that you purchase at least $1000 so you would need to be able to use that amount to be worth the entire 10% off. But anything charged to the room could be paid by the gift card. The links are below. Using a Marriott credit card for the purchase would also get you 5pts/$.
https://www.marriottvacationcardoffer.com/delta
https://www.marriottvacationcardoffer.com/usairways

