FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Practical Travel Safety and Security Issues (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/practical-travel-safety-security-issues-686/)
-   -   A Completely Different Screening Experience (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/practical-travel-safety-security-issues/954415-completely-different-screening-experience.html)

VideoPaul May 20, 2009 3:27 pm


Originally Posted by manneca (Post 11754116)
I was screened yesterday at TLV and at EWR. TVL was wonderful. There were two people working the screening position. One sat behind the monitor and the other came forward to help me. Smiling, very polite. No shouting. Helped me arrange my items. I didn't have to take out my Kippie bag nor my camera. Just my laptop. Helped me put it in a bin. I took off my vest (loaded with electronics) and he put it in a bin for me.

At EWR, completely different experience. A woman TSO yelled at me because I wasn't moving my bins along as I unpacked all the junk: Kippie bag, laptop, camera, vest, jacket, shoes, and loaded my carryon bag and backpack. I told people behind me to go around me. I was trying to take up as little space as possible at the end of the table because I need about five bins. She just stood there, yelling at me. I ignored her basically because if I had moved my stuff along as I unpacked (a difficult task) I would have arrived at the screening machine without all my stuff in its proper position. How much does it take to have a little care and courtesy? Obviously more than TSA is willing to expend.

It is as simple as a mindset. When I was manager of a field office for a nonprofit, I taught my employees basic skills: smile, listen, help. TSA's approach seems to be indimidate, yell, don't listen, and for heaven's sake, don't help. This is why Americans who fly hate TSA.

And yet, somehow, they (Israel) have never had the air disasters and hijackings that we have. Part of the problem is that Israel's security is about SECURITY, not a job program. The second is that Israel doesn't give a tinker's dam about someone's finer sensitivities. They profile and they do not apologize for it.

Their security is the best in the world. Ours is a jobs program for the unemployable that is more worried about how we look to "citizens of the world" and to the American Confused Liberals Union than about actually keeping air transport safe.

But hey, at least we have snazzy blue shirts and tin badges so our screeners can feel better about themselves.

--PP

VideoPaul May 20, 2009 3:34 pm


Originally Posted by AngryMiller (Post 11754991)
At Schiphol and Helsinki the thing I noticed the most was how quiet the airport was when they don't have droning messages over the PA system. Nice.

Your attention please...The Department of Homeland Security has raised the threat level to...PLAID. Anyone thinking about anything that could conceivably be viewed as harmful will be stuffed into a newspaper vending box and dragged kicking and screaming from the terminal.

--PP

Spiny Lumpsucker May 20, 2009 3:45 pm

TSORon: I have a question for you though. If you by had had a knife in your pocket, just how friendly do you think those Israeli screeners would have been?

This has in fact happened to my husband, though in Sydney and not in TLV. The lady at security pointed out that he had a knife in his carry-on bag and after we had told her that we had passed the checkpoints in Munich, Heathrow and Sydney (we connected to another flight) she thanked us, felt sorry for having to throw away his beloved knife and called her colleagues at the other security checkpoint to talk about this. We did not have any trouble whatsoever and were on our way within minutes.

triehle May 20, 2009 4:48 pm


Originally Posted by Spiny Lumpsucker (Post 11780858)
This has in fact happened to my husband, though in Sydney and not in TLV. The lady at security pointed out that he had a knife in his carry-on bag and after we had told her that we had passed the checkpoints in Munich, Heathrow and Sydney (we connected to another flight) she thanked us, felt sorry for having to throw away his beloved knife and called her colleagues at the other security checkpoint to talk about this. We did not have any trouble whatsoever and were on our way within minutes.

Well, now that's a very weird story, you Spiny Lumpsucker. Don't they assume that anyone who wants to fly today must be a terrorist? That's how we do it here, you know.

Fredrik74 May 23, 2009 5:18 pm


Originally Posted by triehle (Post 11781233)
Well, now that's a very weird story, you [B]Spiny Lumpsucker. Don't they assume that anyone who wants to fly today must be a terrorist? That's how we do it here, you know.

Travellers can be illegal immigrants too. The lady at LAS the other day probably didn't know what to do with my Russian visa but then realized there were other pages in the passport to check as well. Lucky she didn't find some of the other visas in there. Not that I understand why it would be her business though,


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 6:20 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.