FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Practical Travel Safety and Security Issues (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/practical-travel-safety-security-issues-686/)
-   -   Will TSA pay for broken items (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/practical-travel-safety-security-issues/503650-will-tsa-pay-broken-items.html)

PatrickHenry1775 Dec 29, 2005 11:15 pm


Originally Posted by n5667
Right then and there, you should have asked to a speak with a supervisor - once the bag has been cleared, you're allowed to do what you wish with it. I don't even repack it; I'm just used to passengers usually preferring to repack the bag themselves.

The poster said that he did not have much time to make his rescheduled flight. When someone is trying to catch a flight, the last thing one needs to do after TSA screeners have ransacked his bags is to speak with a supervisor, who will do diddly squat.

bill63 Dec 30, 2005 6:13 am

Same
 
I have had to stand aside during a screening. They (TSA's) removed all of my things for examination. I remember it was difficult to even see what they were going through. Actually, it was a nice younger woman who proceeded to repack my things while the man stood there and watched me. Like I said, I could barely even see her repacking my things. Until reading this thread, I did not know I even had an option to request to repack my own things. The screening process seems pretty intimidating, and I'm 6', 220 lbs :p

I was never asked to repack my things. Luckily I keep phone(s) and such in a different compartment and my bag is sturdy enough to protect them. I carry 2-3 phones (US-gsm, China-cdma, and Japan-3g) and I woud be pretty peeved if any of them got broken by the TSA. It would be very hard to replace the China and Japan phones in the US also!

This place is becoming my second home and I learn more and more each day!

n5667 Jan 1, 2006 2:25 am


Originally Posted by bill63
I have had to stand aside during a screening. They (TSA's) removed all of my things for examination. I remember it was difficult to even see what they were going through. Actually, it was a nice younger woman who proceeded to repack my things while the man stood there and watched me. Like I said, I could barely even see her repacking my things. Until reading this thread, I did not know I even had an option to request to repack my own things. The screening process seems pretty intimidating, and I'm 6', 220 lbs :p

I was never asked to repack my things. Luckily I keep phone(s) and such in a different compartment and my bag is sturdy enough to protect them. I carry 2-3 phones (US-gsm, China-cdma, and Japan-3g) and I woud be pretty peeved if any of them got broken by the TSA. It would be very hard to replace the China and Japan phones in the US also!

This place is becoming my second home and I learn more and more each day!

If you were receiving additional screening, you could also have asked they wait to search the bags until you are present, and place your items beyond public reach.

AA2070 Jan 26, 2006 11:49 pm

Got a letter from the TSA today informing me that my claim process had been begun. Also included was a code that I could put into their website to check the status of my claim:

Code:

Control Number:    200601XXXXXXX
Claim Amount:  $538.74
Claim Status:  Assigned

Your claim has been assigned to a claims investigator in the Claims
 Management Office.  The investigator may contact you requesting
 clarification, receipts, repair estimates, or other necessary information.
 
Next Step
The investigator will make a recommendation to approve, offer a settlement,
or deny your claim.  Once a recommendation has been made, it must be
approved by a TSA Delegated Authority Official (DAO).  Once the DAO
approves the recommendation, you will receive a letter explaining the
adjudication and outlining your options.

I wonder what my "options" will be when the claim is denied, as I am sure that almost all invariably are.

PoliceStateSurvivor Jan 27, 2006 9:13 am


Originally Posted by AA2070
I wonder what my "options" will be when the claim is denied, as I am sure that almost all invariably are.

If your claim is denied, you can file a lawsuit in a Federal Court.

AA2070 Feb 23, 2006 9:48 am

Got a call today from an investigator asking me to fax a signed statement in. I did so, and the investigator told me that he is recommending that my claim be paid, but it will have to be reviewed by an accountability board and I will find out the final disposition in 4 weeks.........

johnep1 Feb 23, 2006 9:58 am


Originally Posted by AA2070
Got a call today from an investigator asking me to fax a signed statement in. I did so, and the investigator told me that he is recommending that my claim be paid, but it will have to be reviewed by an accountability board and I will find out the final disposition in 4 weeks.........

Wow! I'll believe it when you say you've received a check. Still, this looks promising.

AA2070 Apr 29, 2006 7:43 am

Code:

Control Number:          2006xxxxxxxxx
Claim Amount:        $538.74
Claim Status:        Claim Closed. Approved for $538.74

Claim Closed

^ ^ ^ Still, i'll believe it when I see the check...

AA2070 May 4, 2006 8:34 am

I got the check this morning! In typical TSA fashion, it was mailed to the wrong address - actually no address at all, just the street name. Good thing I live on a short street... Doesn't make me dislike them any less, but at least I've been repaid.

mkt May 7, 2006 7:00 pm

congratulations! I'm still waiting to hear back if my claim from this past March for 1 missing dress shirt and tears/rips on other clothing after my bag was searched in SJU.

Lumpy May 12, 2006 9:38 pm

Why, SHORRRE TSA will pay for broken items. Somehow. Remember, even Saddam Hussein made the Kurdish widows pay for the ammunition his Republican Guards used to murder their husbands...

Keep lining up and PAYING for it, folks.

bpratt May 13, 2006 10:42 pm

As an interested observer (i.e. TSA hasn't broken anything of mine yet, but since I travel with computers it may happen eventually), I'd like to thank you (TSASuper) for actually providing an informative, useful response.
Even though I often disagree with TSA positions, posters like you and Bart are, as far as I'm concerned, the good side of the TSA in that you present the TSA viewpoint without being defensive or "blame the traveller". So thank you. [Now if you could just stop the silly "shoes off" business :-)
And I'm sure you'll agree that its very good news that the OP got reimbursed for his damaged Treo. A few months isn't great speed, but then again I've been waiting 4 months to get a damaged Tag watch repaired by factory service, so long delays isn't just a TSA problem.

Bob


Originally Posted by TSASuper
After reading these posts, I went for a search through our SOP. It does state that we should offer to repack the bag. That would tell me that TSA employees don't necessarily have to repack the bag, but should offer to repack the bag as a courtesy for having to remove everything out of it.

I know that there are TSA employees that either stick to "I have to repack it" or "Here's your items, you can repack it." I can't do anything about those airports, but at my own, I've made it a point for every employee to offer to help repack. I think it's only right to offer help. I know I wouldn't like to get my backpack returned to me with all the contents in a bin and be told "Have a nice flight."

Just on a side note, I can't stand to use the word "officer" since there are no LEO characteristics. So since I can't refer to us as screeners, I use the word employees. That's just me.


PoliceStateSurvivor May 15, 2006 10:35 am


Originally Posted by TSASuper
I know I wouldn't like to get my backpack returned to me with all the contents in a bin and be told "Have a nice flight."

My suitcase was once returned to me stuffed in way that it would never close, which made it necessatry for me to unpack and repack it. The screener did say "Have a nice flight." with a disgusting smirk :mad: .

As if that was not enough, her response to my attempt to complain was: "See the police officer over there? I'll call him over if you do not shut up".

By the way, I had to do my unpacking and repacking on a dirty floor. They needed the table for their next "selectee" or whatever they call it.

Care to comment, TSASuper? What would you do if you observed a screener act this way?

L-1011 May 15, 2006 1:11 pm


Originally Posted by PoliceStateSurvivor
As if that was not enough, her response to my attempt to complain was: "See the police officer over there? I'll call him over if you do not shut up".

A screener in DFW tried that with me once. I've never seen anyone drop a subject as fast as he did, when I said: "Yes, that's a very good idea, why don't you ask him to come over?" :D


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:33 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.