FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Practical Travel Safety and Security Issues (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/practical-travel-safety-security-issues-686/)
-   -   TSA going through wallets now? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/practical-travel-safety-security-issues/1211068-tsa-going-through-wallets-now.html)

Ancien Maestro May 2, 2011 7:51 pm

I've never experienced my wallet rifled through.. but we've had the diaper bag searched.

bajajoes May 3, 2011 6:22 pm

Envelope Mail In Carryon
 
:cool: Thanks for the info "Ink".
I will address to myself and then get it hand cancelled at the PO before flying.

treznor May 3, 2011 9:03 pm


Originally Posted by bajajoes (Post 16323713)
:cool: Thanks for the info "Ink".
I will address to myself and then get it hand cancelled at the PO before flying.

Really don't know if that will do what you think it will. Will they be able to force you to open it? No. Can they then not allow you to fly? Yes. Right or wrong (I think most agree on that answer), the reality is what it is at the moment.

Caradoc May 3, 2011 9:15 pm


Originally Posted by InkUnderNails (Post 16317541)
They can still deny you access to the sterile area.

Based on what we've heard from people claiming to be TSA employees, they can deny you access to the sterile area for any reason they can come up with.

After all - they don't have to justify their decision to anyone - and if asked, they'll just claim that it's "SSI."

This is what happens when you give idiots the idea that they actually have power.

Wally Bird May 4, 2011 6:57 am


Originally Posted by Caradoc (Post 16324463)
This is what happens when you give idiots the idea that they actually have power.

The problem is they do. Arguably not legal nor Constitutional but they can still make you miss your flight and otherwise ruin your day :( .

FaustsAccountant May 4, 2011 6:19 pm


Originally Posted by Wally Bird (Post 16325929)
The problem is they do. Arguably not legal nor Constitutional but they can still make you miss your flight and otherwise ruin your day :( .

Or put you in the 'fish bowl' for a limitless amount of time.

Caradoc May 4, 2011 10:52 pm


Originally Posted by Wally Bird (Post 16325929)
The problem is they do.

No, they don't.

But enough people believe they do to make it possible.

Think about it - if every passenger forced every TSA clerk to adhere to what we know about the rules, the checkpoint would come to a complete stop.

How long do you really think that could possibly last?

What do you think would happen if the real LEOs started telling the TSA clerks to knock off the attempts at using the LEOs as the punitive measure instead of telling passengers to "just play along with the dog and pony show" as Stacey Armato was told to do?

mareh May 5, 2011 1:23 pm


Originally Posted by fschmidt (Post 16309951)
After having my wallet checked at Manchester-Boston in 2009, I changed two travel habits.

My wallet is now locked in my carry-on and I no longer fly out of MHT.

I did not know that Barny Fife had so many brothers and cousins until I had to deal with the TSA at this airport. Second only to Bloomington, IL.

Totally agree with you on MHT. I had a very bad experience there myself.

Loren Pechtel May 5, 2011 9:32 pm


Originally Posted by halls120 (Post 16313804)
Good advice, and something I've been doing for years.

What I don't understand, though, is how TSA can justify a TSO leafing through someone's wallet and examining the cash contained within.

Because the TSA is really about the drug war.

Loren Pechtel May 5, 2011 9:34 pm


Originally Posted by jordanmills (Post 16315510)
I loved pulling that in New York. In Texas, we're required to present both ID and concealed handgun license if an LEO requires our ID. Of course the ASSs aren't LEOs, but it's habit. So I'd hand over both, with the card with "CONCEALED HANDGUN LICENSE" in big red block letters on top. Without fail, their eyes would get wide and they'd start acting nervous...

Huh? I thought such laws only applied if you were carrying.

Wally Bird May 6, 2011 9:04 am


Originally Posted by Caradoc (Post 16330760)
No, they don't.

But enough people believe they do to make it possible.

Think about it - if every passenger forced every TSA clerk to adhere to what we know about the rules, the checkpoint would come to a complete stop.

How long do you really think that could possibly last?

What do you think would happen if the real LEOs started telling the TSA clerks to knock off the attempts at using the LEOs as the punitive measure instead of telling passengers to "just play along with the dog and pony show" as Stacey Armato was told to do?

I'm not talking about "what if" scenarios. Right NOW, checkpoint workers have the subsumed power to deny a passenger entry to the secure area for any reason if they want to. Yes, you can file a complaint (good luck with that), instigate a lawsuit if you have money to throw away, or simply bolt from the checkpoint and see how far you get.

In case I wasn't clear enough, this is NOT RIGHT but it is the current situation. You want to board a flight, they can and do make it so that you don't. You don't think that's power and you don't think they know it ?

Combat Medic May 6, 2011 9:10 am


Originally Posted by Loren Pechtel (Post 16336692)
Huh? I thought such laws only applied if you were carrying.

It is a best practice to hand it over every time. Otherwise when the cop runs your license and sees that you have it he will wonder why you weren't upfront.

Caradoc May 6, 2011 9:28 am


Originally Posted by Wally Bird (Post 16338715)
IYou don't think that's power and you don't think they know it ?

I think they know they've got implied authority - but no power. Power != authority.

redii May 6, 2011 9:53 am

Thanks for the advice, folks. After having my wallet sifted through in CMH, I've stopped carrying -anything- in my pockets, unless I'm in LGA where I have to carry my BP. :-D After TDC, I slip my ID and BP into my carryon, lock it, and smile as it sails through the x-ray.

Caradoc May 6, 2011 11:03 am


Originally Posted by redii (Post 16338974)
After TDC, I slip my ID and BP into my carryon, lock it, and smile as it sails through the x-ray.

It's a reasonable precaution, but it's not hard to open a zippered bag with a lock on it and leave no trace when the bag is re-closed.

If I'm ever forced by circumstances to fly while the blue-shirted jackboots still occupy the terminals, I'll be using a hard-sided carry-on with a good keyless padlock on it.

wboll May 6, 2011 1:22 pm

Flying through MKE yesterday I put my money clip in the bin and saw it enter the machine. The blue-shirted clown raised his hand and called over another wannabe cop. He looked at my money clip and asked why I had foreign currency in it (Canadian dollars mixed with USD). I told him it was none of his business. I saw a cop and waved him over and told him I was being asked questions that did not pertain to airport security and I wanted my rights protected. The blue-shirted baboon handed over my money clip and I proceeded to count the money in front of him saying out loud if any of it is missing I will ask the police officer to make an arrest (I was joking under my breath). I think it's time to threaten our politicians that if they don't do something we won't elect/re-elect them. Funny, if they were forced to go through this there would be changes in a heart beat.

Caradoc May 10, 2011 9:37 am

I wonder how well one of these would go over with the wallet-pawing crowd.

MDtR-Chicago May 10, 2011 9:43 am


Originally Posted by wboll (Post 16340178)
He looked at my money clip and asked why I had foreign currency in it (Canadian dollars mixed with USD). I told him it was none of his business. I saw a cop and waved him over and told him I was being asked questions that did not pertain to airport security and I wanted my rights protected.

Well done and a very appropriate way to handle it. ^

ElPasoPilot May 10, 2011 9:54 am


Originally Posted by wboll (Post 16340178)
Flying through MKE yesterday I put my money clip in the bin and saw it enter the machine. The blue-shirted clown raised his hand and called over another wannabe cop. He looked at my money clip and asked why I had foreign currency in it (Canadian dollars mixed with USD). I told him it was none of his business. I saw a cop and waved him over and told him I was being asked questions that did not pertain to airport security and I wanted my rights protected. The blue-shirted baboon handed over my money clip and I proceeded to count the money in front of him saying out loud if any of it is missing I will ask the police officer to make an arrest (I was joking under my breath). I think it's time to threaten our politicians that if they don't do something we won't elect/re-elect them. Funny, if they were forced to go through this there would be changes in a heart beat.


Great work in effectively retraining a screener.

Immediate actions like the poster above took, and/or taping and publishing such encounters seem to be the only way to get the TSA's attention.

Note how quickly PV counters the you tube video or blog post of the day, vs the typical response received on a formal complaint.

I imagine that the screener who had the LEO brought over will think twice before assuming similar improper authority again. He may never even remember the event 2 months later, when/if the "official" submitted complaint makes it back to him.

halls120 May 10, 2011 10:26 am


Originally Posted by wboll (Post 16340178)
Flying through MKE yesterday I put my money clip in the bin and saw it enter the machine. The blue-shirted clown raised his hand and called over another wannabe cop. He looked at my money clip and asked why I had foreign currency in it (Canadian dollars mixed with USD).

I'd really like to get Bart, or SATTSO, or GSOLTSO to explain how, after all of the supposed training TSO's get, some of their colleagues still behave in such an incorrect manner. Why someone is carrying Canadian or any other currency poses no threat to aviation security.

Yet another reason why TSA is the agency Americans love to hate.

Loren Pechtel May 10, 2011 2:51 pm


Originally Posted by Caradoc (Post 16360364)
I wonder how well one of these would go over with the wallet-pawing crowd.

Are lighters now allowed?

Princess Cruiser May 27, 2012 7:56 pm

Billfold Inspections are Happening in Tulsa
 
Tulsa TSA went through my billfold Thursday before last even though they had zero cause . I guess they were looking for some kind of imaginary dollar bill threat. I'm a mild mannered senior citizen. Tulsa's TSA has historically always been very unfriendly. I didn't opt out of anything. I just stepped out of the millimeter wave machine and the guy put his hand inside my pants and asked me to hand over my billfold which I had held above my head, as instructed, while inside the machine. I had removed my belt and watch and had absolutely nothing in my pockets.

InkUnderNails May 27, 2012 8:03 pm

This is the reason I lock mine in my carry on. Anything on your person is subject to search at a whim of the screener.

Always Flyin Jun 2, 2012 1:47 pm


Originally Posted by Mr. Elliott (Post 16316545)
The state agency issuing the CHL definitely would fall under the “equivalent” portion of the TSA requirements.

No, it wouldn't.

The TSA reference is to state issued ID cards by the DMV or whatever the name of the agency is in that state.

cottonmather0 Jun 2, 2012 3:43 pm


Originally Posted by Always Flyin (Post 18686169)
No, it wouldn't.

The TSA reference is to state issued ID cards by the DMV or whatever the name of the agency is in that state.

In Texas the Department of Public Safety (DPS = state police) issue both DL's and CHL's.

Always Flyin Jun 9, 2012 3:39 pm


Originally Posted by cottonmather0 (Post 18686593)
In Texas the Department of Public Safety (DPS = state police) issue both DL's and CHL's.

Fair enough, but what do you think the chances are of the TSA clerk having the CCW permit in his ID book?

Yosemite Jun 9, 2012 4:42 pm

TSA: The Sleazy Agency
 
Today they are going through our wallet. Tomorrow their dirty hands will be all over our genitals. All done in the name of "homeland security". When will it be stopped? It looks like the real terrorists are the TSA agents themselves.

iluv2fly Jun 11, 2012 11:22 pm


Originally Posted by Yosemite (Post 18728368)
Today they are going through our wallet. Tomorrow their dirty hands will be all over our genitals. All done in the name of "homeland security". When will it be stopped? It looks like the real terrorists are the TSA agents themselves.

Bolding mine.

Tomorrow? Where have you been? They have been doing this for some time now. :(

tinman435 Jun 12, 2012 11:25 am


Originally Posted by iluv2fly (Post 18740790)
Bolding mine.

Tomorrow? Where have you been? They have been doing this for some time now. :(

+1 Siriously, where have you been?

PurduExpat37 Jun 25, 2012 12:57 pm


Originally Posted by dimramon (Post 16309944)
Last week, I opted out at IND. My wallet was in my pocket and I was told they needed to examine it.
I was given the choice of it being run through the x-ray machine or a manual inspection "that would require them to dump everything out into a bin".
When I asked what the motivation was for the procedure, I was told it was SOP and could not shared with me. :rolleyes:

IND is my home airport and have not experienced this-- yet.

If (i.e. when) if happens to me, I'll press for a reason as to why they need to inspect it.

dan1431 Jul 3, 2012 9:48 am

I was going through IAH and TSA employee picked up my wallet and started to open it, when I saw him, I immediately motioned for the police office standing just a few feet away.

The office came over and after being told that TSA employee is going through my wallet, the police office asked the TSA employee if he saw anything suspicious on the X-Ray, when the Employee said no, the police officer told him to hand over the wallet to the passenger and then asked me to check it to ensure nothing was missing.

I checked it as instructed and upon finding everything in its place, the police officer reminded the TSA employee he is still able to be arrested for violating Texas law and walked off.

I collected the rest of my things and thanked the officer for assisting me, he said not a problem, he was just doing his job. I thanked him again and asked where I could send in a commendation for him and said to check the Houston Police Website and gave me his Badge number and full name.

Dan

lovely15 Jul 3, 2012 9:51 am


Originally Posted by dan1431 (Post 18863702)
I checked it as instructed and upon finding everything in its place, the police officer reminded the TSA employee he is still able to be arrested for violating Texas law and walked off.

Too bad he didn't just go ahead and arrest him.

goalie Jul 3, 2012 11:16 am


Originally Posted by dan1431 (Post 18863702)
I was going through IAH and TSA employee picked up my wallet and started to open it, when I saw him, I immediately motioned for the police office standing just a few feet away.

The office came over and after being told that TSA employee is going through my wallet, the police office asked the TSA employee if he saw anything suspicious on the X-Ray, when the Employee said no, the police officer told him to hand over the wallet to the passenger and then asked me to check it to ensure nothing was missing.

I checked it as instructed and upon finding everything in its place, the police officer reminded the TSA employee he is still able to be arrested for violating Texas law and walked off.

I collected the rest of my things and thanked the officer for assisting me, he said not a problem, he was just doing his job. I thanked him again and asked where I could send in a commendation for him and said to check the Houston Police Website and gave me his Badge number and full name.

Dan

Nice job Dan ^ and nice job by the Houston Police Officer ^

FriendlySkies Jul 3, 2012 11:23 am


Originally Posted by dan1431 (Post 18863702)
I was going through IAH and TSA employee picked up my wallet and started to open it, when I saw him, I immediately motioned for the police office standing just a few feet away.

The office came over and after being told that TSA employee is going through my wallet, the police office asked the TSA employee if he saw anything suspicious on the X-Ray, when the Employee said no, the police officer told him to hand over the wallet to the passenger and then asked me to check it to ensure nothing was missing.

I checked it as instructed and upon finding everything in its place, the police officer reminded the TSA employee he is still able to be arrested for violating Texas law and walked off.

I collected the rest of my things and thanked the officer for assisting me, he said not a problem, he was just doing his job. I thanked him again and asked where I could send in a commendation for him and said to check the Houston Police Website and gave me his Badge number and full name.

Dan

It's nice to see that at least a couple cops are willing to stand up against the clerks. If only that trend would spread to other airports...

Paul56 Jul 3, 2012 11:52 am

http://www.tsa.gov/press/goodcatch/1...let_knife.shtm

goalie Jul 3, 2012 12:38 pm


Originally Posted by Paul56 (Post 18864508)

And in that case, the wallet should have been looked thru but as noted (with the bolding and enlarging mine)


Originally Posted by dan1431
I was going through IAH and TSA employee picked up my wallet and started to open it, when I saw him, I immediately motioned for the police office standing just a few feet away.

The office came over and after being told that TSA employee is going through my wallet, the police officer asked the TSA employee if he saw anything suspicious on the X-Ray, when the Employee said no, the police officer told him to hand over the wallet to the passengerand then asked me to check it to ensure nothing was missing...


Pesky Monkey Jul 3, 2012 8:16 pm


Originally Posted by Paul56 (Post 18864508)

As noted, knives show up on the x-ray. The TSO was rooting through a wallet that already cleared the x-ray. (btw, knives are not a threat to airline security).

dan1431 Jul 4, 2012 8:24 am

Interestingly, I was surprised the TSA employee was honest, he could have said, I did see something and I am not sure what the police officer would have done.

As I see it, if he saw something I understand the need to clear it, but to simply root around something as important as a wallet just seems stupid and risky for the TSA employee singularly and the agency as a whole.

As a side note, I was talking with a friend who works for the FBI (as an accountant, not too sexy of a position) and he said that most FBI agents (that he talks with) feel that TSA employees should not have the title of Officer and instead should just be civil servants.

He said that by calling them officers it does lead to this kind of wallet searching behavior, if they feel they are law enforcement, than they have more rights than the common man.

Dan

Caradoc Jul 4, 2012 8:56 am


Originally Posted by dan1431 (Post 18869051)
As I see it, if he saw something I understand the need to clear it, but to simply root around something as important as a wallet just seems stupid and risky for the TSA employee singularly and the agency as a whole.

How so? Their cameras never work when they show the TSA doing something wrong.

All they'd do is trot out that tired old chestnut about how "...TSA holds all of its employees to the highest professional and ethical standards and has zero tolerance for misconduct in the workplace..." and claim that the employee(s) in question were being "retrained."

I don't see much risk for the TSA or the individual screener just for rooting through someone's wallet, even if they took their driver's license and credit cards to make photocopies of them (which has happened!)

stifle Jul 4, 2012 9:55 am


Originally Posted by Caradoc (Post 18869235)
How so? Their cameras never work when they show the TSA doing something wrong.

All they'd do is trot out that tired old chestnut about how "...TSA holds all of its employees to the highest professional and ethical standards and has zero tolerance for misconduct in the workplace..." and claim that the employee(s) in question were being "retrained."

Disagree. They would trot out that tired old chestnut about how "the reports and statements the TSA has received indicate some inconsistencies with how the incident has been described".


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 9:40 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.