I agree with the selections

But no-one for the Concorde Room? It is better from the Cathay's at HKG.

Can't say about the QF's at SYD and MEL as I have never been there.

Can't refer to Concord room at LHR as I have never been at T5's (I did use T4's several times over the years).

I think that the only serious let down on Concorde is the lack of bathtubs :td: (And the showers are not beautiful at all with this sucking noise)

Are there any on QF's at MEL or SYD?

T5 has bathtubs in the arrivals lounge

I think galleries t3 at lhr is the best, always quiet

No Bathtubs at MEL or SYD Flounges.

If I was ranking them based purely on OWE status

1. QF Melbourne F (love the view and a great size as has been posted before)
2. QF Sydney F

Then some distance to
3. BA T3 GF same as T5 but much quieter especially during the day and also the dining area has a great view compared to the T5 lounge.
4. BA T5
4. A very controversial choice here but I always liked the T4 AA Flagship lounge at LAX I guess it is probably because I have flown in from a horrible admirals club so the ability to find something to eat and drink always impressed me. Also preferred the LAX one to JFK.
5. CX WING and the PIER pretty much the same just different location although with the Pier you can always get some noodles from the business lounge. I for one was pretty unimpressed recently with CX lounges I was expecting more.
6. JAL First class lounge in Tokyo is okay gets very crowded though


Best business class lounges I think Cathay have the best in HKG

The LHR T4 Concorde lounge was always the place to be when you saw your Concorde being docked at the gate ready for your next 4 hrs of constant flow Champagne ... :p