FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   MilesBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz-370/)
-   -   Average Monthly Points (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/milesbuzz/1431539-average-monthly-points.html)

ayya Jan 25, 2013 4:23 pm


Originally Posted by lkar (Post 20124226)
It's already difficult enough to explain to colleagues taking the entire family to New York, Hawaii and Europe in premium cabins in one year.

Good one. :) ^

babypuwet Jan 25, 2013 4:24 pm


Originally Posted by MilesGator (Post 20122166)
I'm also curious about this (and I have investigated a little on Google :D ). Not counting the initial sign up offer, you get 100 AA miles per $1000 in their checking account.

That means to get 20k AA miles/month someone has to have $200,000 sitting in a checking account. Lets say those are worth 2 cpm, that's a value of $400/month. Now lets say they get redeemed for business class, that's probably closer to 4-5 cpm(? just a guess as I haven't had the luxury of redeeming for biz/1st) so they are getting a value of $800-1000/month. If you were to park 200k in some retirement/investment account that gets 5% return (doesn't seem unreasonable to me), your value would be $10,000/month.

Why is anyone parking 200k in a checking account? I love to travel, but it just doesn't seem like the smartest way to stash your money.

your math is way off!!!! there is no legit place in this world that offers 5% return per month. I think you mean 5% per year, which means $10,000 per year. Thats about the same rate of return for 240,000 miles. But it depends how you redeem it. 220,000 would get you a rtw ticket on AA for up to 50,000 miles, that alone could be worth around $20,000

ayya Jan 25, 2013 4:37 pm


Originally Posted by lkar (Post 20123093)
If you can guarantee a 5 percent yearly return after taxes on a $200,000 investment that has zero risk whatsoever to principal and is completely liquid, please share.

I am not aware of anything close. Yes, you can possibly get better than 5 percent if you put your principal at risk. And maybe you can start to get upwards of 3 or 4 percent if you lock up your money.

But if I had $200k and did not want to put it at risk, and also potentially needed it somewhere other than in a maturing-nonliquid investment, 360,000 miles a year is pretty good.

How are you getting 360,000 miles a year? Isn't it 240,000 miles a year for the 200K deposit.

I agree it is way better return than most (if not all) investments where you want the principal to be liquid and not at risk.

mrxcoffee Jan 25, 2013 4:47 pm

Earn about 20k UR points a month.

About 15k through mfg spend. Not a huge amount of points but enough to get the family to Japan and another mainland (we're in Hawaii) trip once year.

Also since it's not a huge amount of points I think the risk factor is somewhat low. As many pointed out it's not a 100% risk free game we're engaging in so I only take as much risk as my stomache will allow. :)

AlohaDaveKennedy Jan 25, 2013 5:04 pm

Try being a cardinal who gets to explain visits to 114 countries, dozens of Hawaiian trips, round the world trips every other year, and a monthly commute to Florida and a monthly trip abroad. None of my brethren fly off to Monaco for the weekend or pick up Valentines Day gifts in Paris.:D


Originally Posted by lkar (Post 20124226)
It's already difficult enough to explain to colleagues taking the entire family to New York, Hawaii and Europe in premium cabins in one year.


AlohaDaveKennedy Jan 25, 2013 5:15 pm

Wanna bet - the RoR is way higher. 29% a day in paper recycling (20/.69), infinite a month in electron recycling (20/0). Tax free, of course. Assumes 1k in miles equates to $20 so adjust as desired (some may argue a $5 value). Still over 5% return a day. Welcome to The New Economy aka Looking Glass World.


Originally Posted by babypuwet (Post 20124614)
...there is no legit place in this world that offers 5% return per month...


lkar Jan 25, 2013 7:04 pm


Originally Posted by ayya (Post 20124696)
How are you getting 360,000 miles a year? Isn't it 240,000 miles a year for the 200K deposit.

So, there are not 18 months in a year?

Ok, ok. Math is not my strong suit. What's 120,000 miles among friends?

shopper711 Jan 25, 2013 7:35 pm


Originally Posted by yoonny (Post 20119150)
Damn, I thought I was doing well with about 15k on average. I need to work much harder. Business owners have an unfair advantage.

Start a business. :)

socialfire Jan 25, 2013 7:51 pm

As a broke college student, this thread is making me salivate.

Happy Jan 25, 2013 8:07 pm


Originally Posted by MilesGator (Post 20122166)
I'm also curious about this (and I have investigated a little on Google :D ). Not counting the initial sign up offer, you get 100 AA miles per $1000 in their checking account.

That means to get 20k AA miles/month someone has to have $200,000 sitting in a checking account. Lets say those are worth 2 cpm, that's a value of $400/month. Now lets say they get redeemed for business class, that's probably closer to 4-5 cpm(? just a guess as I haven't had the luxury of redeeming for biz/1st) so they are getting a value of $800-1000/month. If you were to park 200k in some retirement/investment account that gets 5% return (doesn't seem unreasonable to me), your value would be $10,000/month.

Why is anyone parking 200k in a checking account? I love to travel, but it just doesn't seem like the smartest way to stash your money.

I only hope you improve your math so you would really know how to calculate a return. Therefore you would understand better how much your nest egg would worth 10, 20 years from now based on the 5% assumption...

On top of that 5% return is quite difficult to achieve in today's 0% interest rate environment - assuming it is almost a guarantee as you think it is not unreasonable ... does that include the risk factor?

Happy Jan 25, 2013 8:21 pm


Originally Posted by ayya (Post 20124696)
How are you getting 360,000 miles a year? Isn't it 240,000 miles a year for the 200K deposit.

I agree it is way better return than most (if not all) investments where you want the principal to be liquid and not at risk.

A hypothesis Pretax number because if you park the money that earn monetary interest, you are taxed on the earning.

360K pre tax, 240K after tax, at a 33% tax bracket.


Originally Posted by lkar (Post 20125451)
So, there are not 18 months in a year?

Ok, ok. Math is not my strong suit. What's 120,000 miles among friends?

Actually you can view the 360K as a pre-tax number and 240K the after tax number because a monetary earning would be taxable. And your number actually could be correct looking in this context at a 33% tax bracket. ;)

LAX88 Jan 25, 2013 8:33 pm

Let's keep in mind that this thread isn't about one person's mistake as to APY and MPY. To be sure, we'd all keep our money in an account offering 5% a month over an account offering 1% in AA miles.

Now, back to the actual topic of this thread. I average 30,000 UR, 8,000 BA (working towards Travel Together Ticket), and 5,000 SPG in a month by manufacturing spend. Actual spend yields roughly 5,000 in a mix of SPG and UR, depending on my mood/which card comes out of my wallet more easily.

skywalk Jan 25, 2013 8:38 pm

what ia an AP account?

Happy Jan 25, 2013 8:43 pm


Originally Posted by skywalk (Post 20125824)
what ia an AP account?

http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/miles...-payments.html

sam_goh Jan 25, 2013 8:50 pm

I'm currently doing 2 bluebirds + 4 APs a month in manuf spend. Along with some paypal goodness for the savings account. Guess I need to expand the number of bluebirds.

OHijAAzi73 Jan 25, 2013 8:53 pm

Mostly manufactured spend and not counting miles and points earned through travel or credit card churning signup bonuses...:

100k UR across 2xIB and 2x Ink-plus @ office stores
30k HH @ drug stores (ending soon sadly)
10k AA using Bankdirect
2k AP (Various programs)

500k-1 MM /Year through credit card churning that include wife .

Like what others said these are NOT free and it cost ALOT of time and effort (like a part time second job) and also cost some fees but its worth it if you want to travel in style and visit places you never dreamed of.

Having said that there is always a risk of being shut down/financial reviews /closure of accounts using these methods ...

ayya Jan 25, 2013 11:35 pm


Originally Posted by OHijAAzi73 (Post 20125883)
Mostly manufactured spend and not counting miles and points earned through travel or credit card churning signup bonuses...:

100k UR across 2xIB and 2x Ink-plus @ office stores
30k HH @ drug stores (ending soon sadly)
10k AA using Bankdirect
2k AP (Various programs)

500k-1 MM /Year through credit card churning that include wife .

Like what others said these are NOT free and it cost ALOT of time and effort (like a part time second job) and also cost some fees but its worth it if you want to travel in style and visit places you never dreamed of.

Having said that there is always a risk of being shut down/financial reviews /closure of accounts using these methods ...

Looks like your are doing 5K/per ink card at @office stories on 4 cards. How along have you been doing this? I am worried of doing more than 2K/card per month on the 2 ink cards I have. Worried about chase closing the accounts.

Dr Jabadski Jan 26, 2013 12:38 am


Originally Posted by Tr60 (Post 20123625)
This thread is a BIG eye opener! 2012 was my first year churning cards netting 355K in bonuses. I thought I was on a good start until I read this thread. Can some one tell please what these acronyms stand for:
IB
OD
GC

Regarding manufactured spend, can someone point me please on how to do it on Amazon Payment and other potential methods? Excuse my ignorance.
I got the Bank Direct method.

Men & women of FT, you are amazing!!!!

I’m not an expert on these things and I didn’t stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night but I didn’t see an answer to your question so here goes. Hopefully those more knowledgeable will correct my errors.

IB: Ink Bold, a Chase charge (or credit) card which earns Ultimate Rewards (UR) points which can be transferred to any of several different airline and hotel programs and also earns multiple points, 5 per dollar, at certain types of stores (office supply I believe).

OD: Office Depot, an excellent place to charge a lot of purchases on your IB card (because you will get 5 points per dollar).

GC: Gift Card(s), I believe can be purchased with a credit card and then used sometime later (helpful for meeting a time limited spend requirement for a credit card) and might also be used when a credit card is not accepted.

I’m completely unfamiliar with Amazon Payment (?AP).

BTW, I’ve found that I can learn a great deal by Googling things and adding “Flyertalk” in the search field. For example “Amazon Payment Flyertalk” or “Bluebird Flyertalk”.

BREAK

Re: BankDirect, there are some long threads on the American Airlines forum all about BankDirect. I recall reading on one of those threads a year or 2 ago about folks who had significantly more than $200,000 on deposit with BankDirect. Suggest Google “BankDirect Flyertalk”.

Hope this helps.

pointspinnacle Jan 26, 2013 6:37 am


Originally Posted by OHijAAzi73 (Post 20125883)
Mostly manufactured spend and not counting miles and points earned through travel or credit card churning signup bonuses...:

100k UR across 2xIB and 2x Ink-plus @ office stores
30k HH @ drug stores (ending soon sadly)
10k AA using Bankdirect
2k AP (Various programs)

500k-1 MM /Year through credit card churning that include wife .

Like what others said these are NOT free and it cost ALOT of time and effort (like a part time second job) and also cost some fees but its worth it if you want to travel in style and visit places you never dreamed of.

Having said that there is always a risk of being shut down/financial reviews /closure of accounts using these methods ...


Nevermind

hiltonlondon2009 Jan 26, 2013 8:54 am

For me, approximately $6,000 in travel expenses (for work) per month (airfare, cars, hotels).

$1,000 for other expenses (personal expenses like groceries, dining out, etc).

OHijAAzi73 Jan 26, 2013 1:21 pm

About few months ,the reason I'am doing that amount is the nearest OD stores are about 60 miles away ,so I visit them on a weekend and buy about 2-3 k per card twice a month ,I also take advantage of staples,Officemax promotions on the lower denominations Visa/Mastercard GC that they run from time to time but liquidating them are PIA,although I use them for everyday spend .

Yes the risk is there ,but I put other spend as well on the Ink cards not just office stores ,so do what you feel comfortable with.

AlohaDaveKennedy Jan 26, 2013 1:33 pm

AKA the Jungle, Jungleland


Originally Posted by Happy (Post 20125842)


AlohaDaveKennedy Jan 26, 2013 1:39 pm

So I gotta "KIVA" the Pentagon with lots of little amounts? How is their creditwortiness? I trust my KIVA investments in Paraguay, but the Pentagon is backed by the good faith of the United States. Ain't that the deadbeat country with the runaway spending or am I thinking Greece?:D


Originally Posted by rajuabju (Post 20124448)
Isnt the max only $100 for CC funding? thats what I recall... so unless you are going to open up dozens of accounts ... HMMM... lol


AlohaDaveKennedy Jan 26, 2013 1:48 pm

Get a Chase credit card. How about that free Amtrak one for starters? Then you can really get an education.:cool:


Originally Posted by socialfire (Post 20125617)
As a broke college student, this thread is making me salivate.


jcmitchell21 Jan 28, 2013 5:32 am


Originally Posted by lkar (Post 20123093)
If you can guarantee a 5 percent yearly return after taxes on a $200,000 investment that has zero risk whatsoever to principal and is completely liquid, please share.

I am not aware of anything close. Yes, you can possibly get better than 5 percent if you put your principal at risk. And maybe you can start to get upwards of 3 or 4 percent if you lock up your money.

But if I had $200k and did not want to put it at risk, and also potentially needed it somewhere other than in a maturing-nonliquid investment, 360,000 miles a year is pretty good.

As a point-earning website, I was referring to 5% in points/cash. $200k can be leveraged to earn greater than 5% in a year in points.

AlohaDaveKennedy Jan 28, 2013 8:06 am

...or cash with a Chase cash back card (magic card tricks involving bank deposits)


Originally Posted by jcmitchell21 (Post 20137762)
As a point-earning website, I was referring to 5% in points/cash. $200k can be leveraged to earn greater than 5% in a year in points.


rajuabju Jan 28, 2013 8:13 am


Originally Posted by josephstern (Post 20124454)
Yet, we're also living in California . . .

Even with the ridiculous taxes on "the rich" (of whom, many are not actually rich) 70 degree Sundays in January are hard to give up :)

shoreline Jan 28, 2013 9:27 am


Originally Posted by rajuabju (Post 20138465)
Even with the ridiculous taxes on "the rich" (of whom, many are not actually rich) 70 degree Sundays in January are hard to give up :)

try the cost of living in Hawaii.:p
(not that I live there, but been looking at the stats--they will really set someone off to say 'holy manoly')


........and back to the topic at hand (time for the popcorn).

It appears many like the sign up bonuses, many like the VR's and various ways of spending, and many use both. Some of the numbers are real eyeopeners.

farwest101 Jan 28, 2013 10:59 pm

nevermind.

ckgunn01 Jan 28, 2013 11:55 pm

Leave your ridiculous politics to other sites. I dont't care how much you make or what you think of Raegan. I just want info on maximizing my points so I can take my family to Hawaii in style.

AlohaDaveKennedy Jan 29, 2013 5:58 am


Originally Posted by ckgunn01 (Post 20143925)
Leave your ridiculous politics to other sites. I dont't care how much you make or what you think of Raegan. I just want info on maximizing my points so I can take my family to Hawaii in style.


AlohaDaveKennedy Jan 29, 2013 6:04 am

Geez - let's hope they spell his name, Reagan, right when his dollar coin comes out. Else staff at the mint will have to steal the misprints like the last time around.:p


Originally Posted by ckgunn01 (Post 20143925)
Leave your ridiculous politics to other sites. I dont't care how much you make or what you think of Raegan. I just want info on maximizing my points so I can take my family to Hawaii in style.


2Queens Feb 1, 2013 8:44 pm

average monthly points
 
85k in last 2 months,
No flying, cc bonus rewards and 3k in normal monthly bills.

webazoid Feb 9, 2013 12:01 pm

In past month, i got 8k miles to meet 8k spending requirement of amex plat 100k and citi aax2 50k x2. 7k was manufactured.

redtop43 Feb 9, 2013 1:51 pm

Not counting signup bonuses, I would guess that I get about 7-8K/mo in manufactured points, $2-3K in legitimate charges, and 6K for actual flying and the multiplier bonuses associated with charging the tickets on CSP at the UR mall.

It's not worth starting a separate thread over, but I'd be curious to know how people's significant other participates, or doesn't. I have the best possible situation - Mrs. Redtop doesn't get involved, puts no restrictions on me, she just uses whatever credit card(s) I tell her to, and doesn't even care to know what cards I have applied for in her name. I make it easy in return by not switching cards on her more than every 6-12 months, and taking care of minimum spending without her. I'm sure some people's SO has the opposite attitude, an absolute ban on extra applications in their name. I'm lucky in this regard, but I guess she's lucky also that she gets all the travel benefits with none of the work.

zeddy218 Feb 9, 2013 3:40 pm


It's not worth starting a separate thread over, but I'd be curious to know how people's significant other participates, or doesn't. I have the best possible situation - Mrs. Redtop doesn't get involved, puts no restrictions on me, she just uses whatever credit card(s) I tell her to, and doesn't even care to know what cards I have applied for in her name. I make it easy in return by not switching cards on her more than every 6-12 months, and taking care of minimum spending without her. I'm sure some people's SO has the opposite attitude, an absolute ban on extra applications in their name. I'm lucky in this regard, but I guess she's lucky also that she gets all the travel benefits with none of the work.
That's the way it works here as well. I have found this thread inspiring as well. As a person that has not been participating in manufactured spending, I fell I need to make the time to read up on all the possibilities.

2Queens Feb 10, 2013 11:36 am

bonus and spending
 
60,000 in bonuses, 5,000 in spending on 4 cards so far.
I haven't left the ground.

2Queens Feb 10, 2013 11:48 am

acummulating
 
Pretty good for a rookie +
us Canadians
don't have the cards or awesome bonuses like our US neighbours.

Starwoods is great 40k in 1 month not including further reward of 15k each for spending 5k.
20k double Sign up till april 2013, then 15k after 5k spending'.
MC world elite - 20k bonus + 4 priority club lounge passes per year.

brooklynmatt Feb 10, 2013 1:14 pm


Originally Posted by 2Queens (Post 20221063)
60,000 in bonuses, 5,000 in spending on 4 cards so far.
I haven't left the ground.

You probably want to change that last part soon!

AnitaBryant63 Feb 10, 2013 1:38 pm

I'm sure everyone's average is gonna change since OD stopped carrying $500 gift cards :-(


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 1:08 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.