FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Marriott | Marriott Bonvoy (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/marriott-marriott-bonvoy-766/)
-   -   Chicago Ritz Carlton [Master Thread] (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/marriott-marriott-bonvoy/1674941-chicago-ritz-carlton-master-thread.html)

bhrubin Apr 22, 2019 8:14 pm


Originally Posted by damon88 (Post 31027241)
The Club is a total waste for us as we much prefer dining out or using room service when we travel.

But you articulated something I have always suspected- at a Ritz Carlton the Club guests are “preferred”

I know it can happen and I expect it can be true in more places than not. But I don't think that's always true. In Boston, for example, I was treated extremely well. I think Ambassador status ordinarily can preclude that issue--but not in Chicago.

phant0m Apr 22, 2019 10:30 pm


Originally Posted by bhrubin (Post 31027248)
I know it can happen and I expect it can be true in more places than not. But I don't think that's always true. In Boston, for example, I was treated extremely well. I think Ambassador status ordinarily can preclude that issue--but not in Chicago.

One data point, during my stay in Boston I called down to the front desk and asked for a late check out as a Gold member after the merge and they wouldn't extend me past 2pm. I went down to the club lounge and they were more than willing to give me a later check out and let us stay in the lounge til our flight left. This was during the polar vortex so we were there til 10pm that night.

bhrubin Apr 22, 2019 11:34 pm


Originally Posted by phant0m (Post 31027554)
One data point, during my stay in Boston I called down to the front desk and asked for a late check out as a Gold member after the merge and they wouldn't extend me past 2pm. I went down to the club lounge and they were more than willing to give me a later check out and let us stay in the lounge til our flight left. This was during the polar vortex so we were there til 10pm that night.

As a Gold, you are not entitled to more than 2 pm. The front desk didn’t do anything wrong. Just because the Club Lounge did doesn’t mean much to me in that instance. Just because I get upgraded to a specialty suite at one hotel doesn’t mean another hotel isn’t treating me better.

EuropeanPete Apr 22, 2019 11:46 pm

Looks like the Park Hyatt will remain my Chicago hotel of choice, though I do find it rather pricey when I’m only staying for short periods (I once “lived” there a few nights a week on a fantastic negotiated rate).

phant0m Apr 23, 2019 9:54 am


Originally Posted by bhrubin (Post 31027639)

As a Gold, you are not entitled to more than 2 pm. The front desk didn’t do anything wrong. Just because the Club Lounge did doesn’t mean much to me in that instance. Just because I get upgraded to a specialty suite at one hotel doesn’t mean another hotel isn’t treating me better.

Oh didn't mean to try to say that they did anything wrong. I definitely understand they don't have to give me anything past 2pm. It is just that the Club Lounge concierge/team is more willing to go above and beyond for their guests vs. the team downstairs and I've stayed at quite a few RC Clubs and that has definitely been my experience throughout the world as well.

jmd001 May 23, 2019 12:40 pm

Wife is a Titanium Elite. When booking a standard room on points, what sort of upgrade should be expected?

Perhaps more importantly, does this property give lounge access in this situation even though it appears to not be a guaranteed benefit for PE or TE?

Thanks.

bhrubin May 23, 2019 12:48 pm


Originally Posted by jmd001 (Post 31131676)
Wife is a Titanium Elite. When booking a standard room on points, what sort of upgrade should be expected?

Perhaps more importantly, does this property give lounge access in this situation even though it appears to not be a guaranteed benefit for PE or TE?

Thanks.

As always, upgrades are based on availability but can include up to an entry level suite in the suite upgrade pool for a Titanium elite. Shouldn’t make much difference whether booked via points or cash, to be honest.

As always with Ritz-Carlton, there is no elite status entitlement for Club lounge access: you either pay for it or not. Period. It’s worth noting that RC Clubs usually are much nicer than the regular lounges offered elsewhere as an elite/Platinum benefit, so its not exactly comparable.

phant0m May 24, 2019 8:57 am


Originally Posted by jmd001 (Post 31131676)
Wife is a Titanium Elite. When booking a standard room on points, what sort of upgrade should be expected?

Perhaps more importantly, does this property give lounge access in this situation even though it appears to not be a guaranteed benefit for PE or TE?

Thanks.

I will say that the food offerings at the RC Chicago Club Lounge is really subpar to every other Club Lounge I've been too.

sig05 May 26, 2019 8:04 am


Originally Posted by phant0m (Post 31134668)
I will say that the food offerings at the RC Chicago Club Lounge is really subpar to every other Club Lounge I've been too.

Have you been back since the complete renovation of the Club, which opened early Feb? I've been here a few times, and I will say the offerings were better this time than in the past, but I wouldn't rank it as subpar based on my experiences - I know, YMMV.

I would put Aruba and New Orleans near the top and Grand Cayman and South Beach toward to the bottom. For GC, it was mostly because they were very strict about not letting food or drinks leave the Club (this was 2015). Taking a water or two at the end of the night or down to the beach is not unreasonable. For South Beach, the food offerings were very limited and the food sat out for a long time under heat laps so meat was very dry if you weren't at dinner at the start of service.

DrivingRain May 26, 2019 10:26 am


Originally Posted by sig05 (Post 31139882)
For GC, it was mostly because they were very strict about not letting food or drinks leave the Club (this was 2015). T.

Wow, thanks for the tip. That would be enough reason for me to book away from RC Grand Cayman. If I cant take a couple glasses of champagne and a little bite back to the room pre-dinner while getting dressed or coffee and some nibbles when I first wake up then the Club loses a significant amount of value to me.

sig05 May 28, 2019 6:34 am


Originally Posted by DrivingRain (Post 31140192)
Wow, thanks for the tip. That would be enough reason for me to book away from RC Grand Cayman. If I cant take a couple glasses of champagne and a little bite back to the room pre-dinner while getting dressed or coffee and some nibbles when I first wake up then the Club loses a significant amount of value to me.

You should look for more recent feedback since my experience is now 4 years old and the policy might have changed. However, I have the same thoughts as you.

m.photog Jun 5, 2019 9:06 pm


Originally Posted by sig05 (Post 31139882)
Have you been back since the complete renovation of the Club, which opened early Feb? I've been here a few times, and I will say the offerings were better this time than in the past, but I wouldn't rank it as subpar based on my experiences - I know, YMMV.

I would put Aruba and New Orleans near the top and Grand Cayman and South Beach toward to the bottom. For GC, it was mostly because they were very strict about not letting food or drinks leave the Club (this was 2015). Taking a water or two at the end of the night or down to the beach is not unreasonable. For South Beach, the food offerings were very limited and the food sat out for a long time under heat laps so meat was very dry if you weren't at dinner at the start of service.

I am in agreement, The New Orleans club is a favorite for me as well. I hope the South Beach club is improved when it reopens, I got the feeling that they had some extra space and decided to make a club lounge with very little thought put into it.

We have a stay at the RC in Chicago coming up but with so many other options we are not doing the club. It has been several years since we stayed there so i am anxious to see how the property has changed, it was still a FS during our last visit. I really like the Peninsula so we will see how the RC stacks up now.

bhrubin Jun 5, 2019 9:09 pm


Originally Posted by m.photog (Post 31175017)
We have a stay at the RC in Chicago coming up but with so many other options we are not doing the club. It has been several years since we stayed there so i am anxious to see how the property has changed, it was still a FS during our last visit. I really like the Peninsula so we will see how the RC stacks up now.

Take it from me: stay at the Peninsula.

m.photog Jun 5, 2019 9:34 pm


Originally Posted by bhrubin (Post 31175022)

Take it from me: stay at the Peninsula.

I have two free night certs that are about to expire or we probably would be headed to the Peninsula. I will report on my findings. ;)

bhrubin Jun 5, 2019 9:38 pm


Originally Posted by m.photog (Post 31175068)
I have two free night certs that are about to expire or we probably would be headed to the Peninsula. I will report on my findings. ;)

I understand. But I’d recommend using those at a better Ritz-Carlton. The RC Chicago property is really underwhelming, as evidenced by my recent stay in April (and concomitant Expert Review above). Very disappointing hard product. Dated decor and furnishings. Lots of service fails. And I’m Ambassador elite and get treated usually so well at even the best RC and StR properties.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 1:05 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.