FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Lufthansa, Austrian, Swiss, Brussels, LOT and Other Partners | Miles & More (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/lufthansa-austrian-swiss-brussels-lot-other-partners-miles-more-495/)
-   -   Pilot strikes in Autumn / Fall 2014 (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/lufthansa-austrian-swiss-brussels-lot-other-partners-miles-more/1603583-pilot-strikes-autumn-fall-2014-a.html)

Abducted Alien Sep 25, 2014 10:20 am

How about rebooking if any when flying an awards flight to Asia in I (business). Am I being pumped to whY in different carrier?

bhrubin Sep 25, 2014 10:25 am

Geez, protected myself with UA-LH flights to Paris because of the AF pilots strike, and now LH pilots may strike. Talk about bad timing and no luck. Here's hoping Oct. 3 comes with an end to the AF strike so I don't need the LH flights.

superpointsLXflyer Sep 25, 2014 10:57 am

Just called the Swiss SEN hotline. They didn't know about failed negotiations ("where did you read that?") but called LH to find out more. LH's answer was that Cockpit would anounce a strike at least one day ahead. So flights tomorrow should be safe and I hope me and my +1 get to South America without problems...

kamel123 Sep 25, 2014 11:15 am


Originally Posted by superpointsLXflyer (Post 23580372)
Just called the Swiss SEN hotline. They didn't know about failed negotiations ("where did you read that?") but called LH to find out more. LH's answer was that Cockpit would anounce a strike at least one day ahead. So flights tomorrow should be safe and I hope me and my +1 get to South America without problems...

Well, it's headline news on the pilots' union website (www.vcockpit.de) + it's on several German news websites (e.g., www.spiegel.de).

The relevant quotes are: "Verhandlungen zur Übergangsversorgung zwischen Vereinigung Cockpit und Lufthansa Management erneut gescheitert ... Ab sofort ist deshalb mit weiteren Arbeitskampfmaßnahmen zu rechnen. Diese werden jeweils vorher der Öffentlichkeit bekannt gegeben."

LH management is not even able to pass that news to their own call centers?

And yes, the pattern in the past was that strikes would be announced one day in advance, but that is quite short especially for long haul destinations with limited capacity when everyone is trying to get rebooked at the same time.

JCary Sep 25, 2014 11:15 am


Originally Posted by pkerr (Post 23579349)
Just finished all my LH flying.
They had a stoppage right before I left and once after I left and now I'm back.
Dodged that bullet.

Same here!

RTW1 Sep 25, 2014 11:35 am


Originally Posted by kamel123 (Post 23580459)
LH management is not even able to pass that news to their own call centers?

There is no news to be passed to the call centers. This is just your average union posturing.
Unless a strike is announced there is no need to have flights rebooked by call center agents. And no need for any customer to call either.

And remember, the last planned strike day LH was able to reschedule nearly all long hauls.

ysolde Sep 25, 2014 11:36 am

Great. We have a flight (JFK-FRA) on Tuesday night (September 30). Not thrilled at this news.

kamel123 Sep 25, 2014 2:05 pm


Originally Posted by RTW1 (Post 23580568)
There is no news to be passed to the call centers. This is just your average union posturing.
Unless a strike is announced there is no need to have flights rebooked by call center agents. And no need for any customer to call either.

And remember, the last planned strike day LH was able to reschedule nearly all long hauls.

Yes of course this is union posturing. However, given the past track record, I would believe it is extremely likely that we will see another strike, although no date has been announced yet.

Of course, LH does not want anyone to rebook. Fair enough. But it just makes them look stupid when negotiations have apparently broken down and they are ignorant about it/deny it.

And regarding the need for customers to call: It's anyone's own decision if they want to take the risk of their travel being disrupted. I wouldn't.

Wickersley Sep 25, 2014 4:32 pm


Originally Posted by TRAVELSIG (Post 23580107)

The question now is what to do with my October flights to USA.

LH is making it very difficult.

@:-)

Head over to MXP...

MXP > JFK on LH's least favoured ME carrier...

YuropFlyer Sep 26, 2014 1:14 am


Originally Posted by Wickersley (Post 23582174)
@:-)

Head over to MXP...

MXP > JFK on LH's least favoured ME carrier...

Good choice, and fantastic lounge in the mini hub there (with direct boarding ^ )

Compared to the "hole in the wall" that LH provides, it really shows :D

TRAVELSIG Sep 26, 2014 2:34 am


Originally Posted by Wickersley (Post 23582174)
@:-)

Head over to MXP...

MXP > JFK on LH's least favoured ME carrier...

Indeed when heading to New York this is an option.

Even the New York Post is writing about this very flight this week and they seem to note it is very busy in business and first (also the fares are not that low ranging from $5000 to $7000):
http://nypost.com/2014/09/23/emirate...vita-in-milan/

Back on the main topic- Wall Street Journal is noting the strike could indeed cause significant misery if timed together with the AF strike:

http://online.wsj.com/articles/pilot...kes-1411644712

Flying FRA/VCE yesterday coming in off the USA wave of flights- there were a great number of passengers re-accomodated over to Lufthansa from AF due to their also very long ongoing strike. In fact- for the first time in a very long time Lufthansa was announcing compensation offers over the PA loudspeaker system for anyone who would take a later flight to VCE via VIE (although at 200 EUR for a five hour delay and a connection through Vienna I am not sure just how many takers they got for this offer- we certainly left with every seat full obviously).

What I find most concerning about this ongoing strike is information such as this:

"Cockpit regrets that negotiations have failed once again," the union said in a statement, accusing management of not wanting to reach an agreement.

"Further labour action can be expected with immediate effect. The public will be warned in advance," the statement said.

A spokesman for Lufthansa insisted that the airline had "signalled its willingness to compromise" and offered to talk about the contentious points.

No new date had been set for further negotiations, however.

"We appeal to the union not to go ahead with more labour action and to return to the negotiating table," the spokesman said.

Following three separate days of walkouts in recent weeks, Lufthansa pilots agreed to postpone a fourth warning strike last week after receiving a new proposal from management.


http://www.thelocal.de/20140925/pilo...ter-talks-fail

Surely- cannot by this point someone from Lufthansa social media post a comment somewhere about what as a customer my possible risks are?

If not here on Flyertalk- at least on Facebook or Twitter? Instead there are pictures of "our world is truly stunning" with a nice sunset!!!! This is really the part of the problem that as a customer is most difficult to accept- changing market realities, negotiations with labour- there are many dynamics.

How come though it is not possible to keep the customer up to date in 2014 via a social media channel instead of posting pretty sunset pictures??? We used to have on Flyertalk an excellent Lufthansa lurker who gave us advance strike information and helped us to plan our travel- now we have nothing.

www.facebook.com/lufthansa

RTW1 Sep 26, 2014 2:46 am


Originally Posted by TRAVELSIG (Post 23583917)
Surely- cannot by this point someone from Lufthansa social media post a comment somewhere about what as a customer my possible risks are?

So please tell me what other company thinks it is a sound idea to post something on social media regarding the negotiations about employee compensation?
It would be rather silly for a company to make announcements that there might be a strike but no date has been set. Useless information that will only lead to people reacting when there's nothing to react to.

They will make an announcement when the date has been set by the unions, like they have always done. And that, including what to do, will be posted to social media. And a new schedule will be posted as soon as is available.

Please stop behaving like an impatient 5 year old. Go stand in line for the new iPhone or something. But this is a business they are running, not a news site.

The information is available for anyone to find.... Your risks are the same as they were before, there might be a strike, there might not be. You might be affected when you are flying this week, you might not be (and you most likely wont be).
But I'm sure you know that already and don't need a Facebook message to confirm that knowledge.

TRAVELSIG Sep 26, 2014 2:50 am


Originally Posted by RTW1 (Post 23583943)
So please tell me what other company thinks it is a sound idea to post something on social media regarding the negotiations about employee compensation?
It would be rather silly for a company to make announcements that there might be a strike but no date has been set. Useless information that will only lead to people reacting when there's nothing to react to.

They will make an announcement when the date has been set by the unions, like they have always done. And that, including what to do, will be posted to social media. And a new schedule will be posted as soon as is available.

Please stop behaving like an impatient 5 year old. Go stand in line for the new iPhone or something. But this is a business they are running, not a news site.

The information is available for anyone to find.... Your risks are the same as they were before, there might be a strike, there might not be. You might be affected when you are flying this week, you might not be (and you most likely wont be).
But I'm sure you know that already and don't need a Facebook message to confirm that knowledge.

Actually a number of companies post about their labour disruptions using social media. They don't need to post about their negotiations- they can post- as they did for a very long time with the original Lufthansa lurker- via their twitter, Facebook, or even Flyertalk accounts.

The personal comments from you by the way are quite possibly a little off the Flyertalk TOS- perhaps you can modify them if your schedule permits.

mmff Sep 26, 2014 3:00 am


Originally Posted by RTW1 (Post 23583943)
Your risks are the same as they were before, there might be a strike, there might not be.

While the possibilities are the same ("strike", "no strike") the odds and corresponding risk have definitely changed.

kamel123 Sep 26, 2014 4:25 am


Originally Posted by RTW1 (Post 23583943)
It would be rather silly for a company to make announcements that there might be a strike but no date has been set. Useless information that will only lead to people reacting when there's nothing to react to.

...

Your risks are the same as they were before, there might be a strike, there might not be. You might be affected when you are flying this week, you might not be (and you most likely wont be).

Well, I think the risk has definitely gone up. The union has announced that there will be a strike, so unless they restart negotiations in the very short term (which is unlikely), this is going to happen.

And why is there nothing to react to? Of course it is not in LH's interest that customers proactively move their bookings to other carriers as they fear to be affected by a strike. Last time there were strikes on longhaul (this year in March), I had a return flight SFO-FRA on LH in F which was cancelled and I was rebooked into SK via CPH in C. So thank you very much for making me lose half a day, sit on an angled seat and endure the wonderful SK food. So yes, I made it back, not a major disaster. But this time, I would proactively rebook by myself before the strike announcement comes out, because then it's likely to be too late.

I understand they want to keep it quiet, but not even having a small notice on the website while it's all over the news is frankly ridiculous.

TRAVELSIG Sep 26, 2014 4:30 am


Originally Posted by kamel123 (Post 23584148)
Well, I think the risk has definitely gone up. The union has announced that there will be a strike, so unless they restart negotiations in the very short term (which is unlikely), this is going to happen.

And why is there nothing to react to? Of course it is not in LH's interest that customers proactively move their bookings to other carriers as they fear to be affected by a strike. Last time there were strikes on longhaul (this year in March), I had a return flight SFO-FRA on LH in F which was cancelled and I was rebooked into SK via CPH in C. So thank you very much for making me lose half a day, sit on an angled seat and endure the wonderful SK food. So yes, I made it back, not a major disaster. But this time, I would proactively rebook by myself before the strike announcement comes out, because then it's likely to be too late.

I understand they want to keep it quiet, but not even having a small notice on the website while it's all over the news is frankly ridiculous.

Agreed.

Given there have been six strikes so far in the past 12 months involving Lufthansa it is not unreasonable to expect a seventh. I am not asking for the CEO to explain their negotiating strategy- I am just asking that at least on the webpage there is a one line warning of industrial action.

oliver2002 Sep 26, 2014 5:02 am

My take is that LH doesn't think there will be a strike. The last one was called off by VC after they realised their base was not behind it. ;)

htb Sep 26, 2014 5:34 am

I don't think LH has to post about this on its website. I do think, however, that all callcenter workers need to know about the situation in case they are quizzed by customers.

HTB.

8420PR Sep 26, 2014 6:59 am

But the callcentre that superpointsLXflyer called was the Swiss SEN callcenter, i.e. LX. They didn't know, so they called LH and asked and got the answer. Seems reasonable to me...

8420PR Sep 26, 2014 7:06 am


Originally Posted by TRAVELSIG (Post 23583952)
Actually a number of companies post about their labour disruptions using social media. They don't need to post about their negotiations- they can post- as they did for a very long time with the original Lufthansa lurker- via their twitter, Facebook, or even Flyertalk accounts.

I don't think any company would post their labour disruptions until a strike is actually announced. It would just lead to lost business. It would be similar to me telling my boss winter is coming, so I may get a cold, and don't want to take on any more meetings in case I am ill that day.

Also, LH seems to use their social media more to post pretty pictures of planes, as opposed to interacting with customers.

TRAVELSIG Sep 26, 2014 7:08 am


Originally Posted by 8420PR (Post 23584637)
Also, LH seems to use their social media more to post pretty pictures of planes, as opposed to interacting with customers.

This is where my comment was focused on.

t325 Sep 26, 2014 7:16 am

So if I'm flying LH tomorrow longhaul, how far in advance would a strike be announced? When can I safely assume I'll be out of the woods as far as strikes go?

oliver2002 Sep 26, 2014 8:22 am

So far 24h advance notice was the limit they imposed onto themselves. Previously it was 72h.

AFAIK LH is going to go all out this time, VC has lost a lot of internal support.

mmff Sep 26, 2014 10:44 am


Originally Posted by oliver2002 (Post 23584222)
My take is that LH doesn't think there will be a strike. The last one was called off by VC after they realised their base was not behind it. ;)


Originally Posted by oliver2002 (Post 23585055)
AFAIK LH is going to go all out this time, VC has lost a lot of internal support.

Happy to hear this, it was about time.

Germanfflyer Sep 27, 2014 1:28 pm

http://www.vcockpit.de/presse/presse...b6aa00b80.html

Be prepared for next week......a strike will come to all flights and all stations...much easier for VC to have an impact that way!

LufthansaFlyer Sep 27, 2014 2:40 pm


Originally Posted by Germanfflyer (Post 23590746)
http://www.vcockpit.de/presse/presse...b6aa00b80.html

Be prepared for next week......a strike will come to all flights and all stations...much easier for VC to have an impact that way!

Being an alarmist is not helpful. Where did you see the fact that a strike is coming next week to all stations? Or is creating unjustified facts a past time?

TRAVELSIG Sep 27, 2014 5:17 pm


Originally Posted by LufthansaFlyer (Post 23590964)
Being an alarmist is not helpful. Where did you see the fact that a strike is coming next week to all stations? Or is creating unjustified facts a past time?

+1: Is there any concrete information to suggest such a strike? if not conjecture simply makes people nervous unnecessarily.

LufthansaFlyer Sep 27, 2014 5:58 pm


Originally Posted by TRAVELSIG (Post 23591392)
+1: Is there any concrete information to suggest such a strike? if not conjecture simply makes people nervous unnecessarily.

especially when one has two long hauls upcoming on the same day next week....

Germanfflyer Sep 27, 2014 7:43 pm

We will see if I am correct or not about a strike next week :D

One thing is for sure - VC will not narrow it down to 48 flights again - as the last attempt - where LH management was able to shift and squeeze to make these flights happen with not much impact, before it was called off.

I would think they will follow the AF lead and make sure that at least 200-300 flights are affected - maybe for several days again - so the impact is felt for sure no matter what % of the pilot-base follows - also it gives a "free" domino effect into the next days as aircraft are misplaced:)

htb Sep 28, 2014 2:42 am


Originally Posted by Germanfflyer (Post 23591761)
We will see if I am correct or not about a strike next week :D
...

Are you a LH pilot with inside information or are you simply speculating based on what YOU would do?

HTB.

weero Sep 28, 2014 8:05 am


Originally Posted by htb (Post 23592572)
Are you a LH pilot with inside information....

While I agree that skepticism is in order here .. inside information proved to be pretty worthless the last few years as well ;) .

Don Dunham Sep 28, 2014 10:28 am

Are strikes effecting Lufthansa Cityline?
 
Connecting in Munich to Warsaw on Oct. 10th with Lufthansa CityLine, is there a risk of strike? Sorry, industrial 'in'action.:mad:

Germanfflyer Sep 28, 2014 11:20 am

Very simply : YES!

htb Sep 28, 2014 11:29 am


Originally Posted by Don Dunham (Post 23593770)
Connecting in Munich to Warsaw on Oct. 10th with Lufthansa CityLine, is there a risk of strike? Sorry, industrial 'in'action.:mad:

Here I agree with Germanflyer. From today's point of view there's an above average risk of strike. Same as for the days before and after Oct. 10th.

I'm not quite sure why you're asking, though.

HTB.

YuropFlyer Sep 28, 2014 11:32 am

Has it been posted yet that Lufthansa will hire (ie, outsource) pilot jobs outside of LH?

http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/unt...-a-994211.html

Bruch mit ehernen Konzerntraditionen: Lufthansa-Chef Spohr will nach SPIEGEL-Informationen einen Teil seiner Langstreckenflotte mit Piloten besetzen, die nicht zur Lufthansa gehören. Die Vereinigung Cockpit reagiert erstaunlich zurückhaltend.

helosc Sep 28, 2014 11:37 am

Does anyone know if the previous strikes have affected the Lufthansa busses?

I am here thinking of the tickets LH sells that include a bus ride ( one ticket, two segments - one flight and one bus ride ), for example the bus from Frankfurt to Strasbourg.

TRAVELSIG Sep 28, 2014 12:46 pm


Originally Posted by helosc (Post 23594049)
Does anyone know if the previous strikes have affected the Lufthansa busses?

I am here thinking of the tickets LH sells that include a bus ride ( one ticket, two segments - one flight and one bus ride ), for example the bus from Frankfurt to Strasbourg.

Previous strikes have not impacted buses.

more4less Sep 28, 2014 1:13 pm


Originally Posted by TRAVELSIG (Post 23594363)
Previous strikes have not impacted buses.

Bus drivers do not considers themselves pilots, although driving a bus is much more difficult than piloting a plane, once you have been trained on the latter.

cas_de Sep 29, 2014 12:54 am

Here we go again (*dislike*)...

VC is going on strike again. Tomorrow, between 8 a.m. and 11 p.m. all long haul flights from Frankfurt will be affected.

Link (German only, sorry):
http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/unt...-a-994278.html

ralfkrippner Sep 29, 2014 1:17 am

Nothing yet on LH or VC websites. Strange...


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:33 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.