Bogus IHG reviews
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 1,470
Bogus IHG reviews
Earlier this month an IHG hotel in Europe offered me free breakfast (where none was included in the rate) if I agreed to give them a 10-point rating in a 'IHG Heartbeat' survey
I am sure I was not the only person offered such inducements for a high rating of the hotel and I cannot help wondering how widespreaf the practice is.
So how do you trust those hotel reviews that you see on IHG's site and even on third party sites, when some of them are the results of bribes?
I am sure I was not the only person offered such inducements for a high rating of the hotel and I cannot help wondering how widespreaf the practice is.
So how do you trust those hotel reviews that you see on IHG's site and even on third party sites, when some of them are the results of bribes?
#2
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Newcastle, UK
Posts: 2,379
Earlier this month an IHG hotel in Europe offered me free breakfast (where none was included in the rate) if I agreed to give them a 10-point rating in a 'IHG Heartbeat' survey
I am sure I was not the only person offered such inducements for a high rating of the hotel and I cannot help wondering how widespreaf the practice is.
So how do you trust those hotel reviews that you see on IHG's site and even on third party sites, when some of them are the results of bribes?
I am sure I was not the only person offered such inducements for a high rating of the hotel and I cannot help wondering how widespreaf the practice is.
So how do you trust those hotel reviews that you see on IHG's site and even on third party sites, when some of them are the results of bribes?
#3
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Abu Dhabi UAE
Programs: EY Plat, IHG Plat Amb
Posts: 895
Earlier this month an IHG hotel in Europe offered me free breakfast (where none was included in the rate) if I agreed to give them a 10-point rating in a 'IHG Heartbeat' survey
I am sure I was not the only person offered such inducements for a high rating of the hotel and I cannot help wondering how widespreaf the practice is.
So how do you trust those hotel reviews that you see on IHG's site and even on third party sites, when some of them are the results of bribes?
I am sure I was not the only person offered such inducements for a high rating of the hotel and I cannot help wondering how widespreaf the practice is.
So how do you trust those hotel reviews that you see on IHG's site and even on third party sites, when some of them are the results of bribes?
Enjoy!
#4
Original Poster
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 1,470
This blatant attempt at bribery disgusted me so much that I opted for the Hilton (similarly priced), which gave me a complimentary breakfast due to my Diamond status there.
#6
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: London
Programs: IHG Spire Amb, BA Gold, Hyatt
Posts: 131
That is really horrible that they'd try to bribe for good reviews. I too think you should write an email to customer service and report that behaviour. I applaud you, ksen22, for not going along with it.
#7
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Cannock, UK
Posts: 273
Earlier this month an IHG hotel in Europe offered me free breakfast (where none was included in the rate) if I agreed to give them a 10-point rating in a 'IHG Heartbeat' survey
I am sure I was not the only person offered such inducements for a high rating of the hotel and I cannot help wondering how widespreaf the practice is.
So how do you trust those hotel reviews that you see on IHG's site and even on third party sites, when some of them are the results of bribes?
I am sure I was not the only person offered such inducements for a high rating of the hotel and I cannot help wondering how widespreaf the practice is.
So how do you trust those hotel reviews that you see on IHG's site and even on third party sites, when some of them are the results of bribes?
On a serious note, some reviews that have appeared on the IHG main site have been a little suspect. The HI Birmingham had a load of in depth factual 1 and 2 star reviews from Gold/Spires and then a couple of 4/5 star reviews from base members appeared.. Not saying that they are not actual reviews but maybe they were offering incentives..
Shocking that a property would risk a policy of trying to buy reviews. Was this a rougue employee or the establishment.
A brief note to IHG direct may get you a few goodwill points in thanks for pointing out the approach of the property.
#8
Original Poster
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 1,470
It was offered, in writing (e-mail) by a Reservations Supervisor!
Last edited by shonamac; Sep 7, 2016 at 5:49 pm
#9
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Programs: MR LT Titanium, IHG Plat.,UA Premier Silver, & PA/OH Turnpike Million Miler
Posts: 2,333
<BeginRant> Not excusing the behavior of the property. Trying to buy ratings is indeed unethical and wrong. Now the rant.... Part of the problem is brought on by the fact that even though ratings are on a 1 to 10 scale, anything less than a 10 is considered a failure. So this effectively degenerates down to a pass/fail rating system. So there is no room for differentiation to recognize outstanding versus good performance. IHG is not the only culprit. I believe Marriott's rating system is similar though leaves some room for differentiation (e.g. 8 to 10 are passing grades). My car dealership is the same way, The Service Adviser's pay is tied into if they get all 10's on their customer satisfaction surveys. This is ridiculous and puts the consumer in a bad position (e.g. either rate everything as perfect, don't provide feedback at all, or provide honest feedback but wind up hurting employees and/or franchises that shouldn't be hurt (e.g. a 9 is interrupted as terrible and someone gets a bad performance review or becomes ineligible for bonus pay, etc.). <EndRant>.
--Jon
--Jon
#10
#11
Join Date: Aug 2005
Programs: UA*G(1K), PC Diamond Amb, Marriott Titanium, Accor Platinum
Posts: 4,676
When we were bought by an international company they also introduced customer satisfaction questionnaires with scores from 1-10 on various aspects of customer service. And it was the same: anything under 8 points was considered a negative response and weighed as such.
I think it's just unrealistic: some people may give out something in the middle (5-6) for "normal" service and more only if something was completely outstanding.
On surveys I usually give out 8 or 9 when I'm satisfied, but for a 10 there must have been something unusual (usually an incident) where they could prove that their service is outstanding.
One time with a Marriott stay I was given a note when checking out asking me to give 8 points or more if I was satisfied. I understood immediately that they were using the same system.
HTB.
I think it's just unrealistic: some people may give out something in the middle (5-6) for "normal" service and more only if something was completely outstanding.
On surveys I usually give out 8 or 9 when I'm satisfied, but for a 10 there must have been something unusual (usually an incident) where they could prove that their service is outstanding.
One time with a Marriott stay I was given a note when checking out asking me to give 8 points or more if I was satisfied. I understood immediately that they were using the same system.
HTB.
#12
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Somewhere in Europe
Posts: 3,362
Yes for some strange reason a lot of marketing people seem to think the NPS is everything and anything less than a ten is a failure.
At the same time any company with a bit of sense really should be asking themselves why the score is so high. Even the best if the best have blips.
At the same time any company with a bit of sense really should be asking themselves why the score is so high. Even the best if the best have blips.