Inappropriate CBP questions
When I travel to a foreign country, I am essentially asking permission to enter, so I expect and am totally unfazed by questions that might otherwise seem intrusive or personal.
But when I am returning home to my own country of citizenship (in this case, the United States), I find those questions very off-putting. I was returning to the U.S. via Miami this week from a country of "high scrutiny" shall we say, but it was a country that I traveled to many times before. The questions from the agent were very much of a personal nature, about my boyfriend, how we met, his name, his citizenship status. I answered them truthfully and was "let back in" after a minimal delay, but I found the experience disagreeable. As a citizen, I really only wish to have a few cursory questions and then, "Welcome back" from a CBP agent. Am I being unreasonable? |
|
Originally Posted by ewoo
(Post 34290043)
Am I being unreasonable?
Yes, very. |
Originally Posted by Mwenenzi
(Post 34290580)
|
I’m pretty sure you’re not required to answer. Now, if you’re traveling with your boyfriend, and he’s not a citizen, it could affect his entry.
|
Originally Posted by Jaimito Cartero
(Post 34290936)
I’m pretty sure you’re not required to answer. Now, if you’re traveling with your boyfriend, and he’s not a citizen, it could affect his entry.
I googled some ACLU stuff and the sum of their answer is that you're only required to answer the bare minimum upon returning to the country but perceived evasion could lead to delays....which is generally not worth it. In my experience, when there is no line, agents tend to be more chatty...when there are a million people waiting, they're more likely to do a quick glance at the passport and send you on your way. It was a slow day, so I may have just caught a "chatty" agent. |
I don’t want to assume OP’s gender but I know someone who was asked exactly the same question. He responded, “Grindr. Would you like to know anything else, sir?”
The officer quickly waved him along. |
They are only really allowed to ask questions to confirm your identity, name and last name, and citizenship status (if you are a US citizen). For non-US citizens, they can ask anything they want.
However, if you don't answer other questions as a us citizen, you may end up for hours in secondary inspection. |
This is one of the reasons why I'm glad I have Global Entry, in-n-out of immigration in less than 5 mins. For the most part, once the agent see the GE slip, they waved me through, I sometimes get a "welcome back" if I'm lucky lol
|
Originally Posted by smartytravel
(Post 34292291)
They are only really allowed to ask questions to confirm your identity, name and last name, and citizenship status (if you are a US citizen).
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:18 am. |
This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.