FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Emirates | Skywards (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/emirates-skywards-490/)
-   -   Expertflyer wrong on D class availability? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/emirates-skywards/1398527-expertflyer-wrong-d-class-availability.html)

Hyperacusis Nov 2, 2012 8:56 am

D is both awards and upgrades. I is only for flex awards, which are more expensive.

whimike Dec 27, 2012 11:26 pm


Originally Posted by ExpertFlyer Voice (Post 19610746)
As stated in our last post, we have multiple ways of getting this data, so if you can email us specific flight information that you believe to be inaccurate we can look at our other data sources. Thanks.

I am trying to book an F award for my parents, JFK-DXB on the 15th of February. ExpertFlyer is showing A=4 for this date on the 11 PM flight (EK202). However, EK.com is showing no availability at all. I thought Flex F Awards come out of discounted F inventory (A bucket) and there is definitely A bucket available on the flight.

I already PM'ed ExpertFlyer Voice to see if they can let me know the reason for the discrepancy. Has anybody else here found out what the deal is?

whimike Dec 28, 2012 12:31 am

Just as a follow-up, I called the EK service center and they are telling me that FLEX F awards come out of the same Z bucket as SAVER F awards. Does that sound correct? ExpertFlyer shows FLEX F awards coming out of the A bucket.

As a further datapoint, the flight is JFK-DXB-MLE, and ExpertFlyer is showing the DXB-MLE EK652 as O=0 (Business FLEX award), yet at EK.com, EK652 is showing as having FLEX Business award seats available.

Zol Dec 28, 2012 2:20 am

EF doesn't sync up that well with EK, especially when it relates to awards

ExpertFlyer Voice Dec 28, 2012 8:51 am


Originally Posted by whimike (Post 19931479)
I am trying to book an F award for my parents, JFK-DXB on the 15th of February. ExpertFlyer is showing A=4 for this date on the 11 PM flight (EK202). However, EK.com is showing no availability at all. I thought Flex F Awards come out of discounted F inventory (A bucket) and there is definitely A bucket available on the flight.

I already PM'ed ExpertFlyer Voice to see if they can let me know the reason for the discrepancy. Has anybody else here found out what the deal is?


Originally Posted by whimike (Post 19931658)
Just as a follow-up, I called the EK service center and they are telling me that FLEX F awards come out of the same Z bucket as SAVER F awards. Does that sound correct? ExpertFlyer shows FLEX F awards coming out of the A bucket.

As a further datapoint, the flight is JFK-DXB-MLE, and ExpertFlyer is showing the DXB-MLE EK652 as O=0 (Business FLEX award), yet at EK.com, EK652 is showing as having FLEX Business award seats available.


The problem looks to be that you were searching each segment separately when you should have been searching for them together. EK uses married segment logic for awards so you need to search for the entire trip. When you do you'll see that the results are correct:

Results from ExpertFlyer.com
Code:

Awards & Upgrades Search
Departing JFK on 02/15/13 10:00 PM for MLE
Flying EK  on booking class A O     
Connecting at DXB


                                                                    Frequency                                                   
Flight        Stops  Depart            Arrive            Aircraft  Reliability    Class Description                      Code  Seats
1 Connection
EK 202        0      JFK                DXB                388      Daily          First - Flex Award                    A    0
                    02/15/13 11:00 PM  02/16/13 8:30 PM            82% / 19m      Business - Flex Award                  O    7

EK 652        0      DXB                MLE                772      Su,M,Th,F      First - Flex Award                    A    0
                    02/17/13 9:35 AM  02/17/13 2:50 PM            69% / 23m      Business - Flex Award                  O    4


whimike Dec 28, 2012 1:12 pm


Originally Posted by ExpertFlyer Voice (Post 19933030)
The problem looks to be that you were searching each segment separately when you should have been searching for them together. EK uses married segment logic for awards so you need to search for the entire trip. When you do you'll see that the results are correct:

Results from ExpertFlyer.com
Code:

Awards & Upgrades Search
Departing JFK on 02/15/13 10:00 PM for MLE
Flying EK  on booking class A O     
Connecting at DXB


                                                                    Frequency                                             
Flight        Stops  Depart            Arrive            Aircraft  Reliability    Class Description                      Code  Seats
1 Connection
EK 202        0      JFK                DXB                388      Daily          First - Flex Award                    A    0
                    02/15/13 11:00 PM  02/16/13 8:30 PM            82% / 19m      Business - Flex Award                  O    7

EK 652        0      DXB                MLE                772      Su,M,Th,F      First - Flex Award                    A    0
                    02/17/13 9:35 AM  02/17/13 2:50 PM            69% / 23m      Business - Flex Award                  O    4


Actually, at first I was going to get an F award to DXB and pay for the flight to MLE. Still, there is no F availability just JFK-DXB. I have data below, sorry it's unformatted but I am posting from my iPhone.

EF shows:


JFK to DXB on 02/15/13 5:00 PM
Flying EK on booking class(es) A Z O D
Expanded
EK 202 JFK 11:00p → DXB 8:30p
A4 O7
Stops: 0
Aircraft: 388
Frequency: Daily
Reliability: 80% / 26m
Flight Details · Seat Map · Create Alert

And EK.com shows:

2. 23:00 on Fri 15 Feb, 2013
DEPARTING15 FEB 13 New York, United States to Dubai, United Arab Emirates
Flight
Depart / Arrive
Time
Airport
Duration / Aircraft
Economy
Business
First
EK202
Fri
15 Feb 13
23:00 John F Kennedy International Airport (JFK) 12hr 30min
Airbus A380-800 Available
Available
Unavailable
Sat
16 Feb 13
20:30 Dubai International Airport (DXB) Skywards Flex Reward Skywards Flex Reward

father_ted Dec 28, 2012 2:41 pm

Very interesting. EK.com, ITA and EF all agree that there is A inventory available should one wish to purchase a revenue ticket.

I tried a one-way reward search for your date - that doesn't work either.

So do first class Flex rewards no longer book into A? Or are we seeing the first signs of a further restriction on reward bookings?

whimike Dec 28, 2012 5:29 pm


Originally Posted by ExpertFlyer Voice (Post 19933030)
The problem looks to be that you were searching each segment separately when you should have been searching for them together. EK uses married segment logic for awards so you need to search for the entire trip. When you do you'll see that the results are correct:

Results from ExpertFlyer.com
Code:

Awards & Upgrades Search
Departing JFK on 02/15/13 10:00 PM for MLE
Flying EK  on booking class A O     
Connecting at DXB


                                                                    Frequency                                                   
Flight        Stops  Depart            Arrive            Aircraft  Reliability    Class Description                      Code  Seats
1 Connection
EK 202        0      JFK                DXB                388      Daily          First - Flex Award                    A    0
                    02/15/13 11:00 PM  02/16/13 8:30 PM            82% / 19m      Business - Flex Award                  O    7

EK 652        0      DXB                MLE                772      Su,M,Th,F      First - Flex Award                    A    0
                    02/17/13 9:35 AM  02/17/13 2:50 PM            69% / 23m      Business - Flex Award                  O    4


I wanted to wait until I get back to my computer as I didn't recall these flights, even with married segment logic, not having A bucket. I just did an award search on EF with JFK and origin and MLE and destination, and this is what I get:


1 Connections


EK 202 0 JFK
02/15/13
11:00 PM DXB
02/16/13
8:30 PM 388
Daily
80% / 26m
First - Flex Award A 4
Business - Flex Award O 0
Economy - Flex Award W 9
Economy - Partner Award X 9



EK 658 0 DXB
02/17/13
3:15 AM MLE
02/17/13
8:20 AM 77W
Su,Th,F
48% / 15m
Business - Flex Award O 0
Economy - Flex Award W 9
Economy - Partner Award X 9


Am I using EF incorrectly? I can't bring up the results you are bringing up.

father_ted Dec 28, 2012 5:50 pm


Originally Posted by whimike (Post 19935745)
Am I using EF incorrectly? I can't bring up the results you are bringing up.

You can obtain these results as follows:

-Specify classes A and O only. If you request Z,D,X or N also, you lose the ability to choose a connection point.

-Specify DXB as a connection point.

-Optionally, specify 10PM as departure time.

Married segment logic is what is zeroing A class on the JFK-DXB-MLE itinerary. It does not explain why you are unable to book a Flex First reward JFK-DXB as a one-way or return itinerary.

ExpertFlyer Voice Dec 28, 2012 6:52 pm


Originally Posted by whimike (Post 19935745)
I wanted to wait until I get back to my computer as I didn't recall these flights, even with married segment logic, not having A bucket. I just did an award search on EF with JFK and origin and MLE and destination, and this is what I get:


1 Connections


EK 202 0 JFK
02/15/13
11:00 PM DXB
02/16/13
8:30 PM 388
Daily
80% / 26m
First - Flex Award A 4
Business - Flex Award O 0
Economy - Flex Award W 9
Economy - Partner Award X 9



EK 658 0 DXB
02/17/13
3:15 AM MLE
02/17/13
8:20 AM 77W
Su,Th,F
48% / 15m
Business - Flex Award O 0
Economy - Flex Award W 9
Economy - Partner Award X 9


Am I using EF incorrectly? I can't bring up the results you are bringing up.

You are look at the wrong flights. You mentioned, and we posted the results for EK 202/652, however you just pasted the results for 202/658. Apparently the results for EK202 are different for when it is paired with 658 vs 652

whimike Dec 28, 2012 7:17 pm


Originally Posted by ExpertFlyer Voice (Post 19936033)
You are look at the wrong flights. You mentioned, and we posted the results for EK 202/652, however you just pasted the results for 202/658. Apparently the results for EK202 are different for when it is paired with 658 vs 652

Yes, I made an error, I want 658 which arrives to Male at 8 AM. Doing all this research on my iPhone, sitting by the pool in Maui, means I am easily mixing up details! :-)

With that pairing A=4 but of course there is no F award availability on EK.com.

Any ideas why?

whimike Dec 28, 2012 7:18 pm


Originally Posted by father_ted (Post 19935821)
You can obtain these results as follows:

-Specify classes A and O only. If you request Z,D,X or N also, you lose the ability to choose a connection point.

-Specify DXB as a connection point.

-Optionally, specify 10PM as departure time.

Married segment logic is what is zeroing A class on the JFK-DXB-MLE itinerary. It does not explain why you are unable to book a Flex First reward JFK-DXB as a one-way or return itinerary.

I tried this and am still getting A=4 on EK202

father_ted Dec 28, 2012 7:55 pm


Originally Posted by whimike (Post 19936119)
I tried this and am still getting A=4 on EK202

I think we are obtaining the same results. Those instructions were necessary to show the 0935 connection, which I thought you were looking for.

EK202 has A=4 when connecting to EK658 (0315).
EK202 has A=0 when connecting to EK652 (0935).

As a further datapoint, EK202 shows A=4 for an itinerary to DXB only. This is correct as EK.com will sell a JFK-DXB-JFK revenue ticket (on EK202) for $15k, which is an A fare.

What we have here seems to be some process whereby access to A inventory for reward tickets is being limited.

whimike Dec 28, 2012 8:41 pm


Originally Posted by father_ted (Post 19936262)
I think we are obtaining the same results. Those instructions were necessary to show the 0935 connection, which I thought you were looking for.

EK202 has A=4 when connecting to EK658 (0315).
EK202 has A=0 when connecting to EK652 (0935).

As a further datapoint, EK202 shows A=4 for an itinerary to DXB only. This is correct as EK.com will sell a JFK-DXB-JFK revenue ticket (on EK202) for $15k, which is an A fare.

What we have here seems to be some process whereby access to A inventory for reward tickets is being limited.

When I called EK they told me all F awards come out of the Z bucket, which makes no sense as then there would be no distinction between SAVER or FLEX awards.

If they do come out of A bucket then I wonder what is necessary to decode how/where/when seats will be available.

EK202 on that date is relatively empty in F so I am not sure why they are blocking the redemption inventory.

father_ted Dec 29, 2012 11:42 am

I have tried searching for Flex First rewards from DUB - including via the calendar award search function, which incidentally I had never seen before.

There is no Flex First availability on dates that do not have Saver First (Z) availability, but do have plenty of revenue A available.

I think EK has removed the ability to book a Flex award in A inventory. It is still possible to book a Flex award (with increased maximum stay and free rebooking) by selecting the 'Flex' option when searching for awards, however these Flex awards are available only on dates when Z is available.

It seems the information the phone agent gave whimike is correct, all First awards now book into Z.

I'm not sure whether this is a temporary or permanent 'enhancement'...


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 5:25 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.