So milepig, what did you wind up doing?

My couple of experiences with French Press have me of the mind that when my cone breaks, I will probably get a French Press. I also pack good grounds into my Keurig to make coffee. Never ever use the k-cups.

Great normal whole bean coffee?
 

Cafe Britt from Costa Rica. My favorite is their Terrazu. Some other nice ones too.

Since converting entirely to a French Press, I find its product more consistently appealing. Whole beans? fancy names and upscale pricing are no guarantees, and in fact the most satisfying reasonably priced coffee I've had lately came from Trader Joe's, a "House Brand" dark roast, although as with some other TJ's house brands, I'm experienced enough to expect inconsistency.

Coffee am
 

Great coffee and good price. Since converting to burr grinder and French press and fresh beans, my heartburn has gone. I also drink less coffee as satisfied after 2 cups.