FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   DiningBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz-371/)
-   -   Wine- looking for everyday drinkers at a lower price... (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz/1359810-wine-looking-everyday-drinkers-lower-price.html)

DJGMaster1 Jun 24, 2012 7:50 pm


Originally Posted by GuyverII (Post 18813334)
THIS. And if anyone recommends you buy the Two-Buck-(Up)Chuck, they are crazy. Absolutely swill. Just because TJs randomly won a wine contest doesn't mean all of it is good wine. Almost every bottle we have had was spew.

Two Buck Chuck is one thing, but the $10-15 Trader Joes stuff is another matter entirely - some of those wines equal in quality to stuff selling under name brands for 3-4x that price. I personally know of several of the sources for some of their stuff, including an estate reserve Pinot from Carneros Creek Winery that used to sell under that winery's label for $50 a bottle, and some Mazocco Meritage that was originally a $40 Alexander Valley wine.

One of the best wine bargains I ever had was a 2007 Rutherford Meritage under Trader Joes label that they sold last year for $10 a bottle, and it was EASILY worth $50. I threw it into several blind tastings as a ringer and it always finished near the top amongst $30-$80 wines. After I tried it, I bought a case of it, and I would have bought much more if it had been structured for cellar ageing, but it was a near term drinker.

BTW, the wine glut also has salutory affect on Two Buck Chuck, as the quality of the grape juice they get presently is more akin to what sells elsewhere for $6-9 a bottle. It didn't used to be - it used to be that it took great blending skills to make Two Buck Chuck even drinkable. That is much easier for them to accomplish now, with the caliber of bulk wine available to them on the open market.

brooklynmatt Jun 24, 2012 8:21 pm

Like I said, I heard that TJs used to get stuff like this and was excited about it, but right now, their top of the line Reserve Cab is a comparable to a Bogle. It really isn't that good in reality.

In theory, your posts make a lot of sense and get me all excited about them, but buying the wine...nope... not anymore.

I really wish it was otherwise.

printingray Jun 25, 2012 9:32 am

Always drink whatever you like and don't worry about the people pontificating. You should drink what you enjoy like some people prefer crisp and others like buttery.

VivoPerLei Jun 25, 2012 10:40 am

We had the same problem. When we got to about $50/night we decided that maybe it was time to scale back. Now we try to look for sales and buy in bulk.

Eastbay1K Jun 25, 2012 10:58 pm

Perhaps you have a place nearby that stocks value imports. I've got a place in my 'hood that has probably 1/3 or more of its inventory at $10 or under - mostly French and Spanish, with a bit of Italian, Portugal and Chile, Argentina. Just got a few bottles of a very good Bourgogne Blanc for $13/btl. I'm sure (to the OP) in Brooklyn, you can add a couple of bucks per bottle, but maybe there's a small merchant like this. Most of what I buy at this place is $10 and under ($6.99 is the floor there) and at worst, I get a "meh, but not offensive." At best, I buy a $7 bottle and go back right away to buy a case.

I don't buy too many domestic bargains, because well, they tend to be worth what you pay for them, or less.

suthurn Jun 26, 2012 8:46 am

We buy a lot of J Lohr Seven Oaks Cab for $11-12 at Total Wine. My wife and edler son love it more than I do.
http://jlohr.com/wines/estates/Seven-Oaks-Cabernet_2010

Jeeves Jun 26, 2012 12:06 pm

I like the Kirkland Alexander Valley Cab from Costco for $9. Trader Joe's can be hit or miss. A lot of the stuff I like are one-time special purchases that are gone by the time I get back to the store.

I try to keep my everyday wine price point under $9. I can usually find enough stuff out there to keep me happy. Let the glut continue!

GuyverII Jun 26, 2012 12:12 pm


Originally Posted by brooklynmatt (Post 18814372)
Like I said, I heard that TJs used to get stuff like this and was excited about it, but right now, their top of the line Reserve Cab is a comparable to a Bogle. It really isn't that good in reality.

In theory, your posts make a lot of sense and get me all excited about them, but buying the wine...nope... not anymore.

I really wish it was otherwise.

So true brooklynmatt. Personally, I'm so sick of hearing people who know next to nothing (but think they know much) wax on about "how good" TJ wine is. For God's sake, 90% of it is sh**te. On occasion I have had a bottle that was ok.

But as said before, if you like it, go for it.

Two from my adopted country, just for you:

Marques de Caceres 2007 Rioja (14.99)
Yllera 2005 Rioja (15.99)

slawecki Jun 26, 2012 1:22 pm


Originally Posted by brooklynmatt (Post 18814372)
Like I said, I heard that TJs used to get stuff like this and was excited about it, but right now, their top of the line Reserve Cab is a comparable to a Bogle. It really isn't that good in reality.

a friend of mine who chases cheap oakie chards likes j lohr, bogle and wente. i have had some j lohr and thought it a quite decent $10 chard.

brooklynmatt Jun 26, 2012 1:33 pm


Originally Posted by Eastbay1K (Post 18821101)
Perhaps you have a place nearby that stocks value imports. I've got a place in my 'hood that has probably 1/3 or more of its inventory at $10 or under - mostly French and Spanish, with a bit of Italian, Portugal and Chile, Argentina. Just got a few bottles of a very good Bourgogne Blanc for $13/btl. I'm sure (to the OP) in Brooklyn, you can add a couple of bucks per bottle, but maybe there's a small merchant like this. Most of what I buy at this place is $10 and under ($6.99 is the floor there) and at worst, I get a "meh, but not offensive." At best, I buy a $7 bottle and go back right away to buy a case.

I don't buy too many domestic bargains, because well, they tend to be worth what you pay for them, or less.

Thanks for this, I have thought for some time that I should be branching out more into imports.

What would you recommend for bold (often Cabernet) type reds from overseas-to date I have enjoyed Tempranillo, Rioja, not done so well with France yet as I tried several cheaper Bordeaux but they didn't hit the right notes...

And I had an excellent Sangiovese the other day when the restaurant I was eating at didn't have a Montepulciano.

Any other ones that I should look at?

brooklynmatt Jun 26, 2012 1:34 pm


Originally Posted by slawecki (Post 18824691)
a friend of mine who chases cheap oakie chards likes j lohr, bogle and wente. i have had some j lohr and thought it a quite decent $10 chard.

Yeah - I am confident that Chards can be found at 10 the Cupcake was a great one, and I have enjoyed Hobnob at AA lounge in Ohare too...

- will check out the J Lohr one... it is the Cabs that are harder to find at lower prices.

brooklynmatt Jun 26, 2012 1:35 pm

Thanks for the comments guys, especially with names that you have tried and enjoyed, will certainly be looking them up.

cordelli Jun 29, 2012 10:38 am

The news covering the worlds most expensive wine a bottle for $168,000 (of which only 12 were made).

One of the stories about it

http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/20...xpensive-wine/

talks about how price is connected to taste for some people

Research shows that people’s enjoyment of wine is influenced by how much it costs. According to Caltech neuro-economist Antonio Rangel, who has studied this, “When people drank the same wine, but they believed it was a more expensive wine, areas of the brain that are associated with encoding pleasure were more active.”

Rangel and colleagues scanned people in a functional MRI machine while they tasted Cabernet Sauvignons that were marked higher or lower than their actual retail price. Tasters reported liking the exact same wine better when they thought it cost more than they did when it had been marked down, and their brains followed suit: The orbitofrontal cortex, a part of their brains associated with experiencing pleasure, was more active when they thought the wine was costlier.

dot dot dot

Interestingly, when Rangel’s team conducted blind tastings (without providing prices) with people who weren’t connoisseurs, they reported liking the cheapest wines the most. When the researchers did this with people from the Stanford wine club, they found the same thing. “I suspect though that if you go to sommeliers – people with very educated palates – the illusion breaks down,” Rangel said

vmsea Jul 2, 2012 5:06 pm

Go to Costco.. get some Chateau st Michelle, indian wells cab.. i think they're 14 bucks.. pretty good for the money.

DJGMaster1 Jul 2, 2012 7:05 pm


Originally Posted by vmsea (Post 18860075)
Go to Costco.. get some Chateau st Michelle, indian wells cab.. i think they're 14 bucks.. pretty good for the money.

IMHO, Columbia Crest H3 (Horse Heaven Hills) Cabernet is better, and slightly cheaper (usually under $12) from the same area.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:09 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.