FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Delta Air Lines | SkyMiles (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/delta-air-lines-skymiles-665/)
-   -   Is DM really this useless? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/delta-air-lines-skymiles/2204862-dm-really-useless.html)

GagaPilot Oct 8, 2025 8:25 pm


Originally Posted by ATOBTTR (Post 37362344)
If you’re that close to DM, I’d either 1) mileage run for it (even on miles since you’d get MQDs miles with basically zero out of pocket cash cost) or 2) buy a Delta gift card this year that will provide enough MQDs from the purchase aspect that you can still use for next year and at least the MQDs from flying will still be earned in 2026 for 2027. With no rollover it seems almost silly to be so close and not get above the DM threshold especially since you could get direct cash value that would offset the difference like the $700 AmEx credit and either miles or a Delta voucher plus get GUCs and such.

Normally I’d agree with you and go for a mileage run since it’s so close, however I might not have been clear in my post, I already have DM for 2026 due to status extension. The only benefit to crossing the $28K MQD threshold in this case is gaining access to CBs instantly - otherwise I will get access around Feb 1st.

MP2086 Oct 8, 2025 10:03 pm


Originally Posted by xliioper (Post 37360977)
One simple way to search is with Google Flights in calendar view. Looking at SLC-AMS route as an example, one-way Z fares go for $4K and under (after selecting a few flights and looking at fare class). So you can just look for dates on Google Flights which are showing a price of $4K or under which means there must be at least one flight with Z class inventory open. These Z fares do have a 50 day advance purchase requirement, so this technique will work as long as flights are more than 50 days out.

The reverse direction is a bit more involved since all Z fares in EU-US direction require a roundtrip booking from the US. But once you know dates with Z bucket open on outbound, you can use a roundtrip search on Google Flights and look at total price to find dates with Z bucket open on return. You can see from below that Sunday flights and mid-week flights frequently have Z bucket open. While dates with flights with Z inventory open is relatively tight in May, there are quite a few dates in June with availability (20 out of 30 days).

Thanks! This is great advice. I was able to find some availability for my GUCs. It looks like we might be going to Amsterdam for spring break.


Originally Posted by Weekend Away (Post 37360885)
You were flying a hub to hub route, upgrades will be hard to come by. Flying ATL to spoke cities, I've been upgraded many times the past year or two as a silver.

I'm finding it hard to believe that IAD-ORD or IAD-IAH were handing out upgrades to you on UA.

UA upgrades based on fare class, and I do a lot of last minute flying on Y, so I'm guessing that's why I was getting the upgrades.


Originally Posted by WantFunBuyFun (Post 37362323)
In my view if a paying J customer has IRROPs and needs a seat on a recovery flight they should oversell and bump someone who didn't buy it too, but I suspect that wouldn't be universally popular.

I've been upgraded and subsequently bumped back down to Economy a couple times. It only pissed me off the one time United did it as I was boarding.

DLATL777 Oct 9, 2025 2:29 am


Originally Posted by DLASflyer (Post 37362229)
It depends where you are, when you fly and what equipment Delta uses in your market. I’m Diamond and get upgraded around 40% of the time. Here’s an example from today of Delta upgrading every eligble person with any status or even just a Reserve card. And after upgrading the whole list they still have two empty F seats. (The flight was almost full.)

Finding outliers and exceptions is certainly possible, but this was directed at the majority of circumstance.

sydneyracquelle Oct 9, 2025 6:18 am


Originally Posted by FlyBitcoin (Post 37361940)
Why DM is worth it.
  • $700 AMEX credit is worth.... $700

$1,100 if you include the PM Amex credit.

ATOBTTR Oct 9, 2025 6:58 am


Originally Posted by GagaPilot (Post 37362401)
Normally I’d agree with you and go for a mileage run since it’s so close, however I might not have been clear in my post, I already have DM for 2026 due to status extension. The only benefit to crossing the $28K MQD threshold in this case is gaining access to CBs instantly - otherwise I will get access around Feb 1st.

Ah, re-reading your post I do see that now and yes, that makes sense. :tu:

Daremo999 Oct 9, 2025 9:11 am

Expert Flyer is another option for using GUCs, use it to find Z class inventory and then you can use your GUC on partner airlines like AF/KLM. You typically have to call to do this, but it was easy once I knew what flights had inventory.

devans999 Oct 9, 2025 9:17 am


Originally Posted by jhartvu (Post 37360992)
First-year DM here. I cleared all 4 of my GUCs on transatlantic flights this year. All of my RUCs had me sitting in D1 on LAX-JFK transcons. I feel as if I’ve extracted maximum value from my certificates this year. YMMV.

I've used GUC's the last 3 years to book main cabin, upgrade to premium select to europe. Still haven't sat in the PS seat yet, got D1 every time. Closest I got was boarding and just putting my bag on the seat when I got the notification on my phone. Most have cleared at least a few hours before departure. Last 4 were last month, one cleared about an hour before, the other 3 on the way home cleared at T-24.

I've gotten a metric ton of value from those.

dilbertsdaddy Oct 9, 2025 10:06 am


Originally Posted by emma dog (Post 37360905)
FWIW, I’m flying TYS-ATL today ~30 min flight time. I was offered a $450 FCM at check in. And I’m 4/28 for one seat. I was watching the flight for a few days and there were maybe 3 seats open a week ago.

Which tells me that there are plenty of people paying for F. Maybe these folks are going to Europe out of ATL. Maybe there are a bunch of rich people/folks flying on OPM flying domestic F.

There are also at least 4 DM on my flight (me plus everyone above me).

As DLATL777 notes above, the upgrades at all the airlines have dropped off over the past 10-20+ years. I used to be upgraded regularly on US between PIT and SEA as a silver equivalent back in the 1990s. But between then and now, how may airlines have been forced into merger or bankruptcy? And in the same interval, F seats have gone from being ~3x+ coach to frequently only 25-50% more.

TYS has one of the highest concentrations of DM's in the system. I am at roughly 50% for upgrades to and from.

DLASflyer Oct 9, 2025 10:52 am

Glen was asked about long upgrade lists on the earnings call today. He basically said WFBF and upgrades are to C+ these days, not F.

FlyAO2 Oct 9, 2025 11:41 am

As bad as the upgrades have been I view Diamond as useful for these 4 things:

1) 4 RUCs (selected as platinum): People complain about these to no end, but I always find a way to use them. Z fares are regularly available in different markets and I use them for Caribbean trips. My value on these is $250-$300 each (so $1000-$1200)
2) 4 GUCs: I am not willing to use these and risk not getting DeltaOne double upgrade, so I buy Premium and upgrade to DeltaOne. Even with that - this is worth big money. I have not struggled to find availability
3) $700 AMEX Credit
4) 30,000 miles -- which I can usually squeeze about $400 out of.

The better phone support is nice, but not earth shattering and as noted, the higher priority for upgrades also isn't that meaningful.

To me - not even counting the GUCs which could be thousands, Diamond is worth $2000 - $2500 in tangible dollars...enough so that at the end of the year if I'm short, I'll pay taxes with the credit card to make up the difference.

ND76 Oct 9, 2025 11:54 am

Moving to CLE four years ago and being granted "lifetime DM" status as a 3 MMer has done wonders for my UG results. I don't always get UG'd; I was #1 of 60 on the UG list for 0 seats on a 321 ATL-CLE last year (I thought that was about as impressive as getting the last UG seat).

Tennis69 Oct 9, 2025 12:07 pm

For me, my upgrade % as a DM started going down when Delta switched from a miles flown to $ spent requirement for status. $ spent has diluted the pool to where you have DM who fly 2 times a year.

MSPeconomist Oct 9, 2025 12:29 pm


Originally Posted by Tennis69 (Post 37363531)
For me, my upgrade % as a DM started going down when Delta switched from a miles flown to $ spent requirement for status. $ spent has diluted the pool to where you have DM who fly 2 times a year.

I think it would be rare for someone to fly two D1 RTs in full J at about $14,000 per ticket and then buy a domestic nonbasic coach ticket and hope to get a free upgrade. Even so, such a person would fly more than twice a year.

Ben and Jerry Oct 9, 2025 12:35 pm


Originally Posted by FlyAO2 (Post 37363477)
As bad as the upgrades have been I view Diamond as useful for these 4 things:

1) 4 RUCs (selected as platinum): People complain about these to no end, but I always find a way to use them. Z fares are regularly available in different markets and I use them for Caribbean trips. My value on these is $250-$300 each (so $1000-$1200)
2) 4 GUCs: I am not willing to use these and risk not getting DeltaOne double upgrade, so I buy Premium and upgrade to DeltaOne. Even with that - this is worth big money. I have not struggled to find availability
3) $700 AMEX Credit
4) 30,000 miles -- which I can usually squeeze about $400 out of.

The better phone support is nice, but not earth shattering and as noted, the higher priority for upgrades also isn't that meaningful.

To me - not even counting the GUCs which could be thousands, Diamond is worth $2000 - $2500 in tangible dollars...enough so that at the end of the year if I'm short, I'll pay taxes with the credit card to make up the difference.

100% same for me.

xliioper Oct 9, 2025 12:38 pm


Originally Posted by Tennis69 (Post 37363531)
For me, my upgrade % as a DM started going down when Delta switched from a miles flown to $ spent requirement for status. $ spent has diluted the pool to where you have DM who fly 2 times a year.

Statiscally speaking, the chances of losing out on an upgrade to someone who only flies twice a year is going to be quite low. DL just noted today that they think revenue from premium seats may overtake economy seats within a year. I would say that is largely your answer.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 7:21 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.