FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Delta Air Lines | SkyMiles (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/delta-air-lines-skymiles-665/)
-   -   The Official Medallion Qualification Update Thread (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/delta-air-lines-skymiles/1428771-official-medallion-qualification-update-thread.html)

silverman2013 Jan 18, 2013 5:14 pm

The bottom line for me as a self-employed consultant who pulls in about 90k a year gross is that I will be doing less flying period. That will cost Delta about 2 k a year of revenue from me. And that likely add about that amount to my travel expenses in extra bag fees etc. But sitting here going over my 2012 travel getting ready for tax time, I can't see anyway I can even make Gold in 2014. And the twists and turns of trying to qualify are just not going to be worth the frustration. I can see a lot of us ending up right below award level and not being able to do much about it as the calculation is so complex. Especially sad is remembering the old days when you could write Worldperks if you were a few hundred miles "short" of Gold and they would graciously grant Gold status. I can't see Delta being as nice about it. A Million Miler with Silver status for life? That's worth almost nothing and I can't see have my bum in a seat for another 2 million miles to get Gold for life before I lose the ability to wipe that bum myself. I may as well just buy a first class fare when I want to treat myself now and then. My four years of Platinum and Diamond (1 year) with Delta after a 20 year NWA Gold? Nice while it lasted.

dgxoxo Jan 18, 2013 5:17 pm


Originally Posted by bubbashow (Post 20078185)
Here is why.

FO and GM siphon benefits. I just purchased a last-minute DTWLAX and there were no upgrade seats. I know - WF, BF. However, why should I (a Platinum) on a VERY, VERY, VERY high fare (yes out of my pocket) be sitting in back because a GM got a window upgrade?

THIN THE HERD so those paying the bills get the perks.

Agreed. All GM and FO upgrades should be at the battlefield so that DMs and PMs that buy within the upgrade window can get the upgrade inventory first.

DL2SXM Jan 18, 2013 5:18 pm


Originally Posted by silverman2013 (Post 20078358)
The bottom line for me as a self-employed consultant who pulls in about 90k a year gross is that I will be doing less flying period. That will cost Delta about 2 k a year of revenue from me. And that likely add about that amount to my travel expenses in extra bag fees etc. But sitting here going over my 2012 travel gettin ready for tax time, I can't see anyway I can even make Gold in 2014. I may as well just buy a first class fare when i want to treat myself now and then. My four years of Platinum and Diamond (1 year) with Delta after a 20 year NWA Gold? Nice while it lasted.

And there are folks on here who think that DL could care less about people like you. Thing is, if there are enough of people like you who withdraw their flying from Delta, you better believe its going to hurt. DL cant soley survive on HVC's.

jjlovecub Jan 18, 2013 5:22 pm


Originally Posted by dgxoxo (Post 20078368)
Agreed. All GM and FO upgrades should be at the battlefield so that DMs and PMs that buy within the upgrade window can get the upgrade inventory first.

Or buy your tickets earlier. It isn't a FO's fault you travel last minute


Originally Posted by DL2SXM (Post 20078369)
And there are folks on here who think that DL could care less about people like you. Thing is, if there are enough of people like you who withdraw their flying from Delta, you better believe its going to hurt. DL cant soley survive on HVC's.

I agree. They tried changing it years ago (reduced mqm on reduced fares). Enough did leave and they changed it back. Still do not see how this benefits DL at all.

NapaPatTours Jan 18, 2013 5:27 pm


Originally Posted by CPMaverick (Post 20077949)
I am a business traveller and my company takes all the NS flights no matter how much more they cost than connecting... so Delta does benefit from this strategy. And if they can fill the rest of the seats with connecting passengers, they win.

Your travel policy is much more liberal than many. ...and very foolish as well. If I owned stock in your company, this policy would be very disappointing to me. Based on your location, and the excessively wasteful travel policy, I very likely do own your stock. Only the OEMs or their major legacy suppliers would allow this kind of waste. This is why GM went from General Motors to Government Motors. The Big 3 will never learn. ...but that's a different topic for another forum.

DL2SXM Jan 18, 2013 5:34 pm


Originally Posted by jjlovecub (Post 20078379)
Or buy your tickets earlier. It isn't a FO's fault you travel last minute



I agree. They tried changing it years ago (reduced mqm on reduced fares). Enough did leave and they changed it back. Still do not see how this benefits DL at all.

Just got back from reading a similar thread on anet. One of the posters over their seems to think that in a few months time, new and enhanced bennies will be announced for the HVC who hits and maintains DM.

silverman2013 Jan 18, 2013 5:37 pm


Originally Posted by Builderman (Post 20078263)
You should stop talking about things you obviously don't know anything about.

Please explain what I don't understand. thanks.

SJC ORD LDR Jan 18, 2013 5:39 pm


Originally Posted by NapaPatTours (Post 20078401)
Your travel policy is much more liberal than many. ...and very foolish as well. If I owned stock in your company, this policy would be very disappointing to me. Based on your location, and the excessively wasteful travel policy, I very likely do own your stock. Only the OEMs or their major legacy suppliers would allow this kind of waste. This is why GM went from General Motors to Government Motors. The Big 3 will never learn. ...but that's a different topic for another forum.

So, a company actually thinks that it is worth more money to have their employees in the air less time and have them on the ground doing work is a bad thing?

Usually the savings from taking a connection or a roundabout route is not worth the $100 in savings from a connecting ticket.

If anything, while this decreases loyalty, it increases spend on an airline per mile.

bdschobel Jan 18, 2013 5:39 pm


Originally Posted by pbarnette (Post 20077904)
Virtually all my spend is from my own pocket and I don't consider it a big deal.


Originally Posted by DL2SXM (Post 20077961)
It must be nice to have money to throw at delta then. As for me and the majority of people on FT whose spend comes from their own pockets, thats not the case.


Originally Posted by pbarnette (Post 20077983)
Yes. It is nice to have money. I am very fortunate.

It's even nicer not to brag about your good fortune. Anyway, many people with lots and lots of money (such as John D. Rockefeller long ago and Warren Buffett today) don't spend it foolishly. I'd rather have money in my bank account than in Delta's. But that's just me, I suppose....

Bruce

DL2SXM Jan 18, 2013 5:40 pm

The new bennies that are supposed to be announced soon are supposed to be very generous in nature. I wonder if this means that future DM's can expect to redeem SWU's at a reduced M fare cost for international travel then what is currently available?

RobertS975 Jan 18, 2013 5:42 pm


Originally Posted by DCAproducer (Post 20077977)
I'm sure this has been asked, but I'm not reading 65 pages of posts.

So what about a traveler who buys premium tickets and spends above $12,500, but only flies 60k MQM. If DL is putting a value on how much you spend, they should be just as "valuable" as a PM who has 100,000 MQM and spends $8000.

Maybe qualify on MQM, MQD or Segments.

At the same time, if you're buying premium tickets, what do you care about upgrades and free bags.

All that should really matter to DL is dollar spend... miles flown are unimportant, and so are segments. Neither translate or even correlates to "value".

DL2SXM Jan 18, 2013 5:45 pm


Originally Posted by bdschobel (Post 20078461)
It's even nicer not to brag about your good fortune. Anyway, many people with lots and lots of money (such as John D. Rockefeller long ago and Warren Buffett today) don't spend it foolishly. I'd rather have money in my bank account than in Delta's. But that's just me, I suppose....

Bruce

very true, unless your getting something back for spending more, as might be the case.

jamesteroh Jan 18, 2013 5:59 pm


Originally Posted by bubbashow (Post 20078185)
Here is why.

FO and GM siphon benefits. I just purchased a last-minute DTWLAX and there were no upgrade seats. I know - WF, BF. However, why should I (a Platinum) on a VERY, VERY, VERY high fare (yes out of my pocket) be sitting in back because a GM got a window upgrade?

THIN THE HERD so those paying the bills get the perks.

Are you sure that there were any golds or silvers (except those on a full Y fare or using points/miles to upgrade) sitting up front that did NOT pay for a first class ticket? Delta typically holds back first class seats. I take that route at least four times a year and as a PM there are a lot of times I don't get upgraded until the gate and sometimes sit in the back as a PM when the ticket was bought over a month in advance.

It is possible every seat was sold up front as well. Last summer I flew DTW/LAS and BOTH ways EF had F=0 over a week before the flight.

When I was FO, I don't remember ever sitting up front unless I bought a First class ticket and only cleared a couple times as a gold on that route.

I think FCM is more to blame than clearing FO's or GM's at the window. Since you must have bought the ticket less than 48 hours out if the FO upgrade window had passed, it is possible that only DM's and PM's cleared into first and others paid for their first class ticket. When I flew that route Labor day weekend there were only a few seats available up front (bought it a few days in advance) and first class was only about $75 more RT than a coach fare (can't remember the fare class but it wasn't a Y, B or M). FOr $75 I would have been stupid not to take it, I was guaranteed to sit up front and get an aisle seat plus I received almost 2,000 extra MQMs.

Ebes1099 Jan 18, 2013 6:06 pm


Originally Posted by pbarnette (Post 20077677)
How has DL not been honest?

Loyalty is a two way street? What is their definition of loyalty? Am I less loyal if I fly all of my flights for they year on Delta and accrue 100,000 miles but only spend $3,000 or if I split my travel between multiple carriers but spend $8,000 on Delta and fly 80,000 miles?

According to the new program, it's not about loyalty, it's only about the dollars. And like I said, that's their decision, but don't pretend it's about loyalty.

coinboy66 Jan 18, 2013 6:10 pm


Originally Posted by DL2SXM (Post 20078329)
Can you provide a link to this poll?

Here it is:

http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/Y63TYGB


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 8:08 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.