![]() |
Originally Posted by pointman
(Post 8455967)
Ummm, be careful with this. It may have a place under certain circumstances, but paying 2.49% plus $20 per transactions simply to earn miles is, well, idiotic. A $1,000 payment costs $45 in fees. There is no rewards card that can consistently return 4.5% and you'd need that to just break even for your fees! You're far better simply dropping $45 (or whatever the fee would be) in a savings account. At the end of the year, you can spend the cash on your "reward" travel.
Sorry... :td: By the way, we all know that "writetorich" hates TYP, is a firm believer is all things created by AMEX, and that if any program faces a devaluation -- that program SUCKS !!! but we must hear it all the time :D |
What is also somewhat nice about this program is the possibility of the extra float depending on when the charge hits vs. when your statement cuts.
If you can get a credit card whose statement cuts on the 30th, and you mortgage is due on the 15th, you pay your mortgage on the 1st then you have all that extra time before your payment is due. If you switch cards every month you can in theory come out ahead. -Dave |
Originally Posted by MrDave
(Post 8456827)
What is also somewhat nice about this program is the possibility of the extra float depending on when the charge hits vs. when your statement cuts.
If you can get a credit card whose statement cuts on the 30th, and you mortgage is due on the 15th, you pay your mortgage on the 1st then you have all that extra time before your payment is due. If you switch cards every month you can in theory come out ahead. -Dave |
Originally Posted by mtparadis
(Post 8458404)
You "come out ahead" by saving a few days of of interest but paying ~4% for the convenience? If you have a mortgage payment that you need to float, get a smaller house.
-Dave |
Originally Posted by MrDave
(Post 8458818)
...it's not 4% it's 2.5%...
|
If we're getting into details, the fee is 2.49% + $19.99. If your mortgage payment is $199,900 or more, the total fee will be 2.5% or less. :D
|
Originally Posted by mtparadis
(Post 8458404)
You "come out ahead" by saving a few days of of interest but paying ~4% for the convenience? If you have a mortgage payment that you need to float, get a smaller house.
Here is how: 1. Set up your credit card billing cycle to start a couple of days before your payment is due. This will give you a 45 day float (25 days for statement to end + 20 days before payment is due) 2. Pay the credit card using MBNA bill pay. If you set up billing cycle on your MBNA card to start a couple of days before payment is due on above credit card you will get another 45 days or so of float. |
Even if you get your "float" to 90 days, that means long run (after the first 90 days), you will just be on a three month lag so have three months of mortgage payments you could earn interest on. Depending on your mortgage amount and savings account rates, you're probably looking at a couple hundred bucks a year tops.
|
Originally Posted by pointman
(Post 8455967)
Ummm, be careful with this. It may have a place under certain circumstances, but paying 2.49% plus $20 per transactions simply to earn miles is, well, idiotic. A $1,000 payment costs $45 in fees. There is no rewards card that can consistently return 4.5% and you'd need that to just break even for your fees! You're far better simply dropping $45 (or whatever the fee would be) in a savings account. At the end of the year, you can spend the cash on your "reward" travel.
Sorry... :td: Also this is not new at all, there is another out there and has been around for a couple of years that I know of. Rich, Ive started to look at TYN more closely since discovering AMEX Plat and I can show you ways of redeeming Long-Haul J flights which are the most efficient use of miles/points, period. But now gotta run, ill resume later. |
Originally Posted by mtparadis
(Post 8459654)
Even if you get your "float" to 90 days, that means long run (after the first 90 days), you will just be on a three month lag so have three months of mortgage payments you could earn interest on. Depending on your mortgage amount and savings account rates, you're probably looking at a couple hundred bucks a year tops.
|
I would consider it valuable if I was really close to hitting a threshold bonus for spending or during a double/triple points promotion. Sadly, most cards I would want to do this for are AMEX.
|
Originally Posted by bombayduck
(Post 8443590)
Jake,
I find your discussion to many questions honest and compelling to look at the service.... So , if i have to pay my monthly Chase car loan , do I have to advice them prior that i would pay it on CardIt or that step is not necessary...will be happy to consider mortgage payments down the road after the fee stumbling block gets eleminated. Thanks. An integral part of our service offering is *not* having to advise your lender, be it for your car or your mortgage payment. It is received as an electronic check on your behalf. |
Now, we are really starting to "nickel and dime"....theortically it is possible to earn some interest due to the lag...but here is something to consider:
1) Will the interest equal the fees or even 50% of fees associated with each and every single transaction? NO !!! 2) Will this create more headaches for someone who is trying to make this work? YES !! Personally, not for me :td::td: If anyone wants to try it and run a 6 month figures including your time spend, I would love to look at thew figures over a few beers !!! My treat !! |
Let's assume you are already charging every possible to dollar to your preferred cards. Along comes an offer like this...
Citi® Platinum Select® / AAdvantage® World MasterCard® Earn up to 40,000 bonus miles. Earn 20,000 AAdvantage® bonus miles after you make $750 in purchases within 4 months of becoming a cardmember. Earn 10,000 AAdvantage® bonus miles after you make $10,000 in purchases during your FIRST year as a cardmember and 10,000 additional AAdvantage® bonus miles after you make 10,000 in purchases during your SECOND year as a cardmember. Plus, no annual fee for 12 months. You could earn these bonuses by diverting dollars from other cards, or you could use dollars from your mortgage or income taxes that are currently paid by check. Let's say you make four $2,500 payments in the first twelve months, and incur $329 in fees. 10,329 miles for spending $10,329 20,000 miles bonus ($750) 10,000 miles bonus ($10,000) 40,329 @ $0.00816 per mile |
One other thing that I just thought of:
[Dishonest mode on] If you are a business owner, and put through a large amount of charges every month, you could easily put another 3 or 4 thousand on the card and "forget" to list is as income at then end of the year. One of my customers has on average $175,000 to $200,000 on his business card every month (him and 10 or so users) it's his business so it would be a simple matter for him to take almost another $60,000 out of the business a year and not pay taxes on it. [Dishonest mode off] The above would have very limited application in the world but I could see it being useful for some people. -Dave |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 5:58 am. |
This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.