FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Coronavirus and travel (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/coronavirus-travel-773/)
-   -   Have you used BinaxNow Home Test to successfully transit in Germany? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/coronavirus-travel/2041471-have-you-used-binaxnow-home-test-successfully-transit-germany.html)

FlyingfromDC Jun 1, 2021 2:56 am

Have you used BinaxNow Home Test to successfully transit in Germany?
 
Flying United from the U.S. to Frankfurt this summer, and looking to confirm if anyone has had their BinaxNow Home Test result on the NAVICA app accepted by the German authorities during transit? It appears to meet their requirements. My final destination country will be fine with it.

PlowJockey Jun 2, 2021 2:59 pm

Following - same question regarding acceptance by AA and Rome for the "quarantine-free" flights DFW-FCO.

LondonElite Jun 2, 2021 3:01 pm

Is this a home rapid test?

FlyingfromDC Jun 2, 2021 4:20 pm


Originally Posted by LondonElite (Post 33298343)
Is this a home rapid test?

Yes, it is the video proctored antigen test accepted by the CDC for return to the U.S. Just looking for experiences with this one for German transit. Are they used to seeing the certificates on the NAVICA app?

sgopal2 Jun 2, 2021 4:30 pm

I used the BinaxNow test to return back to the US today. Unfortunately did not transit through Germany.

But a couple of points about the Navica app:
1) It calculates the days since the negative test differently as compared to the CDC. Normally a negative test within 3 days is allowed. The Navica app starts counting 1 day earlier. So in this case you might be better off with a print out instead of showing the App
2) The share function for negative results on Navica doesn't seem to work properly from an iPad version of Navica. Works much better in the iPhone version. I couldn't get it to share the results from my iPad properly

FlyingfromDC Jun 2, 2021 6:27 pm


Originally Posted by sgopal2 (Post 33298504)
But a couple of points about the Navica app:
1) It calculates the days since the negative test differently as compared to the CDC. Normally a negative test within 3 days is allowed. The Navica app starts counting 1 day earlier. So in this case you might be better off with a print out instead of showing the App
2) The share function for negative results on Navica doesn't seem to work properly from an iPad version of Navica. Works much better in the iPhone version. I couldn't get it to share the results from my iPad properly

Thanks for these tips! I plan to have results printed out as well as saved as screenshots in case of wifi trouble. I have the app on my iPhone.

LondonElite Jun 2, 2021 10:34 pm

At this point self administered tests are not accepted, and I would guess that they won’t be in the future. Stick with a PCR test.

FlyingfromDC Jun 3, 2021 2:35 am


Originally Posted by LondonElite (Post 33299147)
At this point self administered tests are not accepted, and I would guess that they won’t be in the future. Stick with a PCR test.

The latest guidance from Germany states that antigen tests are accepted, not just PCR: “Alternatively, a negative antigen rapid test result in German, English, French, Italian or Spanish. Following a stay in a risk area or high incidence area, the test must have been carried out no more than 48 hours prior to entry.”

The antigen tests accepted then are elaborated on further, and one of the requirements is that the third party administering the test checks the ID of the person taking the test. This is done by eMed via video who we purchased the Abbott BinaxNow Home Test from. Lufthansa guidance on tests also says that the test m
ust be certified by a doctor or a recognised laboratory - again the eMed issued test checks a box here. It does not say that telehealth option is not allowed.

That’s why I’m wondering if anyone from the U.S. has presented this test result from eMed to German authorities, and has either had success or ran into a problem when in transit through Frankfurt or Munich?

Deckter Jun 3, 2021 3:46 am


Originally Posted by FlyingfromDC (Post 33299395)
The latest guidance from Germany states that antigen tests are accepted, not just PCR: “Alternatively, a negative antigen rapid test result in German, English, French, Italian or Spanish. Following a stay in a risk area or high incidence area, the test must have been carried out no more than 48 hours prior to entry.”

The antigen tests accepted then are elaborated on further, and one of the requirements is that the third party administering the test checks the ID of the person taking the test. This is done by eMed via video who we purchased the Abbott BinaxNow Home Test from. Lufthansa guidance on tests also says that the test m
ust be certified by a doctor or a recognised laboratory - again the eMed issued test checks a box here. It does not say that telehealth option is not allowed.

That’s why I’m wondering if anyone from the U.S. has presented this test result from eMed to German authorities, and has either had success or ran into a problem when in transit through Frankfurt or Munich?

Do you get a piece of paper/digital with the lab signature, result and test accuracy?

FlyingfromDC Jun 3, 2021 3:58 am


Originally Posted by Deckter (Post 33299475)
Do you get a piece of paper/digital with the lab signature, result and test accuracy?

You get both a digital pass and a test certificate for printing. I’m not sure if accuracy and specificity are included in the certificate, so I will print out test specs from Abbott separately (just in case).

Anyone use this yet at a German airport?

Xyzzy Jun 3, 2021 4:22 pm

FYI - this is what eMed is offering. It's video m:)nitored as described above and each test kit comes with an app for verification of the test kit. (United is accepting the app display for use in clearing passengers to board for re-entering the US.)

FlyingfromDC Jun 3, 2021 4:50 pm


Originally Posted by Xyzzy (Post 33301406)
(United is accepting the app display for use in clearing passengers to board for re-entering the US.)

While re-entering the U.S. seems to be fine with this test, I would love to know if anyone has had trouble with United using this test result for OUTBOUND flight though? I have been able to confirm that vaccination card is now accepted for transit in Germany in lieu of the negative test. The issue then is with kids who are older than 6 (not exempt per German rules) but under 12 (not eligible for the vaccine). Mine are terrified of the nasal swab in a lab, so the home video test would be much gentler and easier on them.

Xyzzy Jun 3, 2021 5:44 pm


Originally Posted by FlyingfromDC (Post 33301494)
While re-entering the U.S. seems to be fine with this test, I would love to know if anyone has had trouble with United using this test result for OUTBOUND flight though? I have been able to confirm that vaccination card is now accepted for transit in Germany in lieu of the negative test. The issue then is with kids who are older than 6 (not exempt per German rules) but under 12 (not eligible for the vaccine). Mine are terrified of the nasal swab in a lab, so the home video test would be much gentler and easier on them.

Indeed - those are excellent questions. FWIW, the tests CVS gives at their drive through windows in the US are monitored self-swab tests. Look here under "How is my sample for testing collected?"

I h:ppe this helps...

FlyingfromDC Jun 4, 2021 9:02 am

Update: I just called the airline to ask them (United) and the rep read through the guidance that was just updated on June 2. She said their agents are trained to only look for two things: that the test type is correct (antigen in the case of BinaxNow Home Test), and that the result will not be older than 48 hrs upon arrival in Germany. They see lots of different certificates on a daily basis. Home tests are not specifically banned when performed under supervision. In fact, she said she knows there are testing services that go to the home of the passenger to deliver a kit and again to pick it up.

exp Jun 4, 2021 10:50 am


Originally Posted by FlyingfromDC (Post 33303055)
Update: I just called the airline to ask them (United) and the rep read through the guidance that was just updated on June 2. She said their agents are trained to only look for two things: that the test type is correct (antigen in the case of BinaxNow Home Test), and that the result will not be older than 48 hrs upon arrival in Germany. They see lots of different certificates on a daily basis. Home tests are not specifically banned when performed under supervision. In fact, she said she knows there are testing services that go to the home of the passenger to deliver a kit and again to pick it up.


The question is what the German authorities will do, will they accept looking at your app or maybe a printout from the app or a PDF of a printout shown on your phone screen?

Does BinaxNow generate a QR code?

The issue is, even if they don't accept a home test, why would some random testing lab in the US be more reliable to them?

France is requiring proof of vaccination AND test results from Americans, including Antigen test results.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 5:45 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.