FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   China (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/china-613/)
-   -   Fly or Train?: Beijing to Shanghai (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/china/1776371-fly-train-beijing-shanghai.html)

m3red Jul 9, 2016 10:47 am


Originally Posted by 889 (Post 26892694)
Generally two or three weeks ahead works for getting decent airfares, unless you're travelling at a holiday period.

There can be fairly big seasonal differences in fares, with discounts being greater in the winter than summer.

Also, discounts tend to appear on busy, well-travelled routes. Flights in and out of a small place like Huangshan, for example, often don't get discounted that much.

Thanks - looking at Beijing to xian, Xiang to chengdu and chengdu to Guilin. I'll wait til,3 weeks out.

dongyeh Jul 10, 2016 11:29 pm


Originally Posted by anacapamalibu (Post 26883451)
How do you locate the train # for the 350 KM departures?

All the HSR trains are running at 300km/h, the only difference is that some of them stops at only one (Nanjing) or two (Nanjing/Ji'nan) stations (~4hrs50mins) while others have 5+ stops (5hrs30mins~6hrs).

moondog Jul 10, 2016 11:35 pm


Originally Posted by dongyeh (Post 26898601)
All the HSR trains are running at 300km/h, the only difference is that some of them stops at only one (Nanjing) or two (Nanjing/Ji'nan) stations (~4hrs50mins) while others have 5+ stops (5hrs30mins~6hrs).

Single digit trains stop in Nanjing only.
Most, but not all, double digit trains stop in Nanjing and Jinan only.
Triple digit trains have at least 3 stops.

dongyeh Jul 10, 2016 11:44 pm


Originally Posted by moondog (Post 26881887)
Which trains were speed up? I just checked Shanghai-Beijing on 12306, and the fastest trains are still 4:48 (G2, G4, G8). Incidentally, G8 is a welcome addition to the schedule because it makes it possible to work an entire day before leaving.

Regarding the decrease from 350 to 300, this happened after that accident in ~2010, and safety was the stated reason for the change. However, since that accident had nothing to do with the speed of travel, I have long suspected that saving money was the --behind the scenes-- reason. During testing of the Jing-Hu Line, I recall reading that some trains were run at very high speeds (e.g. 450).

The speed decrease was introduced soon after the former minister of railway Liu Zhijun sacked early 2011. While the accident happened after the decrease event. Actually, there is no connection between them.

dongyeh Jul 10, 2016 11:53 pm


Originally Posted by moondog (Post 26898610)
Single digit trains stop in Nanjing only.
Most, but not all, double digit trains stop in Nanjing and Jinan only.
Triple digit trains have at least 3 stops.

Not exactly
G6 stops at Najing & Ji'nan
G## < G20 usually only stops at Nanjing & Ji'nan, while G12 has 5 stops
Others 5+:p

moondog Jul 10, 2016 11:58 pm


Originally Posted by dongyeh (Post 26898643)
Not exactly
G6 stops at Najing & Ji'nan
G## < G20 usually only stops at Nanjing & Ji'nan, while G12 has 5 stops
Others 5+:p

Oops. I forgot about G5/6.

In the original Jinghu HSR schedule, 2-digit trains adhered to the 2-stop convention, but this went out the window when they starting trying to optimize things.

dongyeh Jul 11, 2016 12:02 am


Originally Posted by moondog (Post 26898654)
Oops. I forgot about G5/6.

In the original Jinghu HSR schedule, 2-digit trains adhered to the 2-stop convention, but this went out the window when they starting trying to optimize things.

I think it is mainly because they departures early. If stopping less, they might not have enough passengers.:D

YuropFlyer Jul 11, 2016 2:13 am

I guess for trains it's quite similar than with cars: After a certain point of speed, consumption goes up so much it's simply not worth it.

I can drive my car at 80km/h or 120km/h for about the same consumption (5l/100km) - when I go up to 150 or 160km/h, I'll have an increase of about 20-40%, still reasonable for the speed I gain (compared to 120km/h) - I gain about as much time as the extra consumption is.

But if I press it above that, consumption does increase much more than the raw speed gain. I can imagine that 300km/h for a train is about the same as 150km/h for my car. Go above it, and it uses much more electric power than going just a little bit slower.

And considering the HSR operator probably got told to be more efficent, they'll keep it that way, unless going at higher speed gets them more money.

moondog Jul 11, 2016 2:32 am


Originally Posted by YuropFlyer (Post 26898904)
I guess for trains it's quite similar than with cars: After a certain point of speed, consumption goes up so much it's simply not worth it.

I believe this principle applies to pretty much all modes of transportation (at least within the earth's atmosphere).

dongyeh Jul 11, 2016 3:53 am


Originally Posted by YuropFlyer (Post 26898904)
I guess for trains it's quite similar than with cars: After a certain point of speed, consumption goes up so much it's simply not worth it.

I can drive my car at 80km/h or 120km/h for about the same consumption (5l/100km) - when I go up to 150 or 160km/h, I'll have an increase of about 20-40%, still reasonable for the speed I gain (compared to 120km/h) - I gain about as much time as the extra consumption is.

But if I press it above that, consumption does increase much more than the raw speed gain. I can imagine that 300km/h for a train is about the same as 150km/h for my car. Go above it, and it uses much more electric power than going just a little bit slower.

And considering the HSR operator probably got told to be more efficent, they'll keep it that way, unless going at higher speed gets them more money.

The interesting thing is that China Railway only applies 5% price off for 350km/h->300km/h and 250km/h->200km/h :D Not sure how the cost is calculated:p


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 5:59 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.