FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Checkpoints and Borders Policy Debate (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/checkpoints-borders-policy-debate-687/)
-   -   'Removal of shoes is now optional' - true? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/checkpoints-borders-policy-debate/1158643-removal-shoes-now-optional-true.html)

goalie Dec 11, 2010 1:32 am


Originally Posted by exbayern (Post 15425646)
I believe that the poster I quoted is a TSO. However according to the TSA website


Yes, you are required to remove your shoes before you enter the walk-through metal detector. This includes all types of footwear.

Due to the Homeland Security threat level being raised for the U.S. aviation sector worldwide this is critical to protect the world's travelers who transit by air to and from the United States.

Our Security Officers will ask that you remove your shoes before entering the metal detector based on the fact that many types of footwear can be used to carry prohibited items. When a Security Officer asks you to remove your shoes, please do. If you refuse, you will not be able to board your flight.

You are required to remove your shoes before you enter the walk-through metal detector. All types of footwear must be placed on the X-ray machine to be screened. If you do not comply with Security Officers, you will not be allowed to board your flight
http://www.tsa.gov/travelers/airtrav...g/index.shtm#3

But let's not forget this part from here: http://www.tsa.gov/travelers/airtrav...al_1370.shtm#3


Advise the Security Officer if you are wearing orthopedic shoes, support appliances, or other exterior medical devices and where the devices are located. Security Officers should not ask you to remove your orthopedic shoes, appliances, or medical device (insulin pump, feeding tube, ostomy or urine bag, or exterior component of cochlear implant) at any time during the screening process.

ghostrider10 Dec 11, 2010 1:39 am


Originally Posted by saizai (Post 15425725)

Lol this video is the epitome of security theatre. First they state that it's easier to scan shoes if they're out of the bin. Then they are like "well if you're concerned about your expensive shoes getting damaged then you can put them in a bin", then at the end they are like "well soon you'll be able to keep your shoes on anyway". LOL. :rolleyes:

Umi206 Dec 11, 2010 1:51 am


Originally Posted by birdstrike (Post 15425708)
That is very, very scary. Why would "Most" people do something that was pointless from day one if it were no longer required today?

Maybe because everyone was first disarmed by the agent checking our IDs who was announcing who was on their way home and who was going to Hilo as a visitor and who wanted to "talk story" about Hilo with each of us. He was a very nice elderly Japanese man. As is ordinary in Hawaii, I saw about ten people I knew (about half of them I had met on the morning flight over) who asked me about my bandaged face and the ID agent asked me if I knew his relative who lives very near to me.

Then as we were putting our things in the bins we all started laughing because one of the agents checking items on the belt was loudly singing a ridiculous song parodying "Don't Touch My Junk". It was hilarious (about how to avoid getting "too much love" from the TSA). So, I think most removed their shoes out of habit and distraction and I also think a lot did not read the rules so didn't notice the change. I said something to the person next me and we wondered if we should remove them or not and wondered if the change was "real" even though it was on an official sign. I always wear pantihose or knee highs even with sandals unless I have shorts on so I wasn't worried about catching toe nail fungus or something if I was bare footed.

Another different thing was there was no search of automobiles entering the parking lot at Hilo but the sign about searching cars was still there. So, I suppose it was because it was 5AM.

sheneh Dec 11, 2010 7:25 am

I remember being told I could leave them on some time ago but mostly not. In fact at least once I've kept them on despite being told I didn't need to because I knew they would set off the WTMD. Which airports had which when I don't recall.

Boggie Dog Dec 11, 2010 8:01 am

Going through LAS yesterday afternoon as while in line for screening TSA had video signage and one sign stated that shoes did not have to be removed but not doing so would likely result in increased screening.

That caught my eye.

Also while not related to this thread the LAS D checkpoint had no NOS in operation on a busy Friday afternoon.

I thought that a bit strange.

exbayern Dec 11, 2010 8:08 am


Originally Posted by Umi206 (Post 15425872)
I was also surprised that there was no one searching our vehicles as we entered the parking lot and figured that was because it was so early in the morning.


Originally Posted by Umi206 (Post 15425918)
Another different thing was there was no search of automobiles entering the parking lot at Hilo but the sign about searching cars was still there. So, I suppose it was because it was 5AM.

Are you saying that at ITO they search all cars entering the airport? Or are you referring to the general cautionary sign that cars are subject to search? They simply do not search every car at the vast majority of airports because the wait time would be astronomical.

A few years ago shoe removal was 'optional' but as FT shows, 'optional' meant something very different to many TSOs, just as the removal of orthopedic shoes and medical devices may not be 'required' but is interpreted differently by many TSOs.

And I can assure you that I was peeved to see TSOs getting angry at foreign passengers who didn't remove their shoes a few days ago. It peeved me because there was no signage to remove shoes, and since we don't play the shoe game in the rest of the world, there was no way to know this.

TSA may be moving to 'shoe removal is again optional' but if a TSO confirms this, it is just like the quart/gallon bag issue - very poorly executed.

edj3 Dec 11, 2010 8:12 am

I just flew out of Hilo last night and didn't see that sign about shoes at security. And I've never had my car searched at that airport, or even seen anyone who would be in a position to search it.

sirdatary Dec 11, 2010 8:47 am


Originally Posted by Umi206 (Post 15425683)
There was a new TSA rule posted on a big sign (along with other rules) for everyone to see as they entered the security line. The rule stated that removing shoes is optional. I saw this rule at both Hilo, Hawaii International Airport yesterday morning and at Honolulu International Airport Interisland terminal upon returning yesterday afternoon. The agents were also telling passengers that they could leave their shoes on. Most of us removed them anyway and put them in the bins. The agents removed all shoes from the bins before they entered the Xray machine and put them separately on the belt apart from any other items.

Uh, yea, shoe scanning is so... 2002. TSA has much more fun things with which to occupy their time. Would you rather touch smelly shoes all day long, or grab strangers' crotches? I think the answer is pretty obvious.

Plus terrorists have stopped putting bombs in shoes, it has been proven that they put it in thier underwear now.

JoeBas Dec 11, 2010 9:11 am

This isn't a policy change at all.

Shoe removal has always been "optional", with "Additional security" (I.E. Auto Secondary Grope-Fest) if you don't "Volunteer".

TXagogo Dec 11, 2010 9:22 am

Makes sense in a way.

TSA: Let's tell them now that they can keep their shoes on. It' will make it look as if we're giving in on something. And now, if they do go through WTMD it will be more likely to set it off and now we can feel up even more people. HIGH FIVE! Raises for everyone!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 4:40 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.