FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Cathay Pacific | Cathay (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/cathay-pacific-cathay-487/)
-   -   Almost 6 months after Asiamiles devaluation... (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/cathay-pacific-cathay/1951240-almost-6-months-after-asiamiles-devaluation.html)

ermen Jan 17, 2019 3:10 am


Originally Posted by toplayer (Post 30664530)
Yes, would prefer this as I can get some SQ status quite easily and this is somewhere my family needs to be at least once a year. But are the redemption issues just as bad as CX? It isn't about the cost as long as not too crazy, just availability. (This is what is really disappointing about CX/Asia Miles. I fly a ton, spend a ton and also spend a ton on flying, so earn a lot of points/miles. Shouldn't CX/Asia Miles be incentivizing us to earn more by spending/flying more on CX and its partners by giving us more ways to use the points/miles, rather than shut off avenues to spend and doing the opposite? This is like what happened with MPC a few years ago when I moved over to BAEC and never looked back, flying all sorts of (mainly) Oneworld airlines away from CX, almost always in paid J for work and pleasure. Now I may just dump CX/Oneworld altogether if all the points/miles I earned end up being useless. Status is one thing but the ability to burn what you earn is more important in my book. I don't understand this company.)

I am also exploring Skyteam options ex-HKG but it looks paltry.

Sorry for going OT!

no i find SQ to be relatively generous with their members with reasonable burn rates. and also more so if you are PPS.

cx is being stingy to both partners + its own members (well they do reserve some seats for their own members, but it is materially worse than before).

i heard its because of they hired some QF person to run their loyalty program. QF have a rubbish loyalty program - easy to earn but lousy to burn in premium cabins.

Rivarix Jan 18, 2019 5:15 am


Originally Posted by Gongzuokuang (Post 30661432)
I have tried two redemption trips since the devaluation and it was significantly more difficult -- and expensive. I saw no evidence of increased availability; quite the contrary.
I only look for business class roundtrip from North America. So perhaps there is increased availability in coach?

I think CX/AM is making AA and Avios redemption more difficult on certain routes/dates so on a relative basis, CX can claim AM is more valuable/has better availability. Of course that's not what we think when CX says additional availability ...
I noticed this several months ago and tested it again yesterday for HKG-CGK (J). No availability the week before CNY for AA and Avios redemption but plenty when using AM. CX uses married segment logic to 'block' both AA and Avios redemption because there are plenty of availability (5 J seats) when I asked for TPE-CGK. So no 'real' blocking but by limiting/making AA and Avios redemption more difficult, CX can claim there's increase availability for AM (on a relative basis). On this one route anyway ...

HarbourGent Jan 18, 2019 6:06 am


Originally Posted by PacificSunrise (Post 30662895)
CX is not santa claus

Availability one day a year and difficult to contact, I'd say they are pretty similar.

writetorich Jan 18, 2019 10:03 pm

sorry I use to have a lot of Asia miles . acct dormant for 6 to 7 years years
 
1- I know my old acct is worthless. I have no access to that email address.
2-I see an award chart ( it;s surprisingly transparent and completely detailed. IS the link below current?????
3- I have a lot of AA miles , maybe 700K ( also one world)
4- I was thinking of redeeming IHG points at an effective rate of 1.67 miles per Asia Miles. I note that they have addition reward partners besides American , altthough one world is obviously somewhat redundant. Would you do this transfer of 100K IHG points ON A SPECULATIVE BASIS??? I can always replace the IHG points.
5- I recall that Asiamiles was very tedious to deal with. Only Avios was worst. lets just say they were not in London.
https://www.asiamiles.com/en/redeem-...lesawardschart

do other quality carriers -- for United I have a strong dislike for them and I have no use for more American Miles.
I'm only using American as an example as I know the fare basis classes,
If a T class set is available in economy , does that mean its available using Asia miles?
or do they have there own inventory

Can premium cabins be gotten on short notice.?
Thank you to all for you kind answers.

kaka Jan 19, 2019 1:15 am

moving miles to a not so active ffp on a speculative basis is asking for trouble down the line, and avios is better than asiamiles.

that aside i would not move ihg-am unless u hv something in mind

rickywk Jan 31, 2019 6:31 pm

It's crazy Avios can redeem CX + BA married segment but AM returned zero seat with same itinerary. Don't know what AM is thinking.
:rolleyes:.

percysmith Jan 31, 2019 7:05 pm


Originally Posted by rickywk (Post 30725600)
It's crazy Avios can redeem CX + BA married segment but AM returned zero seat with same itinerary. Don't know what AM is thinking.
:rolleyes:.

Which flight?

Anything BAEC can get, AM can also get. Just that you have to look in Tailored.

rickywk Jan 31, 2019 7:19 pm


Originally Posted by percysmith (Post 30725695)
Which flight?

Anything BAEC can get, AM can also get. Just that you have to look in Tailored.

HKG->LHR->CPH (CX operated HKG->LHR)
Avios can redeem, but AM said flight full. I little bit drilled down and trying search HKG->LHR->ZRH, same result.
Funny enough.

percysmith Jan 31, 2019 7:47 pm


Originally Posted by rickywk (Post 30725744)
HKG->LHR->CPH (CX operated HKG->LHR)
Avios can redeem, but AM said flight full. I little bit drilled down and trying search HKG->LHR->ZRH, same result.
Funny enough.

LHR-CPH/LHR-ZRH has preferential BA availability?

What about HKG-LHR taking in isolation?

triplefives Jan 31, 2019 8:10 pm

For me, what made AM totally worthless now is HK allowing fuel surcharges on tickets and AM probably was heavily lobbying for this to happen.

As an example, there were some HKG-KIX tickets available for 3.3k cash round trip. If you want to redeem miles, it will cost you 20k AM and 1k in fuel surcharges. The HKG-Japan routes were specifically pointed out by AM as an example of a "better" change. What a joke.

The dumbest thing is crude went from $50/bbl to $70/bbl and CX/AM cried foul. A few months later, it reversed from $70/bbl to $50/bbl with CX pocketing the fuel surcharges. I worry about the potential impending doom of HK Airlines because this monopolistic behavior will further go unchecked without a viable competitor.

rickywk Jan 31, 2019 8:40 pm


Originally Posted by percysmith (Post 30725821)
LHR-CPH/LHR-ZRH has preferential BA availability?

What about HKG-LHR taking in isolation?

Yup, LHR-CPH/ZRH BA wide open, AM can also redeem it.
But if HKG-LHR only, both Avios and AM not able to redeem it

kaka Jan 31, 2019 8:43 pm


Originally Posted by triplefives (Post 30725880)
For me, what made AM totally worthless now is HK allowing fuel surcharges on tickets and AM probably was heavily lobbying for this to happen.

As an example, there were some HKG-KIX tickets available for 3.3k cash round trip. If you want to redeem miles, it will cost you 20k AM and 1k in fuel surcharges. The HKG-Japan routes were specifically pointed out by AM as an example of a "better" change. What a joke.

The dumbest thing is crude went from $50/bbl to $70/bbl and CX/AM cried foul. A few months later, it reversed from $70/bbl to $50/bbl with CX pocketing the fuel surcharges. I worry about the potential impending doom of HK Airlines because this monopolistic behavior will further go unchecked without a viable competitor.

there had always been YQ on ex HKG tickets. its just now its unregulated.
but yeh, i agree with you.

rickywk Jan 31, 2019 8:43 pm


Originally Posted by triplefives (Post 30725880)
For me, what made AM totally worthless now is HK allowing fuel surcharges on tickets and AM probably was heavily lobbying for this to happen.

As an example, there were some HKG-KIX tickets available for 3.3k cash round trip. If you want to redeem miles, it will cost you 20k AM and 1k in fuel surcharges. The HKG-Japan routes were specifically pointed out by AM as an example of a "better" change. What a joke.

The dumbest thing is crude went from $50/bbl to $70/bbl and CX/AM cried foul. A few months later, it reversed from $70/bbl to $50/bbl with CX pocketing the fuel surcharges. I worry about the potential impending doom of HK Airlines because this monopolistic behavior will further go unchecked without a viable competitor.

JAL fuel charge in HKG-TYO route even higher than CX, CAD sucks.

FlyPointyEnd Feb 5, 2019 7:23 pm

Recently saw someone post on IG that while BA shows availability for HKG-HND-HKG, CX doesn't....how is that even possible!?!

bluepanda Feb 5, 2019 8:05 pm

JL now shows up online (I was searching for one-ways). Does it mean AM now allows one-way JL redemptions?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 4:56 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.