FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   British Airways | Executive Club (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/british-airways-executive-club-446/)
-   -   380 or 777 in F from LHR-HKG (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/british-airways-executive-club/1961813-380-777-f-lhr-hkg.html)

sahajesh Mar 20, 2019 5:49 pm

380 or 777 in F from LHR-HKG
 
Hi

Planning a special trip for the two of us (sale pricing) and wondering which is the best plane to get for F travel - gut says the A380 as a newer plane design or are they the same (hard product experience) regardless of the plane type?

Thanks
Sahajesh.

haroon145 Mar 20, 2019 5:54 pm

I only fly CX on this route or QR via Doha

however, having done F on both 777 and a380, a380 every time

Bullswood Mar 20, 2019 6:00 pm


Originally Posted by haroon145 (Post 30911001)
I only fly CX on this route or QR via Doha

however, having done F on both 777 and a380, a380 every time

A380 without doubt IMHO.

sahajesh Mar 20, 2019 6:19 pm

Thanks all. Will go for that - now need to choose a hotel for the first 5 days too!

PETER01 Mar 20, 2019 6:24 pm

Plenty of hotels, so so many at all different price levels but for what its worth I've stayed at The Cordis in Mongkok (formerly The Langham in Mongkok) a fair few times over the years last time in November last year for a week.

Wonderful staff, service, food, rooms especially the club floor rooms. The hotel is linked to a huge mall which the MTR is easily accessed from from the centre.

I'd also choose the A380 too.

Soupdragon62 Mar 20, 2019 7:39 pm

380 and The Peninsula

Close the thread :)

BobServant Mar 20, 2019 7:40 pm

A380 for sure.

sxc Mar 20, 2019 9:03 pm


Originally Posted by Soupdragon62 (Post 30911287)
380 and The Peninsula

Close the thread :)

There are better and more interesting hotels than The Peninsula.

brunos Mar 20, 2019 10:21 pm


Originally Posted by sxc (Post 30911488)
There are better and more interesting hotels than The Peninsula.

Indeed.
HK hotels tend to have small rooms, beware, and views make a huge difference in pricing.
Hotel prices vary immensely over time. ALthough they tend to go up and down together during busy/quiet periods, correlation varies. So you have to search depending on your budget and preferred location.
But make certain you choose A380 and window seat, row 2 or 3

Boten Mar 20, 2019 10:31 pm

Agree that the A380 is better but the A380 is now the later flight of the two. The earlier, I find, is significantly better for getting over jet lag. In fact, I find flights to Singapore/Japan/Hong Kong that depart 6pm to 7pm are the best flights jet lag wise. That is just my experience though.

rocketship87 Mar 20, 2019 11:15 pm

For our staycations we usually stay at the Langham in TST, Ritz Carlton or the W. The Ritz has the best views and the best spa in my opinion, plus the second highest bar in the world.

Bullswood Mar 20, 2019 11:20 pm

The recently opened Murray has joined my top picks.

amt Mar 21, 2019 12:20 am

Take the triple 7... you stand a good chance of only sharing the cabin with 3 or 4 others. The 380 is always full and every time I’ve been on the triple 7 it’s a 3-8 load in First.

Bullswood Mar 21, 2019 12:32 am

Er...perhaps that's because the A380 is better!

firstlight Mar 21, 2019 1:04 am


Originally Posted by sahajesh (Post 30911081)
Thanks all. Will go for that - now need to choose a hotel for the first 5 days too!

the upper house is brilliant but expensive

rossmacd Mar 21, 2019 1:33 am

The A380 without question on this route, compared to the 777.

That being said, if CX F is available - I would take that over either of the BA services.

gypsyjaney Mar 21, 2019 1:45 am

Always stay on the Island at Pacific Place or Central.

flatlander Mar 21, 2019 2:05 am

I've got a soft spot for the Harbour Grand (on HK Island, near Causeway). The Club rooms have good views over the harbour, afternoon snacks and drinks, and it's very convenient for the MTR. It's not one of the prestige luxury brands yet it is very pleasant, the staff are nice, and the prices are not stratospheric.

GIven a choice I would fly there on the A380, in any cabin.

TheJayHatch Mar 21, 2019 2:19 am

I've not flown this route on BA (which might be telling in itself!) but the earlier 777 flight timing will be better for jetlag whilst the later 380 is a more modern F cabin. However these are first world problems and I recently started making decisions based more on how I would feel at the destination and, given you will be up front on both, I would say in most practical terms its pretty marginal. The new F soft product will (unless you are going in the next few weeks) be bedded in and so the experience should (with the exception of the hard product) be near identical.

Knowing how discombobulating travel to the far east can be, and the fact that F, in my experience, is more about the luck of which CC you get than the aircraft you travel in, I would take the earlier 777, sit back with a nice Dartington flute of LGPS or tumbler of JWBlue, and feel sorry for the poor pax behind you who will almost certainly feel the bigger delta between the 777 & 380 in their respective travel classes than you would in F :)

Swanhunter Mar 21, 2019 2:19 am


Originally Posted by Boten (Post 30911689)
Agree that the A380 is better but the A380 is now the later flight of the two. The earlier, I find, is significantly better for getting over jet lag. In fact, I find flights to Singapore/Japan/Hong Kong that depart 6pm to 7pm are the best flights jet lag wise. That is just my experience though.

Agree. Flight time makes a bigger difference. I also find the A380 rather over-rated as an experience - acres of unusable space in the seat. The 777 is a bad plane but I quite like the F cabin.

KARFA Mar 21, 2019 2:22 am

Regardless of cabin anyone who travels enough will know the 777 is a terrible aircraft for making you feel dehydrated and jet lagged, best avoided if possible especially on overnight flights . The A380 has the benefit of a better F seat as well as a better cabin atmosphere.

stuart_f Mar 21, 2019 3:02 am

A380 every time.

We stayed in the Four Seasons (booked through Virtuoso for additional benefits) and thought it was superb.

Also be sure to take full advantage of Downtown Check in to get rid of your luggage on the final day. MTR > Privileges and Complimentary Services
If you don't you'll be stuck at the check-in desk until 2 hours before the flight when you could be in the lounges enjoying a spa treatment, shower and full dinner.

carrotjuice Mar 21, 2019 3:13 am


Originally Posted by Bullswood (Post 30911760)
The recently opened Murray has joined my top picks.

Without. A. Doubt.

1010101 Mar 21, 2019 3:17 am

The A380 is better than the 777, but CX F is significantly better than either of them if you can find an acceptable price.

If price isn't an issue I would choose the old Mandarin Oriental or the Upper House for the hotel. They're the best two in HK all things considered. The Four Seasons is beginning to get a little tired, and the Ritz whilst nice is in the middle of nowhere.

Sozee Mar 21, 2019 3:32 am


Originally Posted by stuart_f (Post 30912138)
Also be sure to take full advantage of Downtown Check in to get rid of your luggage on the final day MTR > Privileges and Complimentary Services
If you don't you'll be stuck at the check-in desk until 2 hours before the flight when you could be in the lounges enjoying a spa treatment, shower and full dinner.

4 hours before departure. BA counters in HKG open around 19:30 for early check-in, and 20:30 for all counters. But I do agree, best to check in at Hong Kong Station or Kowloon Station earlier in the day, so you don't have to drag your bags across town, or spend the afternoon and evening in the Wing and Pier F for massages, bathtubs, nap rooms, sit down dining and the bars.

Might I also suggest the Ritz Carlton, the harbour view from the rooms facing the harbour side are fantastic. (Given good weather of course) It is just next to Kowloon Station, which there also is a shopping mall connecting the hotel to the station.

And of course, A380 for the hard product, but 777 if you want to see if you're lucky with an empty cabin, though sometimes, both flights will be full.

TheJayHatch Mar 21, 2019 3:46 am


Originally Posted by KARFA (Post 30912054)
Regardless of cabin anyone who travels enough will know the 777 is a terrible aircraft for making you feel dehydrated and jet lagged, best avoided if possible especially on overnight flights . The A380 has the benefit of a better F seat as well as a better cabin atmosphere.

This is fairly well documented...although I would probably still seriously consider an early flight on a 777 to minimise those 3am wide-awakies, especially if its a one-off/rare treat where the excitement of F travel and a city break will mitigate much of the pain.

Swanhunter Mar 21, 2019 3:52 am


Originally Posted by TheJayHatch (Post 30912189)
This is fairly well documented...although I would probably still seriously consider an early flight on a 777 to minimise those 3am wide-awakies, especially if its a one-off/rare treat where the excitement of F travel and a city break will mitigate much of the pain.

indeed. I find the A380 gives me a fairly marginal improvement, whereas flight timing can have a much bigger impact on my ability to sleep, energy levels, tiredness. Have been doing this route since 2001 so have learned the hard way. 😂

Globaliser Mar 21, 2019 4:57 am


Originally Posted by Boten (Post 30911689)
... but the A380 is now the later flight of the two.


Originally Posted by TheJayHatch (Post 30912049)
... the later 380 ...

Only for the next few days.

stevie Mar 21, 2019 4:57 am

Choose CX.

Duck1981 Mar 21, 2019 5:42 am

Choose CX or QR via Doha if not too much of a problem.

BA F is of course a great product - compared to other travel classes - but heavily depending on the crew you get so do yourself a favour and have high but reasonable expectations.

Also worth to note that QR Q suites will provide you a superior experience in J (other frequent fliers can challenge me on this one) compared to BA F, so I would consider to save the money on the flight, buy a J Qatar ticket, and splash out the money on a great hotel room in HKG (in example in the Ritz Carlton).

The above would be my choice but of course, you have your own considerations I guess. Anyway have a good flight!

Lefly Mar 21, 2019 8:22 am


Originally Posted by Duck1981 (Post 30912429)
Choose CX or QR via Doha if not too much of a problem.

BA F is of course a great product - compared to other travel classes - but heavily depending on the crew you get so do yourself a favour and have high but reasonable expectations.

Also worth to note that QR Q suites will provide you a superior experience in J (other frequent fliers can challenge me on this one) compared to BA F, so I would consider to save the money on the flight, buy a J Qatar ticket, and splash out the money on a great hotel room in HKG (in example in the Ritz Carlton).

The above would be my choice but of course, you have your own considerations I guess. Anyway have a good flight!

HKG in F is one of the rare case when I am quite happy with BA and I would not choose QR and a Doha stop. A long night flight, a good plane (A380) and in 5 single flights - two as couple and three as family of 4 - I never had crew issues.
I don't know for CX. I would really like to try its F (wishful thinking, as I don't think I'll be able to - too many Avios needed, too high the cash price) however, a said before, I like BA to/from HKG.

TheJayHatch Mar 21, 2019 8:58 am


Originally Posted by Globaliser (Post 30912324)
Only for the next few days.

Is it swapping? Summer timetable I guess? Then it becomes a no-brainer!

Globaliser Mar 21, 2019 9:20 am


Originally Posted by TheJayHatch (Post 30913056)
Is it swapping? Summer timetable I guess?

Less a case of it swapping now than of the (apparently temporary) swap this season coming to an end with the end of the season.

There have been no signs yet of the swap being reintroduced for NW 2019/20.

Whyone Mar 21, 2019 9:28 am

I would choose QR / Q suites over BA F, even on an A380.....

BobServant Mar 21, 2019 9:48 am


Originally Posted by flatlander (Post 30912030)
I've got a soft spot for the Harbour Grand (on HK Island, near Causeway). The Club rooms have good views over the harbour, afternoon snacks and drinks, and it's very convenient for the MTR. It's not one of the prestige luxury brands yet it is very pleasant, the staff are nice, and the prices are not stratospheric.

GIven a choice I would fly there on the A380, in any cabin.

+1 for Harbour Grand. It’s 5 mins walk from Fortress Hill MTR and trams towards Causeway Bay/ Wan Chai and half the price of the more central hotels. The views are great and if you take a Club room, you can enjoy the lounge, happy hour cocktails and breakfast.

Of course, if money is no object then do look at Upper House, Murray and the 4S/MO/Pen but if not would very much recommend HG. We had 4 nights there last week so our recent experience is still very positive.

Our final night at Ritz Carlton was a nice treat and while it’s a great hotel in every way, especially with Club access, the location is rather out on a limb and I suspect the two elevators and a taxi or long walk to MTR would get tiresome fairly quickly if you are going to see the sights rather than relax in a hotel. Clearly it’s a cut above the Harbour Grand but I think we got the balance right at 4:1, with final night before flight AT RC.

1010101 Mar 21, 2019 9:58 am


Originally Posted by BobServant (Post 30913254)


+1 for Harbour Grand. It’s 5 mins walk from Fortress Hill MTR and trams towards Causeway Bay/ Wan Chai and half the price of the more central hotels. The views are great and if you take a Club room, you can enjoy the lounge, happy hour cocktails and breakfast.

Of course, if money is no object then do look at Upper House, Murray and the 4S/MO/Pen but if not would very much recommend HG. We had 4 nights there last week so our recent experience is still very positive.

Our final night at Ritz Carlton was a nice treat and while it’s a great hotel in every way, especially with Club access, the location is rather out on a limb and I suspect the two elevators and a taxi or long walk to MTR would get tiresome fairly quickly if you are going to see the sights rather than relax in a hotel. Clearly it’s a cut above the Harbour Grand but I think we got the balance right at 4:1, with final night before flight AT RC.

There is also a Harbour Grand on Kowloon side which is a bit of a hidden gem now the MTR has opened up next to it. Being that side of the water the views are fantastic and it's a bit more like 'real' Hong Kong.

Ancient Observer Mar 21, 2019 10:02 am

If you are likely to travel around, then I enjoy using the public transport in Hong Kong.
Once you know you will use public transport, then Harbour Grand is a great choice.
However, it is not like Pacific Place - strolling from there is possible. Strolling from Harbour Grand is not so interesting.

SecondGo Mar 21, 2019 3:02 pm

Rosewood has only just opened on Kowloon side to superb reviews, may be some deals?

endoman Mar 21, 2019 3:10 pm

Could someone point me to a site / guide to HK? I know nothing at all about the place, but quite fancy a trip there for a few days having seen bits on the telly. Not fussed on shopping, just walking / sights / the real HK would be good for us.

The _Banking_Scot Mar 21, 2019 4:49 pm


Originally Posted by endoman (Post 30914455)
Could someone point me to a site / guide to HK? I know nothing at all about the place, but quite fancy a trip there for a few days having seen bits on the telly. Not fussed on shopping, just walking / sights / the real HK would be good for us.

Hi

The Hong Kong forum here on FT offers excellent advice;

https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/hong-kong-macau-436/

I do like the Lonely planet guide books and DK Eyewitness guide books.

Also I was there in the 1st week of December 2018 and loved all the christmas decorations

Also the official tourist site

Discover Hong Kong - Official Travel Guide from the Hong Kong Tourism Board

Regards

TBS


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:46 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.