FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   British Airways | Executive Club (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/british-airways-executive-club-446/)
-   -   Passengers sat in crew seats LHR-LAS (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/british-airways-executive-club/1899203-passengers-sat-crew-seats-lhr-las.html)

silonic Mar 17, 2018 5:27 am

Passengers sat in crew seats LHR-LAS
 
Yesterday I was on the BA275 from LHR-LAS. The plane was brought to the gate late and therefore it was catered late, so whilst the boards showed the gate open, the boarding sign didn’t show until 4.25pm. Within 2 mins it had changed to flight closing, so had a mad dash from the lounge to the gate.

i was in the UD and when getting to the top of the stairs, there were a couple of lads standing by the wardrobe to the right and as I got to my seat the purser came up and said to these guys “are you two together? Good, follow me” and took them back down the stairs.

i thought nothing of it but 5 mins later 2 other people came up the stairs (a 20 something male and an older lady) who seemingly weren’t together (and I later found out they were not) and were asked to sit on the ‘crew seat’ (I’ve never seen crew specifically sit there but it’s the double pull down seat) at the top of the stairs. It seemed strange but I thought there must have been some seat swapping going on. Turns out that after we took off, these 2 people were still sat there, now with a blanket each, just buckled in, sat within inches of each other. After about 7 hours of the flight, of which I’d slept the last 4 hours, I went to the bathroom and the male passenger had his head slumped forward asleep, in what looked like a very uncomfortable position.

After we we got served our 2nd meal, they were given something which I think came from economy. As we disembarked, the male flew down to the stairs whilst the rest of us, including the lady, were asked to hold back.

Whilst I appreciate this isn’t usual, is this something that happens every now and then. I initially thought they may be relatives of the crew but neither said goodbye to anyone in a way that would make them familiar with anyone and it just felt awkward that these poor passengers were sat there without even an iPad to watch. If they found out before departure some seats weren’t working, would passengers be offered this as an alternative to being offloaded? When I was in the lounge I had asked about paid upgrades to F but was told every seat on the plane was taken.

Hopefully some wise heads on the board can explain what circumstances need to occur for that to happen.

and don’t get me started on the bread roll being served 15 mins before the starter trolley came by...

Can I help you Mar 17, 2018 5:32 am

There would have been staff or relative/friends off staff travelling on staff travel, oh the joys!

flatlander Mar 17, 2018 5:34 am

They might be staff or relatives of staff using staff travel; sometimes the comfort level is commensurate with what you pay for it (low). One should think of travelling like this before one becomes too envious of airline staff being able to fly the world for cheap.

lavajava Mar 17, 2018 5:38 am

My first impression was that they were on staff travel (not necessarily actual BA staff). The circumstances seem a bit odd though.

Reminds me of when my little brother flew back from SYD and was assigned a boarding pass with seat Jxx indicating a jump seat assignment, he was lucky enough to be given the crew rest after the flight deck had finished with it. Now there's some jealously to having a boarding pass with J before any seat number but not sure it' worth it for the pain and suffering!

Can I help you Mar 17, 2018 5:38 am


Originally Posted by silonic (Post 29535191)
and don’t get me started on the bread roll being served 15 mins before the starter trolley came by...

That’s the new BA standard don’t you know, it seems this is what happens in the best restaurants and is something BA are trying to emulate!

UKtravelbear Mar 17, 2018 5:52 am


Originally Posted by silonic (Post 29535191)

and don’t get me started on the bread roll being served 15 mins before the starter trolley came by...

Think of it as the amuse-bouche being brought back.

Tobias-UK Mar 17, 2018 5:55 am


Originally Posted by UKtravelbear (Post 29535233)
Think of it as the amuse-bouche being brought back.

I don't recall there being amuse-bouches served in Club :confused:

UKtravelbear Mar 17, 2018 6:00 am


Originally Posted by Tobias-UK (Post 29535238)
I don't recall there being amuse-bouches served in Club :confused:

A real enhancement then!

LondonElite Mar 17, 2018 6:43 am


Originally Posted by silonic (Post 29535191)
Hopefully some wise heads on the board can explain what circumstances need to occur for that to happen.

No biggie.

Probably BA staff/family of some kind on standby. Friends of ours do this regularly.

FlyerTalker688786 Mar 17, 2018 7:12 am

i thougt in some airlines you must be current employee to take Jump seat, looks like BA extends Jump seat priority to family members too?

MFCC Mar 17, 2018 7:17 am


Originally Posted by chongcao (Post 29535392)
i thougt in some airlines you must be current employee to take Jump seat, looks like BA extends Jump seat priority to family members too?

I believe any BA employees and their nominees can have a cabin jump seat. Only crew with a valid ID can occupy a flight deck j/s. People using concessions from other airlines cannot have any j/s. Happy to be corrected on this.

Sixth Freedom Mar 17, 2018 7:26 am


Originally Posted by flatlander (Post 29535202)
One should think of travelling like this before one becomes too envious of airline staff being able to fly the world for cheap.

Indeed. This is why I generally refuse to do staff travel and when I consult for an airline I take the hit and buy my own tickets. J priority means nothing if all J seats are taken. :)

LTN Phobia Mar 17, 2018 7:57 am


Originally Posted by Can I help you (Post 29535199)
There would have been staff or relative/friends off staff travelling on staff travel, oh the joys!

That'd of course be the most likely explanation.

As a lesser possibility, a victim of crushing, as I was on VS.

Many moons ago I ended up flying in one of the jump seats because I was left with about 1/3 of a seat and there was nowhere else but the jump seat to sit.

MSPeconomist Mar 17, 2018 8:08 am

I don't know BA/UK/EU rules on this, but on USA legacy carrier flights, nonrevs who are jumpseat qualified (typically cabin crew employed by the airline operating the flight) can take such seats when there aren't regular passenger seats available. In some cases, a nonrev higher on the list who would be entitled to a regular seat on the flight will volunteer to take such a seat in order to enable an additional nonrev to make the flight. I've also seen two jumpseat qualified nonrevs share a jumpseat and a regular seat, switching off once or twice to make a long flight less uncomfortable. Nonrevs should get last choice of meals on board, so they would be given whatever business/coach/crew food is left; there wouldn't be additional catering provided for the jumpseats.

FlyerTalker688786 Mar 17, 2018 8:24 am

@MSPeconomistYes that is my understanding that in certain US airlines, you must be a current employee to take jump seats. So retirees and nominees can not standby for those seats. That is particular good for employees who are risking missing the shift and have to go back on time.

TheFlyingCyclist Mar 17, 2018 8:26 am

My mum used to work for Pan Am and United as a PA. When we did the staff travel thing, one of us would end up in a jump seat pretty regularly as a standby ticket. None of us were what you would call “trained” for that seat! That was the 90s though...

bmibaby737 Mar 17, 2018 11:38 am


Originally Posted by flatlander (Post 29535202)
They might be staff or relatives of staff using staff travel; sometimes the comfort level is commensurate with what you pay for it (low). One should think of travelling like this before one becomes too envious of airline staff being able to fly the world for cheap.

Staff standby can be extremely useful on routes like JFK, IAD etc.

Can I help you Mar 17, 2018 12:58 pm

Anyone that the Captain feels is competent can sit in a cabin jumpseats, staff, family or commercial customers.
Only qualified flight crew, cabin crew and licensed engineers can sit in the flight deck.

Flexible preferences Mar 17, 2018 1:28 pm

One issue we had in F on a 747 back from MIA may have been to do with a staff member in the jump seat just behind F. He was frozen by the doors, with blankets over him, and I think the crew may have cranked up the heat because in the F cabin it was absolutely roasting hot. Tricky one, because he looked like he was shivering, so I can't think of any other way around it, but it made for a very uncomfortable flight.

Waterhorse Mar 17, 2018 3:38 pm


Originally Posted by Can I help you (Post 29536447)
Anyone that the Captain feels is competent can sit in a cabin jumpseats, staff, family or commercial customers.
Only qualified flight crew, cabin crew and licensed engineers can sit in the flight deck.

Actually quite a few more others can sit on a flight deck Jumpseat under certain circumstances. Anyone who occupies a flight deck jumpseat, or in fact any jumpseat can only do so with the authority of the aircraft commander. Engineers are not routinely considered for FD Jumpseats only flight and cabin crew.

Can I help you Mar 17, 2018 3:46 pm

But they are eligible?

MSPeconomist Mar 17, 2018 4:01 pm

I once saw a very high level FAA official take a cockpit jumpseat on at TATL segment operated by a USA carrier. He was assigned the IFC seat next to me
and we chatted a bit during meals, but he spent most of the time up with the pilots.

AFAIK on USA carriers, the rule is that cabin jumpseat riders must be qualified to help with emergency evacuations, hence the "currently employed as a crew member on the carrier operating the flight" general rule.

Waterhorse Mar 17, 2018 4:11 pm


Originally Posted by Can I help you (Post 29536970)
But they are eligible?

not routinely.

Can I help you Mar 17, 2018 4:14 pm

Just not for staff travel purposes?

Waterhorse Mar 17, 2018 4:16 pm


Originally Posted by Can I help you (Post 29537060)
Just not for staff travel purposes?

OM A 8.7.1 para v

SpeedbirdLHR Mar 17, 2018 4:27 pm


Originally Posted by Waterhorse (Post 29536945)


Actually quite a few more others can sit on a flight deck Jumpseat under certain circumstances. Anyone who occupies a flight deck jumpseat, or in fact any jumpseat can only do so with the authority of the aircraft commander. Engineers are not routinely considered for FD Jumpseats only flight and cabin crew.

The Customer Service Policy Manual lists everyone who is entitled to a flight deck jumpseats and you are correct in that engineers are not in that list. However there is provision for authorisation to be given by the CAA or the Director o Flight Operations to allow anyone not listed in the CSPM.

ThisIsntOM Mar 17, 2018 8:50 pm

Staff/relatives of Staff on Staff Travel.

Think the skipper has the final say on who sits in the jumpseats or even if anyone will be able to.... it’s a choice (not our first, obviously) but no one really unknowingly ends up in the jump seat, you say if you are willing to take one or not.

I can firmly say after taking a jump seat from SYD to SIN with the promise of my nice seat from SIN to LHR but ending up on the jumpseat the whole way, I’d only to too glad to be stuck somewhere days on end than take the jumpseat again.

They really are only designed for short periods of time... although the “experience” made me eternally grateful for 53E on a 747 :)

Waterhorse Mar 17, 2018 10:47 pm


Originally Posted by SpeedbirdLHR (Post 29537105)
The Customer Service Policy Manual lists everyone who is entitled to a flight deck jumpseats and you are correct in that engineers are not in that list. However there is provision for authorisation to be given by the CAA or the Director o Flight Operations to allow anyone not listed in the CSPM.

No one is “entitled” to a FD Jumpseat or indeed any jumpseat unless they are part of the operating flight crew. Others may be eligible but are only allowed there with the Captains permission.

Robespierre Nov 12, 2018 10:19 am

I vacated my seat in a full 747 back from Vancouver to take a Crew jumpseat as my neighbour in 1K was the victim of a seat that was stuck in a reclined position at 20 mins to landing. She was highly embarrassed and was a person of size (if that is the right way to express it) so rather than boot her out or play cabin Tetris I thought it would be easier to offer her my seat and for me to take a jumpseat. CSD agreed in a flash so I swapped 1A for 2L with a few odd looks from the WT+ passengers as I was escorted out.

Fun for 20 minutes but the thought of spending the whole flight there is no fun at all.

nshep Nov 12, 2018 11:06 am

When I flew back from Miami I think year before last it was right before the hurricane hit and I was on the upper deck and the jump seats at the top of the stairs and the ones in the middle of the upper deck where taken by passengers who turned out to be BA staff who had been told to take the flight home as they expected cancellations in comming days due to the hurricane. (I.E they where using them for crew movements)

MFCC Nov 12, 2018 11:23 am


Originally Posted by nshep (Post 30421813)
When I flew back from Miami I think year before last it was right before the hurricane hit and I was on the upper deck and the jump seats at the top of the stairs and the ones in the middle of the upper deck where taken by passengers who turned out to be BA staff who had been told to take the flight home as they expected cancellations in comming days due to the hurricane. (I.E they where using them for crew movements)

Chances are they would’ve been out on holiday, using their staff travel concessions and decided to cut their holiday short due to the hurricane. Flights will have been very busy, so jumpseats would be used to get as many people home as possible.

Waterhorse Nov 12, 2018 1:16 pm


Originally Posted by nshep (Post 30421813)
When I flew back from Miami I think year before last it was right before the hurricane hit and I was on the upper deck and the jump seats at the top of the stairs and the ones in the middle of the upper deck where taken by passengers who turned out to be BA staff who had been told to take the flight home as they expected cancellations in comming days due to the hurricane. (I.E they where using them for crew movements)

As MFCC says.BA do not use jump seats for Crew Movements, positioning crew will always have a seat, even if it means offloading or downgrading passengers to ensure it happens

Takiteasy Nov 12, 2018 1:30 pm


Originally Posted by Waterhorse (Post 30422313)


As MFCC says.BA do not use jump seats for Crew Movements, positioning crew will always have a seat, even if it means offloading or downgrading passengers to ensure it happens

I’d love to know why positioning crew within Europe (travelling in uniform) are given Club Europe seats at the expense of paying pax.

Can I help you Nov 12, 2018 1:34 pm

Cabin crew have a ET/WT priority and only get CE or CW if it’s available?

dougzz Nov 12, 2018 2:01 pm


Originally Posted by Takiteasy (Post 30422359)

I’d love to know why positioning crew within Europe (travelling in uniform) are given Club Europe seats at the expense of paying pax.

Even if this were true why would it be wrong? Company has business class travel policy. How many of those in CE are in company paid for seats?

Waterhorse Nov 12, 2018 2:06 pm


Originally Posted by Takiteasy (Post 30422359)

I’d love to know why positioning crew within Europe (travelling in uniform) are given Club Europe seats at the expense of paying pax.

If they are positioning they are at work being moved by the company to ensure that the next flight goes. If they are on personal travel it’s a different business. I will not engage with justifying why crew sit where etc.

jeremyBA Nov 12, 2018 3:08 pm

Ex girlfriend of mine used to work for ba. Finance manager.

She he used to travel all over Europe for business and the majority of the time ended up in the jump seat ( including cockpit but it was 20 years ago). Only choise or don’t get home. Used to annoy her as it was duty travel!

For her holidays she always ended up in odd places ( Venezuela was popular at the time ) as it was the only way they could half guarantee to get back in time for work ( which was their problem even if bumped from the flight !). I think she got a limited number of guaranteed seats but I can’t really remember as it was a long time ago.


Takiteasy Nov 15, 2018 2:17 pm


Originally Posted by Waterhorse (Post 30422481)


If they are positioning they are at work being moved by the company to ensure that the next flight goes. If they are on personal travel it’s a different business. I will not engage with justifying why crew sit where etc.

I should have bolded the ‘at the expense of paying pax’ and give you some context.

Couple of weeks ago at ARN the flight before mine went tech and presumably a lot of the pax were reaccommodated on the later flight. I heard a couple of guys grumbling to each other in the boarding area about being downgraded but I think at the end of the day they were happy to go home just a couple of hours late.

It all kicked off however upon boarding when they saw the cabin crew of their tech service seated in CE, meaning the crew had been reseated ahead of them. They made a huge fuss, and when the crew was not sympathetic decided they would walk off in protest. Given one of them had checked luggage this resulted in 2 crews being promptly moved from CE to ET in order to be able to depart on time.

I am not one for DYKWIA attitude but for once was behind the pax here, as customers should always come first. I also wonder what would have happened had they not have the leverage of the hold luggage.

Waterhorse Nov 15, 2018 4:29 pm

Which customers should come first? The 2 delayed ones or the many delayed in the morning when the service doesn’t operate?

MFCC Nov 15, 2018 4:33 pm


Originally Posted by Takiteasy (Post 30433717)

I should have bolded the ‘at the expense of paying pax’ and give you some context.

Couple of weeks ago at ARN the flight before mine went tech and presumably a lot of the pax were reaccommodated on the later flight. I heard a couple of guys grumbling to each other in the boarding area about being downgraded but I think at the end of the day they were happy to go home just a couple of hours late.

It all kicked off however upon boarding when they saw the cabin crew of their tech service seated in CE, meaning the crew had been reseated ahead of them. They made a huge fuss, and when the crew was not sympathetic decided they would walk off in protest. Given one of them had checked luggage this resulted in 2 crews being promptly moved from CE to ET in order to be able to depart on time.

I am not one for DYKWIA attitude but for once was behind the pax here, as customers should always come first. I also wonder what would have happened had they not have the leverage of the hold luggage.

As mentioned upthread by CIHY; cabin crew positioning will only receive a Club seat only if a Club seat is available (at least this is the case on MF, presuming the same for WW/EF). Crew will not be allocated CE/CW if there are no available seats.
I expect there was some confusion on the part of the outstation staff re staff travel priorities and reacommodating commercial pax on the later flight.
I don’t know whether or not the same applies for flight crew.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 7:20 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.