FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Asia (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/asia-460/)
-   -   Taiwan E-Gate / Global Entry (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/asia/1875279-taiwan-e-gate-global-entry.html)

hsumh316 Dec 1, 2017 8:38 am


Originally Posted by calvin16662002 (Post 29120746)
Well, at least from the arrival perspective there is no screening; you aren't saving much time when you already have APEC card....

The e-gate staff told me if you have APEC already, you don't need e-gate. I had already paid for the application so they went ahead and processed my application. You aren't saving much time on arrival but you do get to avoid having to deal with an immigration officer altogether.

gengar Dec 2, 2017 12:08 am


Originally Posted by hsumh316 (Post 29109272)
I completed the electronic arrival card and my interview was on my departure. I was approved for e-gate and when I tried to use the e-gate, it required me to fill out an arrival card. According to staff, they said when I filled out the electronic arrival card it was not tied to my e-gate info, so I had to submit it again.

I also interviewed on departure and had the same experience. The explanation (although not that clear because none of the NIA staffers spoke good English) is that approving my passport for e-gate 'cleared' the information in the NIA system from my original arrival card, so the system did not recognize that I was legally in the country. I inferred from their statements that they consider this a bug and will look to fix it, but again hard to tell because of poor communication.

For those who are planning on interviewing on departure, I wonder if submitting the online arrival card before the interview would help (the NIA staff told me to input my outbound flight information) so as to avoid the hassle of filling it out during the process (I literally submitted the online arrival card on my phone while standing with NIA staff in front of the e-gates). Of course, there's still the chance that the the information gets 'disassociated' during the e-gate approval process.

Just as a general warning, the interview/approval process is clearly not ready for prime time. I don't know if I interviewed before hsumh316, but the process took nearly one hour from the time I arrived at the NIA counter in T2 (including waiting ~10 mins in line and then another ~15mins just for the NIA staff member conducting the interview to show up), so make sure to budget plenty of time if you're planning on doing the interview on departure.

Bear4Asian Dec 8, 2017 4:49 pm

I had my interview on arrival yesterday (Dec 9). I gave them my passport and Nexus card and they took me to a small interview room where they talked me through 5 or so questions. E.g. Have you denied entry to any country..., etc. it took just a few minutes. Then they printed off the form (I believe with the questions on it) and asked me to sign it. They had me fill in the electronic arrival form in the office and did a facial scan with a camera and we were done.

The problem came after. They took me to the eGate machine where they showed me how to place the passport in the machine. They emphasized that one must only put in one passport page otherwise it wouldn’t scan. It failed to scan. They tried multiple machines. One page only and open with multiple pages. Failed every time. After @ half hour I had the original intervewer and 4-5 others including system programmers helping and never made it work. They were very nice, but couldn’t figure out a solution.

They told old me there were other America passports that didn’t work. So... a mixed bag. Hopefully they’ll figure out a solution soon.

By they way way I asked how many GE folks had applied and they said around 10.

Majuki Dec 8, 2017 5:19 pm


Originally Posted by Bear4Asian (Post 29151600)
I had my interview on arrival yesterday (Dec 9). I gave them my passport and Nexus card and they took me to a small interview room where they talked me through 5 or so questions. E.g. Have you denied entry to any country..., etc. it took just a few minutes. Then they printed off the form (I believe with the questions on it) and asked me to sign it. They had me fill in the electronic arrival form in the office and did a facial scan with a camera and we were done.

The problem came after. They took me to the eGate machine where they showed me how to place the passport in the machine. They emphasized that one must only put in one passport page otherwise it wouldn’t scan. It failed to scan. They tried multiple machines. One page only and open with multiple pages. Failed every time. After @ half hour I had the original intervewer and 4-5 others including system programmers helping and never made it work. They were very nice, but couldn’t figure out a solution.

They told old me there were other America passports that didn’t work. So... a mixed bag. Hopefully they’ll figure out a solution soon.

By they way way I asked how many GE folks had applied and they said around 10.

1) So the people on arrival knew what to do it seems. This was Terminal 1 or 2? I'm planning to arrive on an early flight.

2) I'm wondering if it has to do with the initial use of the electronic arrival card, but it should have worked since you completed it after you were enrolled in the eGate.

3) I feel like all 10 are on this FlyerTalk thread. :D

Bear4Asian Dec 9, 2017 5:32 pm

It was Terminal 2 | See image below with map they sent me
 

username Dec 10, 2017 12:11 am


Originally Posted by Bear4Asian (Post 29151600)
...The problem came after.....

I thought maybe the machine said "ERROR, all westerns look the same" :D You definitely cannot smile to those machines. They facial recognition does not work when you smile.

So, interesting that they took NEXUS but I guess you have a US passport. It would be interesting to see if non-US NEXUS holders get this benefit.

Bear4Asian Dec 10, 2017 6:16 pm


Originally Posted by username (Post 29155457)
I thought maybe the machine said "ERROR, all westerns look the same" :D You definitely cannot smile to those machines. They facial recognition does not work when you smile.

So, interesting that they took NEXUS but I guess you have a US passport. It would be interesting to see if non-US NEXUS holders get this benefit.

Since my passport wouldn’t scan the gate never opened so I didn’t reach the area where you smile. When I applied online I told them I had both my passport and a Nexus card. They asked to see both during the interview. But only the passport could be scanned at the eGate.

Bear4Asian Dec 11, 2017 5:46 pm

Taipei Times report on e-Gate system | bioscanners from China
 
The 12/13/2017 Taipei Times reports this morning that the biometric scanners were procured, against Taiwanese regulations from China. Officials claim there is no evidence that personal travelers information was leaked.
Who knows, but there were underlying claims of corruption with regard to the software vendor as well. And I found this quote from the owner of the vendor company interesting,...”claimed his software costs less and has fewer hardware requirements than Microsoft, IBM and Oracle’s competing proprietary systems, because it makes use of open protocols...”Link to the complete story:Officials deny security, personal leaks over e-Gate - Taipei Times

kevino Dec 20, 2017 11:42 am

For those who have gone through interviews, did you apply online first? If so, how long after applying online did you get a pending approval, which then allows scheduling an interview? I applied online 8 days ago, but my online account still shows "Pending Review." :( Thanks.

mlin32 Dec 20, 2017 1:27 pm


Originally Posted by kevino (Post 29197901)
For those who have gone through interviews, did you apply online first? If so, how long after applying online did you get a pending approval, which then allows scheduling an interview? I applied online 8 days ago, but my online account still shows "Pending Review." :( Thanks.

When I applied online, I was approved to schedule an interview within 3h.

hsumh316 Dec 20, 2017 4:08 pm


Originally Posted by kevino (Post 29197901)
For those who have gone through interviews, did you apply online first? If so, how long after applying online did you get a pending approval, which then allows scheduling an interview? I applied online 8 days ago, but my online account still shows "Pending Review." :( Thanks.

Yes, I applied online first. I got my email to schedule within an hour of payment.

Majuki Dec 20, 2017 5:50 pm


Originally Posted by mlin32 (Post 29198335)
When I applied online, I was approved to schedule an interview within 3h.

My experience was the same, if not faster.

kevino Dec 21, 2017 1:49 am

Thank you kindly for the replies. I guess I'm "special." :(

Majuki Dec 25, 2017 8:37 pm

I had my interview at Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport Terminal 2 at 05:00 this morning. The staff had just arrived, and the person who helped me didn't have any difficulty with the enrollment process. I asked her how many had applied, and she said 38 so far. She also told me about the Speedy Immigration Inspection Certificate, which I hadn't known about previously. Unlike the one for Hong Kong, this one is only valid for one year and does not allow for e-Gate use, so I still think the e-Gate for US Global Entry member option is a better one.

The person helping me did give a best practice of aligning the edge of the US passport with the first red light on the reader. She said there had been some failures if US passport holders placed the passport flush against the edge of the glass reader. Following her advice, I was able to get the reader to read the passport on the first try and use e-Gate to enter Taiwan. (I had filled out an electronic arrival form before departing the US.)

I had mentioned that they had taken photos when BlackHappy was the first to complete the enrollment process, and the person conducting my interview seemed familiar with that.

Thanks all for the tips on the process, and I look forward to using e-Gate now during my travels. ^

kevino Dec 26, 2017 12:21 am

I finally got an e-mail with conditional approval inviting me to set an interview date. :) It was exactly 14 days after I applied online.

I set my interview for the end of January when I'll next arrive in TPE.

Since I have APEC, the sole reason I'm doing this is to reduce the number of passport stamps I get so as to prolong the life of my passport. :)

Majuki Dec 27, 2017 12:38 am

I had a slight hiccup while leaving on a flight to Japan today. The ticketing agent at the JAL counters was thumbing through my passport, looking for a recent entry stamp. Since I used e-Gate to enter, my most recent entry was October 2014. I said I had used e-Gate, and she was looking for the e-Gate stamp (I didn't receive one) like the one in Mrs. Majuki's Taiwan passport, and then she asked if I had an ARC or APRC (I don't). I took out my GE card, which I don't normally carry, and said, "I have e-Gate through a new program." I think she remained unconvinced, but I got my boarding pass and proceeded through e-Gate to exit without issues.

longtimeflyin Dec 27, 2017 5:50 am

Can anybody answer these questions?

I am Canadian, and have a Canadian passport and I have NEXUS/GE from Canada. Can I use this service?

My wife is Taiwanese, with a Taiwanese passport - I assume that's not a problem. (has Nexus/GE from Canada)

My son(s) hold a Taiwanese and Canadian passport. They have to use their Taiwanese passport when entering/leaving Taiwan because they are otherwise subject to mandatory military service. Everytime we go to Taiwan, they have to apply for an exit permit as they are not residents of Taiwan. Given this situation, can they register for this too? (have NEXUS/GE from Canada)

[We all reside in Canada]

Majuki Dec 27, 2017 3:08 pm


Originally Posted by longtimeflyin (Post 29218698)
Can anybody answer these questions?

I am Canadian, and have a Canadian passport and I have NEXUS/GE from Canada. Can I use this service?

My wife is Taiwanese, with a Taiwanese passport - I assume that's not a problem. (has Nexus/GE from Canada)

My son(s) hold a Taiwanese and Canadian passport. They have to use their Taiwanese passport when entering/leaving Taiwan because they are otherwise subject to mandatory military service. Everytime we go to Taiwan, they have to apply for an exit permit as they are not residents of Taiwan. Given this situation, can they register for this too? (have NEXUS/GE from Canada)

[We all reside in Canada]

The NIA website doesn't mention anything about US citizens only, but the CBP website indicates that it's only reciprocity between the US in Taiwan, even if other passport holders can participate in NEXUS or GE.

Your wife shouldn't have any issues enrolling with her Taiwan passport as long as she maintains her household registration. I don't know about your sons since they need to obtain to exit permits, but you can always ask the next time you visit. There is an e-Gate enrollment desk before passport control in T2 and also one landside at the 3F departures level. Someone else can chime in on the T1 configuration as well.

myperks Jan 1, 2018 9:53 am


Originally Posted by longtimeflyin (Post 29218698)
Can anybody answer these questions?

I am Canadian, and have a Canadian passport and I have NEXUS/GE from Canada. Can I use this service?

My wife is Taiwanese, with a Taiwanese passport - I assume that's not a problem. (has Nexus/GE from Canada)

My son(s) hold a Taiwanese and Canadian passport. They have to use their Taiwanese passport when entering/leaving Taiwan because they are otherwise subject to mandatory military service. Everytime we go to Taiwan, they have to apply for an exit permit as they are not residents of Taiwan. Given this situation, can they register for this too? (have NEXUS/GE from Canada)

[We all reside in Canada]

Taiwanese passports can use eGate for free and can sign up for it upon arrival. Takes like 5 minutes.
As for the compulsatory military service, it doesn't matter which passport you enter with, they are all connected and if you have the overseas Taiwanese permit and not stay overstay certain of days per year, you can enter with a non Taiwanese passport (even if you have one). So if your sons can exit Taiwan, that means they have the oversea Taiwanese (exit) permit AFAIK.

longtimeflyin Jan 1, 2018 10:52 am


Originally Posted by myperks (Post 29236254)


Taiwanese passports can use eGate for free and can sign up for it upon arrival. Takes like 5 minutes.
As for the compulsatory military service, it doesn't matter which passport you enter with, they are all connected and if you have the overseas Taiwanese permit and not stay overstay certain of days per year, you can enter with a non Taiwanese passport (even if you have one). So if your sons can exit Taiwan, that means they have the oversea Taiwanese (exit) permit AFAIK.

Not quite actually. My sons have to apply for an exit permit every time before we go to Taiwan despite having an oversees stamp. They are also required by law to use their Taiwanese passport.

Any idea on where we would go to inquire about using the egates at TPE?

myperks Jan 1, 2018 11:28 am


Originally Posted by longtimeflyin (Post 29236419)
Not quite actually. My sons have to apply for an exit permit every time before we go to Taiwan despite having an oversees stamp. They are also required by law to use their Taiwanese passport.

Without giving immigration advice, I would suggest you follow up on the exit permit not being required each time. The only time I would think you would want to use your TWN passport is to maintain household registry and national insurance.

jackson112233 Jan 1, 2018 12:58 pm


Originally Posted by longtimeflyin (Post 29236419)
Not quite actually. My sons have to apply for an exit permit every time before we go to Taiwan despite having an oversees stamp. They are also required by law to use their Taiwanese passport.

Any idea on where we would go to inquire about using the egates at TPE?

You can do it at the airport, at the counter where they exit stamp for military service exemption for overseas citizens. The only thing is I don’t think exiting taiwan e-gate works because customs has to check for that stamp. There is also a multiple entry/exit document that you can apply for so that you don’t have to get a stamp every time.

longtimeflyin Jan 1, 2018 1:27 pm


Originally Posted by jackson112233 (Post 29236777)
You can do it at the airport, at the counter where they exit stamp for military service exemption for overseas citizens. The only thing is I don’t think exiting taiwan e-gate works because customs has to check for that stamp. There is also a multiple entry/exit document that you can apply for so that you don’t have to get a stamp every time.

My apologies for the mixup of terminology here. Yes, my sons have that document for multiple entry/exit, but it's only valid for a period of 3-6 months if I recall correctly. They have been told they explicitly need to use their Taiwanese passports.Customs does manually look at that document everything so I think you're right in that the egate program would not work for them.

Sorry to derail the thread, thank you both for your help

Majuki Jan 1, 2018 6:28 pm

I just used e-Gate a second time. I had a conversation with the attendant because he was asking for my ARC - I don't have one. I told him, "I am registered with e-Gate for Global Entry," and he seemed to understand. I feel as though I might have to carry my GE card for trips to Taiwan, but perhaps there will be fewer situations of, "You're in the wrong line," as more people enroll.

PaclantFlyer Jan 6, 2018 8:10 am

Anyone finding the e-Gate machines very finicky for US Passports?
So far I'm 0 for 2 for successful scans and the immigration staff are 1 for 2.

The staff do note that the US Passports are aligned differently from the Taiwanese ones, but I've yet to get a successful scan, getting errors like "UV check failed" or something to that extent.

Majuki Jan 6, 2018 1:53 pm


Originally Posted by PaclantFlyer (Post 29257548)
Anyone finding the e-Gate machines very finicky for US Passports?
So far I'm 0 for 2 for successful scans and the immigration staff are 1 for 2.

The staff do note that the US Passports are aligned differently from the Taiwanese ones, but I've yet to get a successful scan, getting errors like "UV check failed" or something to that extent.

There is a red light that's offset from the edge of the reader on the left side. Align the edge of your passport with that light. Do not place it flush against the edge of the reader. This was a best practice that the person helping me enroll told me. I'm 4/4 following this advice.

mlin32 Jan 9, 2018 6:43 am

I successfully signed up for the eGate yesterday arriving into T1 with CX. Due to the weather disruptions on my flight schedule, I ended up trying to enroll on a day before my scheduled appt. No problems, they found me in the system and had me signed up. Didn't even ask to see my NEXUS card.

US passport worked the first time I inserted into the eGate reader.. Didn't find it hard to read at all.

PaclantFlyer Jan 9, 2018 7:02 am


Originally Posted by Majuki (Post 29258649)
There is a red light that's offset from the edge of the reader on the left side. Align the edge of your passport with that light. Do not place it flush against the edge of the reader. This was a best practice that the person helping me enroll told me. I'm 4/4 following this advice.

That definitely did the trick! I'm surprised the interviewer didn't have more specific guidance about aligning the passport other than it needs to be more in the middle (I even did the interview in Chinese!).

I compared my US passport with a Taiwanese Passport and found that the machine-readable section is definitely centered differently.
Maybe the newer US passports have a properly centered machine-readable section?

Majuki Jan 9, 2018 9:26 am


Originally Posted by mlin32 (Post 29269392)
I successfully signed up for the eGate yesterday arriving into T1 with CX. Due to the weather disruptions on my flight schedule, I ended up trying to enroll on a day before my scheduled appt. No problems, they found me in the system and had me signed up. Didn't even ask to see my NEXUS card.

US passport worked the first time I inserted into the eGate reader.. Didn't find it hard to read at all.

It's good to know there is some flexibility in the appointment scheduling. I arrived the first thing in the morning, which was during my scheduled appointment window, and there was nobody there. I believe ARC/APRC holders or ROC passport holders can enroll on the spot without an appointment, so I never really understood the need for an appointment for people for this program other than the enrollment takes a little longer.


Originally Posted by PaclantFlyer (Post 29269466)
That definitely did the trick! I'm surprised the interviewer didn't have more specific guidance about aligning the passport other than it needs to be more in the middle (I even did the interview in Chinese!).

I compared my US passport with a Taiwanese Passport and found that the machine-readable section is definitely centered differently.
Maybe the newer US passports have a properly centered machine-readable section?

I'm glad to know that worked! I'm a bit surprised that the readers have an issue with alignment since one would assume they'd be able to find the machine readable part as long as it's somewhere on the reader.

pchen0 Jan 9, 2018 12:21 pm

E-Gate Expiration?
 
Hi all,

I am having trouble finding exactly when the e-Gate membership expires. From a previous thread, I believe it expires with your current U.S. Passport expiration date.
Can someone confirm?
Thank you!

gengar Jan 9, 2018 4:24 pm


Originally Posted by pchen0 (Post 29271007)
Hi all,

I am having trouble finding exactly when the e-Gate membership expires. From a previous thread, I believe it expires with your current U.S. Passport expiration date.
Can someone confirm?
Thank you!

Taiwan foreign policy operates on a principle of strict reciprocity, so the e-Gate membership for GE holders lasts as long as GE membership for Taiwan citizens (i.e., 5 years); this is also why both cost basically the same, both require an in-person interview with stupid questions, etc. etc. For whatever reason, the validity period doesn't currently appear to be listed on the NIA website, but I can confirm that my membership expiration date is 5 years from the date of my e-Gate interview.

Majuki Jan 9, 2018 6:56 pm


Originally Posted by gengar (Post 29272040)
Taiwan foreign policy operates on a principle of strict reciprocity, so the e-Gate membership for GE holders lasts as long as GE membership for Taiwan citizens (i.e., 5 years); this is also why both cost basically the same, both require an in-person interview with stupid questions, etc. etc. For whatever reason, the validity period doesn't currently appear to be listed on the NIA website, but I can confirm that my membership expiration date is 5 years from the date of my e-Gate interview.

Correct. I believe even as an ARC holder there is no need for an interview for e-Gate enrollment, right?

Now, who's going to be the first to renew their passport?

Bear4Asian Jan 11, 2018 7:01 am


Originally Posted by PaclantFlyer (Post 29269466)
That definitely did the trick! I'm surprised the interviewer didn't have more specific guidance about aligning the passport other than it needs to be more in the middle (I even did the interview in Chinese!).

I compared my US passport with a Taiwanese Passport and found that the machine-readable section is definitely centered differently.
Maybe the newer US passports have a properly centered machine-readable section?


Originally Posted by Majuki (Post 29270204)
It's good to know there is some flexibility in the appointment scheduling. I arrived the first thing in the morning, which was during my scheduled appointment window, and there was nobody there. I believe ARC/APRC holders or ROC passport holders can enroll on the spot without an appointment, so I never really understood the need for an appointment for people for this program other than the enrollment takes a little longer.



I'm glad to know that worked! I'm a bit surprised that the readers have an issue with alignment since one would assume they'd be able to find the machine readable part as long as it's somewhere on the reader.

I’ve tried to use my passport in eGate when I entered Taiwan late last year and when I left Taiwan today. As you can see upthread I had @ 5 experts try to use my passport in eGate multiple times and it never worked. They each tried multiple times and it never worked. When I left today, I tried the trick about lining up the passport with the upper left red light. Didn’t work. Then two eGate personnel tried multiple times. Never worked. So my passport is zero for around 25 or so. They were aware of the issue, apologized profusely and suggested the problem might be created by the crease or wrinkles in the bottom of the passport. But it didn’t seem there was any real confidence that they knew how to correct the issue.

My passport is nine years old. Does anyone of you have a passport that old that has worked? Sigh.
​​​​​​​

calvin16662002 Jan 11, 2018 7:46 am


Originally Posted by Bear4Asian (Post 29278768)




I’ve tried to use my passport in eGate when I entered Taiwan late last year and when I left Taiwan today. As you can see upthread I had @ 5 experts try to use my passport in eGate multiple times and it never worked. They each tried multiple times and it never worked. When I left today, I tried the trick about lining up the passport with the upper left red light. Didn’t work. Then two eGate personnel tried multiple times. Never worked. So my passport is zero for around 25 or so. They were aware of the issue, apologized profusely and suggested the problem might be created by the crease or wrinkles in the bottom of the passport. But it didn’t seem there was any real confidence that they knew how to correct the issue.

My passport is nine years old. Does anyone of you have a passport that old that has worked? Sigh.

No issue with my <1-year-old passport in or out...

mlin32 Jan 11, 2018 8:05 am

My passport is one of those biometric passports issued in 2016 and like i said, worked first attempt at the Taiwan eGate....

PaclantFlyer Jan 11, 2018 9:53 am


Originally Posted by Bear4Asian (Post 29278768)
I’ve tried to use my passport in eGate when I entered Taiwan late last year and when I left Taiwan today. As you can see upthread I had @ 5 experts try to use my passport in eGate multiple times and it never worked. They each tried multiple times and it never worked. When I left today, I tried the trick about lining up the passport with the upper left red light. Didn’t work. Then two eGate personnel tried multiple times. Never worked. So my passport is zero for around 25 or so. They were aware of the issue, apologized profusely and suggested the problem might be created by the crease or wrinkles in the bottom of the passport. But it didn’t seem there was any real confidence that they knew how to correct the issue.

My passport is nine years old. Does anyone of you have a passport that old that has worked? Sigh.

My passport is on the order of 7-8 years old and contains a crease in the machine-readable area pointed out to me by the immigration staff when they failed to get it to read.
When I got it to work, the left edge of the passport was aligned with the left edge of the left red light (covering it) and the top edge was against the top of the reader.

Majuki Jan 11, 2018 4:32 pm


Originally Posted by Bear4Asian (Post 29278768)
My passport is nine years old. Does anyone of you have a passport that old that has worked? Sigh.​


Originally Posted by PaclantFlyer (Post 29279521)
When I got it to work, the left edge of the passport was aligned with the left edge of the left red light (covering it) and the top edge was against the top of the reader.

My passport is 8 years old and has seen a lot of use, but the machine readable section doesn't have any creases. I did the alignment trick exactly as you described, PaclantFlyer, and have had zero issues. Bear4Asian, perhaps it's time to send in for a passport renewal, and you can be our test case for the passport update. :D

BlackHappy Jan 14, 2018 5:10 pm

Anyone face any issues with the lack of Taiwan stamps because of egate entry/exit? A few times on departure from Taiwan, the check-in agent was really confused because he couldn’t find the entry stamp. After explaining to him the situation, everything was fine. (No big deal).

yesterday, I flew TSA-SHA and got stuck at the China side for a bit. Customs agents kept asking for my other ID (I use Us passport with Visa) and I said I didn’t have any (which is true). They assumed that since I didn’t have Taiwan stamps, I must have a Taiwan passport or another passport. After a gathering of supervisors, they let me pass. (Ended up all right, but I can see this potentially being an issue in the future).

Majuki Jan 15, 2018 12:44 am


Originally Posted by BlackHappy (Post 29292933)
Anyone face any issues with the lack of Taiwan stamps because of egate entry/exit? A few times on departure from Taiwan, the check-in agent was really confused because he couldn’t find the entry stamp. After explaining to him the situation, everything was fine. (No big deal).

yesterday, I flew TSA-SHA and got stuck at the China side for a bit. Customs agents kept asking for my other ID (I use Us passport with Visa) and I said I didn’t have any (which is true). They assumed that since I didn’t have Taiwan stamps, I must have a Taiwan passport or another passport. After a gathering of supervisors, they let me pass. (Ended up all right, but I can see this potentially being an issue in the future).

I've departed from Taiwan twice since using the e-Gate, both times on flights to Japan on JAL. The first time - and I had posted about that earlier - the ticketing agent thumbed through my passport, looking for an entry stamp. The most recent ones I have are from three years ago. She asked for my ARC or APRC, which I don't have. After saying, "I have e-Gate for Global Entry. It is a new program," she seemed satisfied. Checking in for the second flight on JAL didn't get a second glance from the ticketing agent. The only issue the second time was an attendant who thought I was a confused visitor in the wrong line while waiting for to use an e-Gate. I said, "I have e-Gate for Global Entry," and didn't face further issues.

I haven't traveled from Taiwan to Mainland China directly, so I can't comment on the process. Is it common practice for passport control in the mainland to match entry/exit stamps on flights from Taiwan?

mlin32 Jan 16, 2018 7:07 am

So eGate worked for me upon entry, but not upon exit. When it read my passport exiting, it said I needed to fill out an arrival card. Well, considering I entered using eGate, I wouldn't have filled one out.

Passport control officer shrugged it off....."sorry our programming just isn't very good thesedays".

Kind of irritating; the whole point of paying the (not insubstantial) fee is for it to work.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 4:03 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.